Who makes a good ROS?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
without spending my kids' inheritance for a Fein or Festool? My Porter Cable ROS just died and there are no replacement parts made for it anymore, at least the one I need?
I'm looking for one sub $200.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Who makes a good ROS?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
without spending my kids' inheritance for a Fein or Festool? My Porter Cable ROS just died and there are no replacement parts made for it anymore, at least the one I need?
I'm looking for one sub $200.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
John in NM
I have a Makita I like, only trouble is the hook & loop pad is worn out after a pretty short time (ok, a few years lightly used = short time normally used).
I used to always buy the $50 Ryobi at HD because it was cheap, durable, and I could get replacement hook sheets at the same store (way cheaper than replacing the whole pad). That made so much sense that they discontinued it 
My wife bought a DeWalt when she got tired of my not ordering a new pad for the Makita. She likes it too. Both seem to run smoother than the old Ryobis - they made your hands tingle after a while.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Jim Dillon
Bruce, Santa was very nice to me this year. I received a 5-inch Bosch ROS20VSC ROS, and a Bosch ROS65VC-6 6-inch sander. My PC 333 ROS is still going strong but getting long-in-the-tooth. I have had good luck with Bosch tools and they were offering a $25 discount at Xmas time. The price on the 6-incher would slightly break your budget however. Both work very well and I am most surprised at how well balanced the 6-incher is and how vibration free each are. Two finger handling of the 6-incher is easy. While the dust container that comes with each really does work well, when you empty it very fine dust fills the air. Thus, I hook mine up to a shop vac. Hope this helps. Jim
Edit: These sanders almost make sanding fun, but not quite ;-)
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Ron in Sterling, CT
Family Handyman did a comparison in their November 2017 issue. Lots of info. FWIW
Ron
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Grant Smith
While it is just beyond your budget, I would consider the Mirka Deros line. I have been researching, reading reviews, and considering one for my shop. I have used its predecessor, the unit with a power pack, and I was impressed with that. The Deros is light weight, and the plate is drillable to accomodate your current sandpaper if you like.
FWIW,
Grant in Iowa
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Eric Kuehne
I have a 5 inch Bosch with a handle that I've had for close to 20 years. One pad replacement. The only negative is the the clip dust collector fittings are wimpy. Is was about $100 then and IIRC I saw an ad recently for a basic Festool sander in the same price range. Maybe I was dreaming.
Eric in Los Gatos
Bosch
Dick Coers
I've always like the 3727 for furniture making. They also make a 5", 3725. The stock dust collection works pretty well, and the variable speed is nice. Spins up to 12,000 orbits per minute. I highly recommend these.
Re: Bosch
Larry
I'm with Dick, that the only I use!
Think air
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
See if you can score a used upright 5 HP compressor and use it to run an air driven sander. Many models are available for about $200. There is a reason that shops and factories use them.
Shops and factories use them
Dick Coers
because the plant needs compressed air for other operations (CNC and the spray booth). The one thing I detested in my pro shop was a big compressor hammering away while we sanded. Two Dynabrades would keep the compressor in a fairly active cycle when we were sanding large panels. Then come July around here, and the tank would get warm, and all the water traps would be active as well. Have it too close and you have to wear hearing protection along with the lung protection. I also can't see the cost advantage of buying a big compressor, adding moisture traps and lines, instead of running a tiny electric motor.
Adapters?
JL
Not really a hijack - how important are adapters for shop vacuums for you?
Do you want to hook your shop vacuum up to your ROS?
If so, you may want to consider brands other than the Bosch.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
John K Jordan
I'm happy with a 5" Bosch I've had for about 5 years.
For smaller ROS I have a couple of pneumatic sanders: a 3" palm sander from Woodturners Wonders and a tiny 2"/1" Grex. Like other pneumatic tools these do need good air in the shop but I have a 60 gal 5hp compressor in a sound-insulated shop. Otherwise, the compressor would be annoying.
JKJ
Re: Bosch
John McGaw
I'll second (or third) the Bosch. I've had a 5" with free-wheeling orbital and a 6" with 'driven' orbital for years and both have given excellent service. The only maintenance has been replacement of a hook-and-loop pad after maybe 10 years of heavy use.
Re: Bosch - Fort(?)
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey
(one mahr dan toid)
ROS20VS is 5" and has relegated my workhorse 6" PC7336 to rub-outs and car wax buffing.
PS: Have a large stock of 6" H&L 6-hole abrasives if any one's interested. 
I have had better experience
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
My home shop needs compressed air to run spray equipment, nailers, impact wrench, and, compressed air can't be beat for dusting the shop or removing dust from the pores of walnut about to be finished. Ditto for even the smallest cabinet shops in my area. Whether you are a factory or my home shop one should consider the whole package- the compressor and what the compressor can run that can't be run in some other way, or can be run better by air. In my case the incremental increase in cost of a compressor large enough to intermittently run an air sander turned out to money well spent.
