Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Design question

Posts

Design question

#1

Design question

tom

I started making a trestle table for our dining room. The base is solid cherry. I had thought to use a figured maple for the top. After going to a local Amish wood yard and seeing the prices I am wondering about something different.

What if I used clear white pine and finished it in a "honey" pine finish.

Thoughts?

Re: Design question

#2

Re: Wood Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Pine, naturally, is way softer than maple so it will dent far easier. That said, I've seen some lovely pine tables. Keep in mind that high grade White Pine ain't all that cheap.

I'd suggest you go to WoodFinder here on the WC home page and do some searching for wood from different yards within a reasonable distance. I've had a few contacts with Amish yards, haven't found them to be notably inexpensive for their stock, and did better at other places when I've had to buy wood.

Re: Design question

#3

Re: Design question

Dick Coers

As far as I am concerned, the cost of wood is the small part of a piece of furniture. Considering the amount of labor put into it, and the longevity of use on a family heirloom. You would have to be happy with a "character" surface on a pine table as it will show a lot of wear very quickly. Especially if you have kids or grand kids! I'd choose a standard maple top a lot faster than pine.

Re: Design question

#4

Re: Design question

William Duffield

What about looking for a different sawyer? You should start with WoodFinder. There's a link at the top of the page. Unless you want a really rustic look, I agree with the others: use something harder than pine.

Re: Design question

#5

Clint Searl

It only costs a bit more to go 1st class


Re: Design question

#6

Re: Design question

Robin Corell in Atascadero

I think pine tops work better with painted bases. With a cherry base you need need either cherry for the top or something nicer, stay away from similar colored woods and go with something substantially darker or lighter.

Re: Design question

#7

Choose the best

Clementine

There are always buyers for the best.

Donald J. Trump

Trump: The Art of the Deal (New York: Ballantine, 1987), 203.

Re: Design question

#8

two toned furniture-not

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most of the furniture I see that employs two wood species looks contrived to be trendy and novel.

Cherry is less expensive now than it has been and the quality has improved. Build a cherry table. It will look good 100 years from now when this two toned furniture notion has passed.

This is a sensitive issue for me right now. Son in law wants me to build a dresser. He saw some two toned maple/walnut dovetail example and decided he wanted a two toned dresser instead of just boring nontrendy walnut. We visited the internet to find maple-walnut furniture and eventually he became persuaded that maple-walnut was best as an ice cream and not a dresser.

While I am ranting I might as well rant against the current fashion of furniture being all about the wood and not the design. For example, figured wood should be an accent and not the main show. I am reminded of the saying "gilding the lily".

Re: Design question

#9

Re: Design question

Barry Irby

I generally agree with those who say not to use pine and with Bill's rant on two toned furniture. However, my son and I built a cherry table for him with a top made of two bookmatched boards and the base was osage orange. At first the base was that wonderful but shocking yellow. It has mellowed to the color of Tea or bourbon and is no longer shocking. Nobody but a woodworker would think it was anything but dark cherry.

I also agree with those who point out the cost spread out over the rest of your life is trivial. After all, it's only for you and your family. Build something that will make you proud, not something you will have to make excuses for. (DAMHIKT, I have both.)

Re: Design question

#10

Good advice...

John in NM

I would stick with cherry for the top too, it'd be a lot cheaper than figured maple and a lot more durable than pine.

The only exception I'd make to the non-two tone rule is that a cherry table base can do ok with a maple top. Sometimes a cherry top with a walnut base can also look good, but its usually too contrasty for my taste.

Re: Design question

#11

Re: two toned furniture-not

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Another consideration is the figure in the wood. Some woods have what I call a "loud figure". Pine, oak, ash are examples. They have pronounced figures in their grain patterns. Other woods have "quiet figure". Cherry, walnut and others have less pronounced grain patterns. To my eye, mixing a "loud" figure top with a "quiet" figure cherry base might present a visual conflict. Whatever wood you choose for the top, I might suggest you consider harmony with the grain patterns of the base. T.

Re: Design question

#12

I vote Cherry base & Cherry top too


Re: Design question

#13

veneer the top

Joseph Piotrowski

to reduce cost you can always veneer the top.

sometimes a single wood and color works. sometimes two contrasting woods work, sometimes a small contrasting accent works, sometime a tonal difference in two woods work. the grain pattern matters.

as i study objects that really appeal to me. i like some over others, I see lots of great works that appeal to me but some i like more than others. i ask; is it shape? color, proportions? grain patterns? all of these work in concert to make something better than the other.

sure i have my opinion on this. such as i think a contrasting full figured maple top is a bit overwhelming. unless you do some book matching, maybe frame it with cherry. when it comes to contrasting colors, i like pieces where the color is used to separate the object into two distinct sections. i find the lighter piece is more in isolation visually and therefore should have something other than color to dazzle the eye. some curvature, interesting grain, beveling etc

of course these are my predisposes and maybe no one else's :)

good luck!

Re: Design question

#14

About the only two toned wood pieces I like

Gary Smyth

are the old high school standby of the stacked wood turning or box. They are just something stuck in my mind. As a shop class folk piece, getting scarcer.

If two tones are still preferred, sometimes a granite or marble top serves well on a base.


Re: Design question

#15

Cherry and

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

walnut can live nicely together. I've done several that way





I did, however, blend the colors with a bit of cherry flavored Watco oil