Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Cherry drop leaf table repair

Posts

Cherry drop leaf table repair

#1

Cherry drop leaf table repair

Barney in NJ

I ran across this table and thought I could use the wood, but upon closer inspection it seems that it is very nice and worth to be repaired.


The table is made of three solid panels, the center panel is 21in.

It has a crack down the center as well as several cracks on the side.




The drawer shows nice dovetails, Bottom panel has a t&g joint 3/4 down the depth that is almost open. The end is pinned. The pull looks like a replacement. At least it appears out of proportion.






The screws look partially handmade. They have a similar rust pattern. Hinges look handmade to me, too.




The leafs are kept up by a board that rotate out.



You can see one of the screws that holds the top.

The top was fixed to the apron with 4 large screws, and additionally with glued blocks. When I got the table, the blocks were already detached from the top, and the screws were somewhat lose. They are also slightly bent. All the cracks look very clean and recent. The center cut shows signs of previous attempt to glue it with hide glue.

Wouldn't this method of attachment cause the split? The screws have a bit of wiggle room, maybe 1/8in. Or maybe the addition of the blocks caused the split?


My plan is to glue the splits with hide glue. I might want to de-rust the screws and hinges (electrolysis). But how should I re-attach the top? Using the screws only? Enlarge the screw holes in the apron?

Or use the center glue block and add a screw? I would like to keep everything as original as possible.

Thanks for any advice.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#2

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have never seen a top attached with glue blocks but typically tops were attached with pocket screws. I would have no reluctance to reattach with the screws.

I believe a lot of these old pieces split because insufficiently dry lumber was used in construction. Others believe it is something to do with central heating.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#3

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Barney,

There are enough antique shops in this state so it might be good if you talk to one about the piece before you embark on a program that wipes out any real value in your piece. Definitely leave the hinges and screws alone, rust and all. You might also consider some butterfly inlays across your cracks (from the under side) as it sounds like you've got a piece of wood in the top that likes to move and break glue joints.

Once repaired, I'd look to affix the top with clips with a single screw in the middle of each end so that the top can expand or contract in both directions away from the center point. Unless, of course, such a modern technique would be po-pooed by your antique guy.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#4

Glue joints do not....

Brian Roberts

break by some kind of magic.

They break, and the wood splits in other than glued areas, for one reason....the wood is constrained by incorrect construction methods so that it can't expand and contract with seasonal humidity changes.

Regardless of the value of the piece....if you repair it and do not allow for movement across the grain it will fail again.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#5

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Barney in NJ

The cracks are straight and go together without clamping. I think that butterflies will not add much. I rather modify the attachment.

The cracks on the side are most likley caused by abuse, like somebody dropped it.

Shouldn't the rust be addressed?

Thanks

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#6

Not

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

before you speak to someone knowledgeable for advice on valuation. Collectors of Old Stuff can be weird in that they want the piece, with all its "warts" preserved just the way you found it.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#7

more ideas

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You will likely get a different opinion on what to do to an antique from every person you ask.

My personal philosophy is to decide why I own it in the first place. Am I going to sell it or use it? If I am going to sell it then I need to worry about what the buyer wants. If it is going to join my household its looks is going to please me, not some antique dealer or buyer of varying whims.

I have discussed furniture conservation with the lab at Winterthur, not implying that the piece in question merits furniture conservation as opposed to other remedies for it ills. The current philosophy in museum conservation is to stabilize and restore the piece using techniques that are reversible and/or do not irreversibly alter the material.

For example rust. The old way was electrolysis. But this technique irreversibly changed the chemistry of the surface of the metal. Now days rust is removed by sand blasting with very mild abrasive or brushing. A museum piece is not going to be left rusty.

An alternative to museum conservation is to make it look as good as you want it to look for your use of it. Personally, I would rip through the splits and reglue them if practical. Every table you will ever look at from the 18th and 19th century will be fastened on with pocket screws and that is how I would put the top back on. Then I would refinish the piece with a finish compatible with my intended use of the table. The fact that I might have reduced the current value of the piece according to current fashion notions (which have changed and will likely change in the future) by $XX would not enter my mind.

BTW there is a shop near Lancaster that does high end furniture restoration. They put legs back on, fix splits, refinish, repair veneer, etc. They do work for Christies and the Keno Brothers, those advocates of "don't mess with it" on the Antiques Road Show. The true story is don't mess with furniture that doesn't need messing with because it remains in near new condition. The rest benefits from some work to make it useful and attractive, while preserving what is left.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#8

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

the table deserves a turned cherry drawer knob. The glass one is awful!

