Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question
Grant Smith
Hi Lee,
Good to see you back here. I always enjoyed your "company".
I cant speak to brush on products much, but I can say I have found a good, durable finish solution with Minwax wipe on poly. I use satin, or sometimes gloss followed by satin for more build or on figured wood. Since you mentioned Minwax, I thought I'd chime in.
Why wipe on? For me, it allows me to apply a very nice "in the wood" finish in an easy manner that fits within my short bursts of time in the shop. How I do it:
-If I want to pop the figure or add an amber tone I can begin with BLO or waterlox, which can add to the rich look of some woods and figured components
-I use the blue shop rags that come on the paper towel rolls. Some are wary of them, but I have found they work well and are as durable as I need. They don't bleed blue dye, despite the warnings of some. I buy them about 12 to a package at Sams club. Available elsewhere in boxes, or individual rolls.
- I fold the rag twice so it is square, then once more. In one gloved hand I mold it so it will hold some wipe on poly and saturate the towel.
-Wipe on all surfaces (except inside drawers and drawer bottoms). If your project is larger than ---say a night stand, then break it up in to components to prevent drying.
-After about five minutes, take two new rags and wipe off the excess until the surface is smooth. If the wipe off towel is grabbed by the poly drying too fast, just rewipe with the applicator rag and then immediately wipe it off.
-As soon as you have "wiped off", you can reapply more finish using your saturated towel. Repeat wiping on and off until you have a nice finish with the hand rubbed "in the wood" look.
-I usually apply about six coats, and usually over about three days. Maybe two coats to three coats between allowing it to cure overnight, though I have actually gone start to finish in one session with no issues.
-When done, you can rub it out with 0000 steel wool and follow with wax if you like, but it isn't necessary if you buff the last coat with your wipe off towels.
-Cleanup is to simply lay your towels out flat on the floor of the shop until they harden, then throw them away.
Why I like it:
-Easy, can be done in a shop with other dust makers going on simultaneously without issues
-No sanding back between coats, no dust nibs, no brushes or sprayers to clean, no respirator.
-Show quality finish used by a few pros I know and learned it from
-Easily repaired later if necessary
-Easy to repair flaws found after the first coat goes on. Just wipe it dry and re-sand
-Fast, good finish for tight deadlines
-No brushes to buy, maintain
-My wife and I an work together on a larger project and get it done faster. One wipes on, one wipes off, following each other around the project.
-I can think of no easier finish to apply for a retired hobbyist that is more fool proof
I just took a headboard to our local woodworking club with a mere two coats preceded by BLO, and everyone was commenting on the finish quality (which is really a function of the sanding effort beforehand). That kind of says it all.
Where to use something else:
-table tops or high wear objects might be better off with a brush or spray on product, since a build is easy to achieve that way and more appropriate.
-I have used General Finishes "Arm-R-seal" and "Arm-R-Coat" together for table top finishes. Brushed on, sanded back as necessary to remove nibs and flatten. Great product for a durable build finish.
-Each time I have presented this here, there are some who declare that it wont work well, or complain that the blue rags will ruin things or bleed color or some such. In all cases, I am betting they haven't tried it.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa