Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

Posts

Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#1

Lee Grindinger

Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

Lee Grindinger

Hi folks, I'm dabbling in woodworking again. I've been out of the loop for long enough that my old favorite varnish, McCloskey's Heirloom is gone so I'm forced to choose between Cabot's and Minwax's polyurethanes. Not having the data sheets I was wondering which you folks would choose, the gloss will be satin.

Thanks!

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#2

Lee Grindinger

Oh, and has anyone tried Franklin 5176

Lee Grindinger

Has anyone tried Franklin 5176 Cold Press Glue for veneering in a vacuum press? How is the bleed through, sandability, and transparency to clear finishes?

Again, thanks!

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#3

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

John Veerkamp

Lee, Can't help with the questions but it is Good to see you on the forum again. Are you somewhat fixed in abode that you can do some more WW?

JohnV

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#4

Lee Grindinger

We're back home in Montana

Lee Grindinger

We've been back here for a few years after travelling for 5 after my 'retirement', I am doing some home improvements and easing back into making sawdust..., just for us and possibly friends and never again will I work at the level I worked during my career, those days are gone. I still have my carving tools and may, may, pull those out again at some point but they are still safely stored. My workshop serves many purposes now and we're acquiring a few basic woodworking tools again.

Thanks for asking.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#5

Re: We're back home in Montana

Martin S.

You should teach classes. I am sure several woodworking schools would love to have you. You could teach a couple classes a year, and pass on your knowledge to the next generation.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#6

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

David Yoho

Hi Lee, been a while. Since it sounds like you need a polyurethane, I've always used Minwax because it's so easy to come by locally. I can't speak about the Cabot's because I've never used it.

Whenever I don't need the bullet proof protection of a poly, my go-to varnishes are either the Waterlox (medium sheen) or General Finishes Arm-R-Seal. I like the GF varnish a little better because there isn't the amount of odor after application and it doesn't cost as much as the Waterlox.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#7

I use varnish finishes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You didn't say what you were finishing. If a dining room table I would use a urethane for its durability. But they are not all created equal and manufacturers reformulate without notice. When I need a urethane varnish I go to places that sell them and do a finger nail test for hardness on the test pieces they invariably have on display. Pick the hardest. They all must be thinned to flow out even and not build a heavy "plastic" looking coating. Seal coat 50/50 and top coat about 1 part thinner to 2 or 3 parts varnish.

For chests of drawers, and the like, an alkyd varnish could be better. Again, they differ widely. The traditional one is Pratt and Lambert 38 if you can find it. I don't like the Benjamine Moore. The luster looks odd. It is not bright as a good varnish should be.

I am experimenting with General Finishes Arm-R-Seal. I like the luster. It is already thin so it flows level and does not build a heavy coat. It can be wiped on. It dries hard for a durable finish. Have not experimented with rubbing it out because it dried so level I didn't need to grind it flat.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#8

Lee Grindinger

You're very kind, Martin. Thank you


Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#9

Lee Grindinger

David, Bill, thanks

Lee Grindinger

I doubt there is much difference between Minwax and Cabot so I'll probably pick the prettier can. :D

Lee

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#10

There almost surely is a difference

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Polyurethane just describes how the molecules in part of the finish components are hooked together. It says nothing about what these constituents are. I see large differences in the hardness of "polyurethane" finishes. There could also be differences in luster of the film (I am talking about inherent luster, not the luster resulting from delusterants) and how much the cured film yellows with age.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#11

Lee Grindinger

Do you know what the difference is?

Lee Grindinger

Cabot or Minwax?

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#12

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

William Duffield

Welcome back, Lee.

I can't help you much with your poly questions. I've only used it once in 10 years, and only out of necessity. I was away from the shop, and MinWax PolyShades was all I could get. I applied it in a garage with temperatures up to 115° and high Florida* summer humidity, to a kitchen table top. It has held up very well, and my mother really likes the color and the way it performs.

* Sorry, my experience won't help you much on the Yellowstone river.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#13

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

Grant Smith

Hi Lee,

Good to see you back here. I always enjoyed your "company".

I cant speak to brush on products much, but I can say I have found a good, durable finish solution with Minwax wipe on poly. I use satin, or sometimes gloss followed by satin for more build or on figured wood. Since you mentioned Minwax, I thought I'd chime in.

Why wipe on? For me, it allows me to apply a very nice "in the wood" finish in an easy manner that fits within my short bursts of time in the shop. How I do it:

-If I want to pop the figure or add an amber tone I can begin with BLO or waterlox, which can add to the rich look of some woods and figured components

-I use the blue shop rags that come on the paper towel rolls. Some are wary of them, but I have found they work well and are as durable as I need. They don't bleed blue dye, despite the warnings of some. I buy them about 12 to a package at Sams club. Available elsewhere in boxes, or individual rolls.

- I fold the rag twice so it is square, then once more. In one gloved hand I mold it so it will hold some wipe on poly and saturate the towel.

-Wipe on all surfaces (except inside drawers and drawer bottoms). If your project is larger than ---say a night stand, then break it up in to components to prevent drying.

