Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Water based varnish sanding

Posts

Water based varnish sanding

#1

Water based varnish sanding

tomG

I am using a water based top coat on a table top for the first time. It is Resisthane pre-catalyzed lacquer by hydrocote. http://hydrocote.com/our-products.htm

Under the Resisthane is a seal coat of 1# dewaxed shellac followed by an oil stain, followed by 3 more light coats of 1# dewaxed shellac.

Brushing it with a foam brush. The first coat looked amazing. However I think I put subsequent coats (approx 4 or 5 coats) on too think (and I perhaps could have done a more thorough job sanding between coats). The finish is super clear. But there are ridges that kind of look like brush marks parallel to the brush direction, and just a few bubbles (that I could live with). Starting to feel like a do over-- for the Resisthane . However, I'd rather do as little doing over as possible.

Wondering if I could sand back the Resisthane with an orbital sander (220 grit) instead of trying to cut it back by hand. Also wondering if there are other suggestions / guidance for getting back to a flat surface (other than "do it right the first time!").

The table to is fairly rustic (maple with some spalt, knots, etc) so it does not have to be flawless, but right now there are enough ridges (brushmarks?) that it does not look good enough in reflected light.

Thanks a lot.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#2

Depends on cure time

Dick Coers

Water based finishes dry fast, but cure slowly. Might take a month or more for it to go fully cured after all those heavy coats. If you put a RO sander on it now, you'll have little balls of finish stuck to the sandpaper almost instantly. You sure went to a lot of effort before the water based finish. Never heard of anyone putting on that many coats before the finish. I'm kinda stumped on how you should proceed.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#3

Re: Depends on cure time

tomG

It's a coffee table for my teenagers' area of the house so needs to be fairly bomb proof, hence the 4-5 coats, although it did build a lot faster than I expected.

I should have mentioned the can says it's sandable, rubbable etc after 24 hrs, which i know is unusual. However, just did a test spot on an inconspicuous area and it seemed ok

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#4

Re: Water based varnish sanding

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Tom,

You finish routine has the "right" components and will give outstanding results with a few tweeks.

1. Put your oil on first. I will guess that you've used a pigment oil like Minwax. If that first application of shellac is to control blotching like on cherry, keep it as thin as possible.

2. Allow your oil more time to cure up, at lease 24-48 hours to prevent bleeding from the grain.

3. Apply your tie coat of shellac but 1 coat of 2lb cut or 2 lighter coats of 1 lb cut will do the trick. Be careful not to build the shellac because shellac under waterborne finishes is subject to cold checking (cracks and shrinkage forming in the shellac layer) which I learned about the hard way.

4. Haven't used Resisthane, but most waterbornes specify 3 applications. Those directions usually anticipate spray finishing which is where the waterbornes really shine with an HVLP gun. If you're hand-applying, consider adding an extender to your top coats to allow the wet film more time to flow out and level. If you're getting brush strokes, you're trying to put too much on with each application.

As for your sanding question, you should be able to level out the ridges and brush marks by wet sanding with 320 or 400 paper on a flat block with water. Move with the grain and have a low-angle light set up so that you can see the shinny streaks in the valleys of the film. When those streaks are gone, your finish is level. You can continue with finer and finer abrasives and then rub out your film to whatever gloss you wish or you can apply a last thinned coat of your finish and call it done. If your sanding reveals witness marks (where you cut through one coat into the next layer), the best you can do will be another application of top coat to try to hide them.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#5

Re: Depends on cure time

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I found that a foam brush worked best the one time I used a water based finish on kitchen cabinets....in place where I could not spray.

220 is way to coarse, hand sand and follow the rest of Marks directions.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#6

flat block warning

Dick Coers

I'd only use the flat block for sanding the finish, IF, you block sanded the wood. It sounds like the wood may be "rustic", so if not flat, the block sanding will sand through the finish on the high spots and not touch the lows. You could end up sanding down to the stain if it's off too much! I'd suggest a 320 sanding sponge.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#7

Related question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I intend to spray General Finishes water-based poly on Hard Maple kitchen doors. A test board worked well, but did raise the grain. I rubbed this back with grey mesh.

I am wondering whether a sealer coat of white, unwaxed shellac (specifically, Ubeaut White Shellac) would be be helpful in regard to avoiding a raised grain. My concern is that the water-based poly was chosen specially to aid in keeping the wood as white and unyellowed as possible. Would white shellac yellow over time? If not, is it a worthwhile exercise to use as a sealer?

Regards from Perth

Derek (16 doors completed)

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#8

Re: Related question

Thomas S Stockton

Derek

I don't know about shellac but when I spray water based finish I find it best to apply two coats before I sand down the raised grain, this seems to freeze the grain in place and make it easier to sand as well not raising again.

I also find that using sandpaper and a block tends to cut and level the finish much better than the grey pads which tend to ride over bumps and defects, Although the pads work great for hard to sand areas and shapes.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#9

Re: Depends on cure time

TomD

Foam brushes are good. LV has some special brush for them, I bought one but am still "saving" it. Foam brushes should be the pro grade ones, normally wooden handles, and harder foam. Two are good, one for applying, one for tipping off. On larger areas, not to be sprayed, you can apply with a foam roller cover, the 3mm type, and tip off with a foam brush, or a piece of roller cover used like a squeegee.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#10

Yes +

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Using dewaxed shellac as a sanding sealer with improve your waterborne finish by several factors of good. Here's why.