Air driven sanders are lightweight and inexpensive compared to premium electric driven ROS units. And they cut fast at 10,000, and greater, rpm and, they don't leave swirl marks. They are used where they are used for these reasons, I believe.
My compressor is remote from my shop working area so the noise factor is irrelevant. In any case the home shop will be running the beast intermittently so the noise can be dealt with just like the intermittent noise from the router.
I got 15 years of service from my bosch
Robin Corell in Atascadero
I have a 5" Bosch that I've had for almost 15 years. the model I have has been re designed and now has a more powerful motor and what looks like more comfortable ergos as well as being available as either single or variable speed versions. I like the self contained dust filter/collector but the retaining ears on mine no longer flexible and it tends to fall off. The part I need is no longer available and will likely be the reason I replace the tool but after 15 years and the amount of use I have gotten I consider it to be a great value and will replace it with a the updated version.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
eliot feldman
Would you believe that about a month ago there was some sort of Festool special for such a tool listed online and I got one for $99. I seem to remember that even the shipping was free. Apparently , they do this from time to time. You have to wait quite a while to get it, though.
Fe$tool ETS 125 EQ
Virgil Johnson
I have a Festool 5". ETS 125 EQ. I'm sure I'm one of the cheapest cheap skates here but have never regretted the purchase.
Re: I have had better experience
TomD
Depends on the ROS, I don't like the high speed ones auto body ones like Chicago Electric has, though with the right pad they would get 'er done.
I own a high quality one that runs lower RPM and has tons of torque. I bought it because at the time there weren't electric ROS at least not in the home market, maybe there were some 2K models somewhere. The low end torque was nice, and the ability to wet sand with no issues. But overall not better than electric, particularly after extraction was perfected. Looking at google pics my air tool one doesn't appear to be represented, it was all metal, probably too expensive to make. It was like a palm sander, but very powerful. There are tons of similar ones out there with plastic frames. There is more variety in air, from 2 inch to 8 inch.
I have been perfectly happy with these:

They have way more easily managed power than the palm electric ones, and they extract pretty well. I hear the Festool one is worth the extra money, but not to me. A friend of mine built a 46 foot catamaran that involves sanding like you can't imagine, and he is a pro boat finisher. He was happy with the PC.
Re: I have had better experience
TomD
Hey Virgil, I didn't see your post. That is what I hear about the Festool, and if I could get a loaner, and it was that much better the money would not be an issue. Boats can involve a lot of sanding, though I try to get away with as near to none as I can. The older I get, the less I sand, but still, there is enough of it that a better sander would be worth the cost if starting a new project. But the extra costs seems to be about 4x and I wouldn't bother in my shop.
What really makes a difference is good foam pads, and good sandpaper, and knowing when to change it out.
If you don't want to plane, a way to super charge flat panel sanding is with a disc sander/polisher (preferably with a square pad), or a belt sander. Pretty much any ROS will finish sand fairly quickly.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Barry Irby
Wish I had known about that deal. I have a 6" Festool ROS and like it, but it is huge in my hands.
Re: Fe$tool ETS 125 EQ
William Duffield
I'm not usually a cheapskate, and I have several Fe$tool$. When the last of my P-C and Makita ROSs gave up the ghost, I really wanted to like the 5" ETS125, but I found I couldn't effectively control it. It bounced around like an empty dog dish.
So, instead, I bought a Fe$$tool 6" Rotex RO 150. I really like it, and with two different sanding modes, variable speed and excellent dust collection, it is versatile enough to do the job of at least two sanders. If I ever thought I might need another ROS, Festool or otherwise, I'm now stuck with the 6" format, unless I want to invest in an assortment of 5" discs to fit the other sander. Later, I also bought a 3" RO 90, with circular Rotex, circular random orbit and triangular oscillating modes, which I am also pleased with. I doubt seriously I will ever need or want to buy another ROS.
Re: Who makes a good ROS?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
Thanks to everyone for great suggestions and experience. It looks like a contest between the Bosch and Makita, and I'll have to visit the nearest Acme store to see which one wins. In the meantime, I bypassed the VS switch in the sander and it made no difference. I have a hard time believing that an on/off switch could be such a culprit and that Black and Decker/Porter Cable no longer make those parts.
Anyway, thanks much.
Re: I have had better experience
Barry W. Larson
I have a question for TomD and I apologize for this small hijack of the thread. Do you happen to know if the more recent incarnations of the PC Right angle ROS (Models 7345, 7455 and 7346, 7456) are up to the standards of the older versions you picture (7335 and 7336)? I've been thinking about one of these sanders (likely a 6" version) for a while, but I am wondering if I should hold out for an old one or if the newer ones are worth a chance.
Thanks,
Barry W. Larson
Calgary, Alberta, Canada eh!