Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

OT: Oil Change

Posts

OT: Oil Change

#1

OT: Oil Change

Stuart Johnson

According to the oil change places the oil should be changed every 3000 miles. My question is does oil go bad? I have a 98 Dodge Ram that gets driven around 500 a year. Is there a reason I should change the oil based on the calendar rather than mileage?

Re: OT: Oil Change

#2

yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The additives package can age depending on the details of what they are. My daughter the polymer chemist recently worked on a synthetic oil project. The consultant she worked with told her that modern synthetic oil itself would last 20,000 miles. Additives could vary. The oil change schedule recommended on my new car is 10,000 miles with synthetic oil.

I think I recall the Car Talk people recommending 5000 miles for regular oil, or once a year.

I have a similar situation to yours and I change oil once a year. I change it myself so it is cheaper to do. In your case I might change the oil but not the filter every year, changing the filter every other year.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#3

Re: OT: Oil Change

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

Yep, Oil doesn't "go bad" at that mileage but does become contaminated, often with water, gasoline etc. You probably have much more contamination then the normal driver because obviously you put far less miles on your vehicle. Normal water condensation and fuel are boiled off when the vehicle is ran until the engine and oil is heated up during normal longer trips. Often an engine that is used for short trips only may show full when checked only to be driven on a long trip and drop to a quart low within 50 miles or so. This indicates that one quart in the oil pan was contaminates (water and fuel). I used to see that when my mothers car was taken on a trip, as she normally only drove locally.

Normal oil breakdown (usually in 5k / 10k miles) is caused by failure of the additives which are added at the refiners to make the oil viscosity stable at temperatures, reduce wear and deposits etc.. This is not an issue with the low mileage you drive.

When I was a young man I looked at used cars in the city's in northern Indiana, often a very low mileage car, say a 5 year old car with 10K miles would actually have rust on the oil dip stick above the oil level mark. Often these cars were in far worse shape mechanically then cars with 50 ~ 60k mile due to the stop / start, long idling driving manner of the city cars.

In your case I would not use an expensive oil, but would have the oil and filter changed in the fall and spring. Pretty minor cost to prevent excess engine wear and other issues like lifters hanging up etc..

Re: OT: Oil Change

#4

Re: OT: Oil Change

Grant Smith

Hi Stuart,

Most owners manuals I have read have a mileage limit and a time limit on motor oil.

It isn't that the oil goes bad, rather it is the contaminants it can pick up from a vehicle sitting for long periods. Obviously, the internals of an engine are steel, aluminum, cast iron, and other metals. Each of these metals corrode when in contact with moisture. Over time, oil runs off of the internals, letting moisture get to bare metals. That corrosion may be washed in to the oil as a long idle engine is started. So you would then have iron oxide, Aluminum oxide, and some degree of moisture in the oil (at least until it gets up to temperature). Freeze thaw cycles can introduce lots of moisture to the crankcase, and therefore oil as well.

If you talk to a mechanic (not an entry level service tech at the oil change or tire specialist place), they will likely tell you to change your oil and filter at least annually, even if the manual doesn't tell you to do so. This is to help clean the above described contaminants out of the crankcase.

Today's engines are using synthetic oils. Manufacturers are designing engines to use synthetic oils because it has a lower viscosity, which means less resistance to moving parts and thus better fuel mileage. Secondly, most owners like the longer time between oil changes. There is some debate about what is better for longevity, but most are coming down on the side of synthetic oils being superior to conventional oil.

Any master mechanic will tell you that a vehicle left idle for long periods, especially if left outside or even on a dirt floor inside, will have as many if not more problems than the same vehicle that is regularly driven. My experience also confirms this.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: OT: Oil Change

#5

Re: OT: Oil Change

Tony-Memphis

Well, I have never subscribed to the popular oil change myths. My 01 truck has been sitting for 4 years, less than 500 a year as well, 120k miles or so and I haven't changed the oil in probably six years or so. I used synthetic but the mechanic that replaced the intake gasket used conventional (that is what is still in it). It still cranks and runs just fine. To qualify, I am a mechanical engineer, spent the first 8 years of my career designing performance valve train components (NASCAR, NHRA, street, etc.). The truck doesn't leak or smoke much at all either. That engine will outlast the rest of the truck I'm sure - and I'll probably never change the oil again! Chevy 4.3 V6, btw - nothing special (my last Chevy - long story).

Tony

Re: OT: Oil Change

#6

good advice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Now and then the car should be driven to get the engine hot for a while. On my seldom driven truck I give it a good run at least once a month.

Engines are sealed up better now days. I never see any evidence of water condensation in the oil in my situation. This better sealing is one reason engines last forever now days.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#7

Re: OT: Oil Change - Thanks

Stuart Johnson

From the majority of the answers it sounds like the oil doesn't go bad but does get contaminated. I guess I'll go ahead and change it and then worry about it again in a few years. I'm not too worried about it lasting another 100M miles.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#8

Re: OT: Oil Change - Thanks

paul in AZ

Ha! I am also not worried about lasting another 100K miles

Seriously, with a seldom driven car motor oil is less of a potential problem than the fuel.

If you are not going to drive it for any length of time consider adding a fuel stabilizer to the gas tank.

I have a '71 280SL w/190+K miles that gets used a little in the winter and parked for summer [no A/C] with stabilizer in a full tank of gas.

I also use Mobil 1 and change it every couple of years.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#9

Re: OT: Oil Change

John McGaw

Oil, like virtually everything else, will eventually go 'bad'. That said, 3,000 miles is really too frequent unless the vehicle is being used hard under the worst conditions. For a vehicle which sits unused for long periods I'd certainly consider changing the oil & filter at least every other years if it hasn't gotten up to 5K. I've been doing an oil & filter change on all of my vehicles at 5,000 for decades now and they've all held up well and had good compression after up to 15 years of use. BTW, I don't spring for synthetic oil -- when the changes are being done at 5,000 it would be wasteful.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#10

Re: OT: Oil Change

AZ in Colorado Springs

I change my oil on the 5000s -- pick-up truck due next at 255k, Durango due next at 200k. It's very easy to tell, with a glance, when it's due, and if you're a little off, the average remains 5k miles between oil changes. Don't forget the lube at the same time.

I think the oil change shops say 3 months or 3k miles for their own financial well being

Re: OT: Oil Change

#11

Re: OT: Oil Change

Bill Howatt

I don't think it is just the oil-change shops, manufacturer's owners manuals may have the same recommendation. However, that may also be to increase service traffic since cars have far less regular maintenance requirements than years ago. When my father had his garage way back when, we did spark plugs, points and condensers, carburetor cleanings, generator (yes, generator) brushes, and other things that today aren't an issue at all.

Note that what most consider regular day-to-day driving puts you into the category that requires more frequent oil changes if the manual has a light use or heavy use categories.

Bill

Re: OT: Oil Change

#12

Here's the problem....

Barry Irby

If you change the oil too often, time wise or miles wise, you can't tell.

If you don't change it often enough, it might be a disaster.

Re: OT: Oil Change

#13

Joe Bradshaw

Re: Here's the problem....

Joe Bradshaw

I had a Mercedes SLK 280 and the oil change interval was 13,000 miles. It would start giving me notices30 days before the service was due and then count down.

Joe