Waterbornes (water based, etm) will not only raise the grain they will also pucker or wrinkle the wood surface of the wood as the wood takes in water. The film dries sealing in that excess water and the wrinkled surface. Even sanding the finish will not get all of the feathery fibers nor the now-bumpy surface. The wood surface is the primary reflective layer we view so a bumpy feathery surface will not do well at reflecting light up to our eyes. Shellac, on the other hand, doesn't effect the carefully prepared surface except to float the tiny feathers or wood grain that get matted down. They stand up and get stiff when the shellac dries so that a careful re-sanding cuts them off leaving a smooth hardened surface that is much more reflective. A light recoat with your shellac seals the surface that is then followed by your waterbased finish to bring out the true life and beauty of the wood when there are no wrinkles and tiny feathers in the finish film to mess with the refraction and reflection of light through the dried film.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#11

What I do

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Dick's warning should be heeded.

I find that anything more coarse than 360 (I use 400) grit leaves scratches that can show up in the final coat. I lightly! block sand a flat surface getting what can be got with a flat sanding block. Then I fold paper and with light finger pressure sand all the surface to make it uniformly dull.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#12

more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. You maple is not going to stay white. It will eventually become light brown. Hence, a small amount of change in finish color is irrelevant.

2. The thinned coat of shellac needed to stiffen sanded fibers, and then sanded, is going to not wind up a very thick shellac coating. I doubt (speculate) it will add any significant color to the browning maple.

3. Finck, the Krenov plane maker, showed me something about water based finishes. They don't raise the grain of hand planed surfaces.

4. The first coat should be a thin coat that dries quick.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#13

Re: more

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Bill.

I ran a trial today, with a slight difference.

The shellac is Ubeaut White Shellac, which is unwaxed and concentrated. It is recommended to thin it 50% as a finish and up to 80% as a sealer. I wiped a thin coat of 50% on a sanded (400 grit) surface. It did not raise the grain. I did this again when dry and rubbed down with grey mesh (although I could not feel any nibs).

Then, instead of spraying the GF water-based finish, I wiped on a coat. Then I wiped on two more coats. It looks great so far. No brush marks. And the colour is still very, very light (I accept than it will go slightly darker over time but not as much as with oil-based poly). I plan to add another coat tomorrow and rub it down.

This is important for me as I do not have spray equipment, and if I choose to spray, I need someone to do it for me.

Any thoughts?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#14

Re: more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If wiping works that is a useful discovery. I would have suggested a foam brush, something I have had excellent success with on cabinet frames and other flat surfaces. However, the area where you panel meets the frame is going to be hard to brush without this edge wiping finish from the brush and making a run, or puddle. Lets us know what works.

For what it is worth, learning to spray and buying the stuff to do it was one of the most important investments of time and money I have made in woodworking.

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#15

Re: more

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well Bill, I gave the test board one more rubbed coat, let it dry, and rubbed over it with grey mesh. The finish is exactly as I wanted: a little on the shinier side of matt, but flat and no brush marks. It looks clear. I will be very satisfied if all the doors I build turn out this well.

I am surprised that no one appears to have rubbed this finish. That is what I do with all the finishes I use, be it shellac, variations of danish oil, or wax. I swear by rubbing finishes. All I read about in reviews and discussions about water-based poly are efforts to find the ideal brush, and in fact General Finishes have a video of emphasising the use of a foam brush. But another video (of a reviewer) used a foam brush and made a mess.

I decided that the common error was creating a thick coat. These water-based finishes dry very quickly, and a thick finish ends up with ridges. These then have to be sanded out. I also tried the finish as a first coat, but it did raise the grain slightly, hence the decision to first rub on a coat of shellac. The Ubeaut White Shellac is near colourless.

All coats are rubbed on very quickly and as thin as possible. It feels like you are wiping it off rather than wiping it on. Don't try and do it all. Stop before it dries. Let it dry, then do some more. So the coats are thin and I ended up with 2 coats of shellac and 4 coats of water-based poly. I used a worn 400 grit Abranet on a Mirko sanding block between coats. At the end I rubbed down with grey mesh.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#16

No Rub

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Derek,

The waterborne finishes have really been formulated to mate with HVLP spray equipment. With the application control I get with a good gun, the finish film self-levels so well that I quit the rub-out routine. Couple of examples of "off the gun" finishes with no rubbing:

White Oak


Maple


Product is General's Enduro Clear Gloss Poly

Re: Water based varnish sanding

#17

Re: Water based varnish sanding

tom gattiker

Thanks guys. After trying on a test piece, I sanded flat with a 320 abralon pad on an ROS then applied a final coat of varnish. Had to get a few low spots with finger pressure. Here's the finished product in situ

https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B1h6u0kbt7c6YWo4WHgwZDFyV2c/view?usp=sharing

I really appreciate the knowledge available on this forum

(Gotta learn to spray).