Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

New wood jointer

Posts

New wood jointer

#1

New wood jointer

Lynn Reedy

I am in the search for a new wood jointer. I am looking at a Grizzly

or a Baileigh jointer 6 inch or maybe a 8 inch. Does anyone have any

comments, pro or con, as to the quality of these two machines?

Re: New wood jointer

#2

Re: New wood jointer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Buy the longest jointer you can afford. Look at how the knives are set. Things like jack screws, or whatever, added to the cutter head that make knife alignment easier will be greatly appreciated down the road.

First check locally for used machine. They occasionally come up where I live for half new price. Other than bearings that are easy to replace there is little that can go wrong.

Re: New wood jointer

#3

Re: New wood jointer

Yoak

Lynn, I can't really compare your choices but I did have an 8" Grizzly jointer which I have, since, sold to my neighbor. It was my favorite jointer I've had. I got a replacement 12" Jet jointer and, while I appreciate the extra width, length and weight, I feel the Grizzly was a better-made and smoother-running machine. Plus, the knives were easier to change. Since these were used machines, however, the smoothness of run was, likely, related to those particular machines and maybe not design-related.

Re: New wood jointer

#4

Re: New wood jointer

Dick Coers

Very likely the exact same machine with different color paint. I'd pay even more for a vintage cast iron machine compared to new Chinese machine. "I won't buy anything from Grizzly that has an electrical cord." Terry Quiram quote that I agree with whole heartedly. Interestingly, Grizzly and I reached an agreement. I don't want to buy anything from them, they don't want to sell me anything, long story................

Re: New wood jointer

#5

Re: New wood jointer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Lynn, I do recommend that you look beyond the usual 6" and 8" machines. It is the board faces that count, not their edges.

My experience is limited to an 8" (same as the Grizzly), which I had for several years, and my current machine, a 12" Hammer combination jointer-planer, which I have had for about 3 years now. The combo has shorter beds than the 8" had, but the extra width is the reason I went down this path, and time had reassured me that this was the correct decision.

Typically, recommendations are for bed length - the longer the better - but most combination machines are long enough, unless you are in the habit of jointing 15' and longer beams. It is easy enough to support the occasional extra long board. Mostly one wants width in a jointer - at least 10". I use all of the 12" in my jointer since my bandsaw resaws 11 1/2".

Once you begin thinking this way, a 6" jointer is far too narrow, and the 8" is almost equally limited.

The question is, how does one find an affordable 10" - 12" jointer? There are two options: either find a good second-hand machine, or buy a new combination machine. The latter are more expensive than a basic jointer, but there some available that can be had reasonably inexpensively (much less than my Hammer), and for not a lot more than a jointer on its own. Keep in mind that you are after the jointer section of the combo. The planer is a bonus.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New wood jointer

#6

Re: New wood jointer

Howard Pollack

Derek, do you have the version with the spiral cutterhead or the version with straight knives. I'd like to hear your opinion of whichever you have. Thanks.

Howard

Re: New wood jointer

#7

Re: New wood jointer

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Howard

I have the Hammer A3-31 with the spiral blades.

They were advertised as a "silent head", among other things, and this was one of their attractions for me since the Delta lunchbox planer I previously owned screamed like a banshee in heat when fired up. I was too scared to use it as I wanted to remain on good terms with family and neighbours. The spiral blade version is pretty quiet. One can easily have a conversation without raising voices when it is running. The dust control is noisier.

The finish from the carbide blades is excellent. The blades are angled slightly for a slicing cut, and this has the effect of reducing the demands on the blades. The Hammer is a 4 hp machine and recommendation for the straight blade version (and this) is a 20 amp power (as with my Hammer 4400 bandsaw). The A3-31 runs very comfortably on 15 amps.

The carbide blades are very long lasting. I have had the machine about 4 years now, cut very abrasive hardwood (high levels of silica), and am on the same blade faces (note that I do this on weekends only). I have yet to turn the blades - one can do so four times (four faces) for each chip. I did turn one square some while back when a corner was chipped. That is all. This is a huge advantage over straight blades.