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#9

Re: PS

Barney in NJ

> The glass one is awful!

I'm glad you say that.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#10

Re: more ideas

Barry Irby

I agree with the don't mess with it thought until you figure out what messing with it will do to the value. What is the value anyway? To Whom? You? You planing to sell it? Use It?

I also agree with improving the attachment of the top. And with replacing the horrible knob.

I was faced with a vaguely similar decision. My Grandmother had a table built of walnut that came from the family farm. All my life I thought it was very elegant and ate many Christmas and Thanks giving dinners on it. My cousin inherited it but it was exhibiting its age and they asked me to fix it. I reluctantly agreed. They brought it to me and I was horrified. Not nearly as elegant or well made as I remembered. Its a big drop leaf table. It was built by a carpenter. Had door hinges for the gate legs. Many of the glue joints were failing. The taper on the legs was clumsy. The hinges were poorly made and poorly installed. It was like finding out you first girl friend has gotten old and fat, crushing the fond memories. I discussed it with a friend and rebuilt the table as it should have been. It was not an antique, but was probably 70 years old. I never told them and apparently they did not notice.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#11

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Barney in NJ

Thanks everybody for your feedback.

The table will be for our own use. Collectors won't enter into the matter.

I have managed so far to glue the top with hide glue. Unfortunatey it is slow going, because I cant afford much shop time.

Now a question about the finish. The top is still quite nice and I think one or two coats of shellac might be good.

However the base looks not as good. My original thought was that someone tried to strip the base, but left half of the finish on. It is not shellac since alcohol is not doing anything. I tried turpentine, which is not making a dent either. Here are two snapshots, one shows the front of the drawer around the knob, the other is a part of the leg. What could that finish be? Should I remove it or try to even it out with shellac?

Thanks.




Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#13

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....which is vastly easier to strip than lacquer or shellac

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#14

And......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would be using a wipe on varnish for the top.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#15

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Barney in NJ

With the varnish on the base in such a bad state I thought about stripping it and re-finishing. I stripped a small hidden patch on the leg, and it turns out the wood is maple. This would mean I will have to re-dye or stain the legs after stripping.

It looks like everything except the long aprons is painted with a reddish / orange stain. Even the cherry top, short aprons and drawer front. The long aprons are very low grade knotty pine witha dark dye.

Here is a picture:


What would you do with the base?

- leave as is

- try to even out the crackled varnish with shellac

- strip, then refinish, using similar stain on the legs / aprons to get a faux cherry?

Thanks

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#16

Ellis Walentine

Suggestions

Ellis Walentine

What I would do with this table is take it entirely apart, strip all the old finish off with a gentle stripper (not ZipStrip or one of the heavy-duty ones with methylene chloride), glue up anything that still needs it (cracks, splits, loose M&T joints), stain it with a dye stain to an authentic looking color (probably a honey color), finish it with two or three coats of wiping varnish followed by two coats of polyurethane on the top (or regular varnish, for wear protection), and then put it back together with pocket screws, making sure that your screw holes in the apron have enough clearance for the top to move in whichever direction is likely in the course of a year.

How's that for a sentence.

Other notes and some wild speculations:

-A wooden knob would be nice, Shaker style, screwed with a wood screw from inside the drawer.

-Are you sure this is a cherry table? If the base is maple, I suspect the top may be also. The design appears to be that of early production furniture, probably not a high-value antique, but it can be quite serviceable as a utility table in your home if the style complements yours. At any rate, I don't think I'd agonize too much about preserving the original top attachment method or hardware. Even figure eight connectors or steel Z-clips would seem acceptable, and they'd allow for movement of the top.

-The screws look like they hark to sometime in the mid-to-late 1800s, FWIW.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#17

Re: Suggestions

Barney in NJ

Thanks for your suggestions.

The top is cherry. It was visible at the cracks. Same for the drawer front.

Wooden knob is on the list.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#18

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Barney

The table is finally finished. Top is glued with hide glue. The legs were very lightly sanded at locations of high varnish buildup. Then shellac, amber on top and garnet for the legs to even out the difference in tone.

Used Van Dyck christals to blend in the glue line. I ovalized the pocket holes a bit to attach the top. I'm very happy how it turned out.





Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#19

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Table looks nice. The drawer knob....not so nice.

Re: Cherry drop leaf table repair

#20

Ellis Walentine

Great looking table, Barney

Ellis Walentine

I like those scrolled corners, too.

Thanks for posting.

Ellis Walentine, Host