Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Dust deputy questions.

Posts

Dust deputy questions.

#1

Dust deputy questions.

Barry Irby

I have been using my shop vac connected to my sanders. 6" by 48" belt/disk sander and switching to a ROS, etc. There is almost nothing in the drum, but the filter is completely packed and the suction reduced to nearly nothing. I can take the filter outside and clean it, but it's cold and snowy.

Would a Dust Deputy work as a prefilter? Does it capture enough of the very fine dust that clogs the filter? I have been reluctant to try it because I have a tiny shop and really don't like having the shop vac in there. I have a DC outside the shop and maybe I should use that. It seems to lack the "slurp" factor of the shop vac. Do you have a Dust Deputy or alternative and like it?

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#2

Re: Dust

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use my shop vac for the sanders (ROS & Belt), but I clean the vac with a shop vac 2-3/8 hose and brush adapted to a DC port. No going outside in the cold

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#3

Re: Dust deputy questions.

Dick Coers

I got one for Christmas (2 years ago, LOL) because I heard really good things about them. I bought a Mirka vacuum on close-out and plan on doing a vertical mounting system for the Dust Deputy on a 5 gallon bucket. I don't need more space used up with a two stage portable vac, compared to just my shop vac. The advantage of the vac is if you have an on demand switch on it. You just turn on sander and everything works. I just need to stop turning and start making flat work to inspire me to build it! Your dust collector will work well, but can be chocked down by the fines if you don't have a separator on it as well.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#4

BTW

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

I use the DC as the primary cleaner for the whole shop. I won't pick of chunks, screws, and such, buy it keeps counters, machines, and the floor clear of wood dust.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#5

Re: Dust deputy questions.

Hank Knight

Barry,

I don't know if this is the case with a Dust Deputy, but with a cyclone, the seal between the cyclone and the collection bin must be airtight. If it is not, the impeller sucks air in at the bottom and it carries the fines into the filter. I have to reseal mine every time I empty the bin and it's a PITA. If I don't get a good seal, my filters quickly clog with fine dust. You might want to check your manual to see if it talks about that.

My $.02.

Hank

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#6

JL

Re: Dust deputy questions.

JL

I've tried the Dust Deputy.

It does work and gets about 90% of the sanding dust and fines. I didn't really measure, I was just using Mike's over at his shop.

My problem is that I don't really want to invest in a rolling cart for the Dust Deputy and a shop vacuum - it does take up a bit of real estate when you figure a 5 gallon bucket w/ a Dust Deputy and a shop vacuum.

YMMV of course. If I could go vertical, I might buy one - I really have to figure out a way to roll it around.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#7

Re: Dust deputy questions.

JAMES FOLLETTE

I use the Dust Deputy which I mounted on a 55 gallon plastic trash barrel (Brute) that is on casters. It works great and keeps the filter on the shop vac fairly clean. I did have to reinforce the sides of the trash barrel because the suction would pull the sides in. Obviously I have to empty alot less frequently.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#8

Re: Dust deputy questions.

William Duffield

For a cyclone separator, you really need to use a metal trash can. They're available at Tractor Supply and Horror Freight.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#9

Re: Dust deputy questions.

William Duffield

Oneida makes one specifically to mount on top of your Festool CT. It's already completely portable, takes up no floor space, and drastically reduces the amount of dust and chips that end up in your expensive Festool dust bags. The only problem is you can't latch a stack of Systainers to the top of it.

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#10

Re: Oops, forgot the link

William Duffield


http://www.oneida-air.com/inventoryD.asp?item_no=AXD000009&CatId={6EE79B16-EB63-43E7-8F30-1E06240A24A4}

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#11

Re: Dust deputy questions.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have been using my shop vac connected to my sanders. 6" by 48" belt/disk sander and switching to a ROS, etc. There is almost nothing in the drum, but the filter is completely packed and the suction reduced to nearly nothing. I can take the filter outside and clean it, but it's cold and snowy.

Would a Dust Deputy work as a prefilter? Does it capture enough of the very fine dust that clogs the filter? I have been reluctant to try it because I have a tiny shop and really don't like having the shop vac in there. I have a DC outside the shop and maybe I should use that. It seems to lack the "slurp" factor of the shop vac. Do you have a Dust Deputy or alternative and like it?

Hi Barry

I have had the original DD attached to a Fein vacuum cleaner for about 5 or 6 years. It does a reasonable job collecting possibly about 95% of the coarser chips, but stuff still sneaks through and eventually I have to dismantle the Fein and clean it out. You can tell when this occurs as the suction drops and stops.

A retired friend of mine has a specific interest in dust collection. He was in charge of dust control in operating theatres. He absolutely hates shop vacs since he has measured as much fine dust coming out of them as going in. In fact, he will strongly argue that dust control is strangled with less than a 3 hp machine and 6" pipes. Plus it must be vented directly outdoors - better still, place the dust extractor outside - as none of the filters prevents the fine dust circulating in the shop air. It can take some hours before it can be removed.

This is one of the reasons I use handtools as much as possible. Still, I have all the big power equipment, and my dust control system is woeful at this time (2 hp Dust Extractor into 4" pipes). My saviour is all is in a double garage, and I can open the garage door and rear entry door, and blow out all the dust when the wind picks up.

I also cannot vent outdoors since I have neighbours.

The Fein finally blew up and I purchased a Festool CT26E about 2 years ago. This has more power and a better (?) HEPA filter. It was also time to look at an improved DD.

In my on-line searches I was horrified to read about static problems and Festool and the DD. It seems that the Festools are earthed differently and the standard DD is not recommended. DD brought out a second, antistatic version. This was not available in Oz. I came across the Dust Commander, which is available in anti-static construction (all anti-static items appear to be black). This is manufactured in France, and easily available on eBay. It was about the same price as the DD. Note that one needs antistatic hoses and connectors to go with this.

So far my experience with the Dust Commander has been good. It seems to create more suck than the DD, and control more dust.

The Dust Commander is attached to a 15lt screw-top storage container (for home brew), in turn attached to a Systainer, which clips onto the top of the CT26E.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Dust deputy questions.

#12

Re: Dust deputy questions.

John M in Mid Mich

I suppose it IS a solution Derek, but whereas repurposing some shop apparatus for home brewing seems a high achievement, you've done the opposite which seems terribly wrong - mein Gott! What about the brew? What next - using your pint glass for mixing dewaxed shellac?! :D