Change over is reasonably quick. Of course, I would expect a professional to have separate machines. For my purposes, the space saved is important, and the bed width is such a boon.

All-in-all, I am so impressed with this machine, its design, and the carbide spiral blades.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: New wood jointer

#8

Re: New wood jointer

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have nothing but good things to say about the Grizzly jointers.

I had a 6" with straight cutter blades for several years. I mistreated it badly as I had to store it in a back room of my house and we moved it outside to use it ~ carrying it by the ends of the beds. It stayed aligned and never gave me a bit of problem. Did take a long time to install and adjust the blades but I am anal about machine alignment so part of that was due to aligning to .001 on blade height.

When I built my new shop, I purchased a new Grizzly 8" jointer with the Grizzly carbide inserted spiral head. It doesn't require ANY alignment when rotating or replacing cutter inserts and has one of the longest beds for the width on the market. I agree with Bill that the longer the beds the easier it is to get good results. However I would not trade my Grizzly for any old iron of the same size.

I have a 20" stationary planer so in the event I have a board wider than 8" I knock off the high spots, either with my jointer or by hand planing. Then carefully use the planer to flatten the board. This has worked well for me.

Re: New wood jointer

#9

Re: I have the straight-knife version

Hank Knight

I got a great deal on the earlier, straight-knife model of Derek's Hammer A3-31. We agree on everything about this fantastic machine. If I were buying the machine new, I would purchase the spiral head for all the reasons Derek has mentioned: noise level, durability of the carbide and edges, easy replacement and good surface quality. Having said that, I'm satisfied with my straight-knife machine. The knives are relatively easy to change and adjust with jack screws. They produce a nice surface, even on figured wood. I recently built a chest if drawers from highly figured maple. The jointer planer did a pretty good job on the curly stuff. I had a little tearout, but it was manageable. The machine is pretty loud when surface jointing or planing wide boards. Otherwise, I think the Hammer jointer/placer combo is a fine machine. It has been a wonderful upgrade for my shop.

Re: New wood jointer

#10

Re: New wood jointer

Hank Knight

Lynn,

If you are committed to a traditional 6" jointer, I suggest you look for an older American made machine rather than one of the new machines manufactured in the Far East. The "old arn" machines are built like tanks. They are rock solid, easy to work on and preform exceptionally well. My father had a Walker Turner 6" jointer that was probably built in the 1940s. It was the best woodworking machine I have ever used. They appear on Craigslist from time to time and on eBay. You can probably pick one up for $400 or less.

My $.02

Hank

Re: New wood jointer

#11

Re: New wood jointer

Paul Blackwell

When I downsized to a new home over 5 years ago, I had to fit my woodworking shop into the basement of the new house. I sold most of my larger equipment because everything had to be carried down the stairs to the basement. I sold my 8 in. Grizzly jointer (straight knives) and purchased a 6 in. Grizzly jointer with spiral head and indexable carbide inserts. This is the smoothest cutting jointer I have ever used, even with cross-grained wood. I have been using the jointer for about five years now and have yet to rotate the inserts. I also purchased a cyclone type dust collector from Grizzly along with a combination belt/disc sander. All have performed flawlessly with no problems whatsoever. There are certainly better quality woodworking machines available, but for a non-professional, it works for me.

Re: New wood jointer

#12

Thanks to both of you


Re: New wood jointer

#13

griz parallel 8" with byrd

ronster

1.5 yrs ago I picked up the long grizzly 8" parallelogram model with regular knives. Didn't run it until I replaced the head with a byrd spiral head. Ebayed the original head & knives. Great unit and great plan by me. The fence could use a little flattening. I recently retired so now I am using the jointer nearly every day and enjoying it.

ron

Re: New wood jointer

#14

Re: New wood jointer

Tony - Memphis

I have been using a Griz 6" for 18+ years. Got off to a rough start with an issue - the fence had a lot of slop in it. Griz never was able to fix it and the local Griz folks were very unsupportive. That killed my interest in any further Griz purchases. That said, I fixed it myself and it has been a very good jointer and a good value even considering the issue. I have found the 6" cutting width to be limiting and would love to upgrade to an 8" helical insert type. Someday...

Tony