-After about five minutes, take two new rags and wipe off the excess until the surface is smooth. If the wipe off towel is grabbed by the poly drying too fast, just rewipe with the applicator rag and then immediately wipe it off.

-As soon as you have "wiped off", you can reapply more finish using your saturated towel. Repeat wiping on and off until you have a nice finish with the hand rubbed "in the wood" look.

-I usually apply about six coats, and usually over about three days. Maybe two coats to three coats between allowing it to cure overnight, though I have actually gone start to finish in one session with no issues.

-When done, you can rub it out with 0000 steel wool and follow with wax if you like, but it isn't necessary if you buff the last coat with your wipe off towels.

-Cleanup is to simply lay your towels out flat on the floor of the shop until they harden, then throw them away.

Why I like it:

-Easy, can be done in a shop with other dust makers going on simultaneously without issues

-No sanding back between coats, no dust nibs, no brushes or sprayers to clean, no respirator.

-Show quality finish used by a few pros I know and learned it from

-Easily repaired later if necessary

-Easy to repair flaws found after the first coat goes on. Just wipe it dry and re-sand

-Fast, good finish for tight deadlines

-No brushes to buy, maintain

-My wife and I an work together on a larger project and get it done faster. One wipes on, one wipes off, following each other around the project.

-I can think of no easier finish to apply for a retired hobbyist that is more fool proof

I just took a headboard to our local woodworking club with a mere two coats preceded by BLO, and everyone was commenting on the finish quality (which is really a function of the sanding effort beforehand). That kind of says it all.

Where to use something else:

-table tops or high wear objects might be better off with a brush or spray on product, since a build is easy to achieve that way and more appropriate.

-I have used General Finishes "Arm-R-seal" and "Arm-R-Coat" together for table top finishes. Brushed on, sanded back as necessary to remove nibs and flatten. Great product for a durable build finish.

-Each time I have presented this here, there are some who declare that it wont work well, or complain that the blue rags will ruin things or bleed color or some such. In all cases, I am betting they haven't tried it.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#14

Alan Young

Welcome back

Alan Young

I used it in 2004 in a cold press setting on a set of table tops


After Montana fest I bought a vacuum press and used Titebond Liquid Hide Glue . A year ago or so I tried

Unibond 1- A one part adhesive- pretty good on bleed through properties.


and I've now just been experimenting with Dark Titebond II-if panels are smaller-



used on Sapele-a generally "dark" species-any bleed through seems to sand out well

-Alan

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#15

Alan Young

Unibond 1 Project

Alan Young

Lee- I used the Unibond 1 on this credenza with Sapele veneer-I tinted Seal Coat shellac for the finish because the framing was Mahogany and I needed to tone finish to bring woods together-





Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#16

Lee Grindinger

Wow, thanks Grant!

Lee Grindinger

Finishing is the single biggest bugaboo many woodworkers experience, if you have found a system that works stick with it!

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#17

Lee Grindinger

Thanks, Alan

Lee Grindinger

Good info, thanks!

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#18

Lee Grindinger

Unibond 1 Project- nice work, good stuff


Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#19

Well . .

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

it's about d... time!

"Gone" too long (we've heard rumors ;) )

Nice to have you back.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#20

Lee Grindinger

Thanks Mark, the rumors are, ummm..., false


Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#21

Great post, Thanks


Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#22

Re: Oh, and has anyone tried Franklin 5176

jessecloud

I tried Franklin cold press a few times. Worked fine, but nothing special. But I might not be a good reviewer as I hardly ever get bleed through. IMO lots of woodworkers put way too much glue under veneer. Doesn't take much as long as it has consistently good coverage of the substrate.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#23

PS

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When I used to use oil finish top coats, I had a preference for Absolute's LastnLast gloss poly. It seemed to level better than Minwax, especially with 5% naptha added. Had to thin separately when using naptha and not return any to the can as it would gel the whole batch in about 2 weeks time. Got pretty good at estimating how much I'd need for a piece. MS doesn't evaporate as fast but the naptha seemed to erase the brush marks better.

Hand applying I used good foam brushes.

Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#24

no and some glue information

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

no, but it could involve the factors I enumerated above, or others, ......or not. You can be certain that the composition is not equivalent, for better or worse, or indifferent.

The hardness, if that is important, is easy to test by trying to dent the samples in the store with a thumb nail. Luster can also be compared from store samples. How much it yellows can only be assessed by someone that has a few years experience and then one does not know if the manufacturer has changed the formulation. You might get some assessment of color by peaking in the can.

if none of these factors are important then shop by price.

BTW, the Mack Headley shop in Winchester uses plain white glue for veneering everything. When I vacuum veneered some crotch mahogany there the glue came pouring through the vertical grain, sanded smooth, and had no effect I could tell on staining (water soluble stain, oil and shellac). They like the fact that it remains a bit flexible. I have seen no cracking of the crotch over time.


Re: Wow, been gone a while, varnish question

#25

wipe on route

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If considering a wipe on finish Fine Woodworking has a review of many wipe on products.

Gerald Mayberry, see his Period slant top gallery desk in Member Gallery, uses Minwax wipe on as does a professional jewelry box maker in our club.