Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Lathe needs

Posts

Lathe needs

#1

Lathe needs

Jim Cunningham

Have been doing lathe work for several years making components for furniture I have an entry level lathe and am considering a new one

My Rockwell is probably a '70's vintage with a 1/3 hp motor and 4 speed pulley drive. It's not real heavy duty and the video's showed quickly where it is lacking

My question is what do I look for in a new (or used) lathe. Shop Fox has a 2hp variable speed 12" x 40" for about $800 delivered. The other end of the spectrum is thousands and huge. Out of my price range and needs.

I don't plan on going professional but wonder what to look for. Projects (bowls-hollow forms etc) will be of moderate size

Your combined knowledge and thoughts and comments are ,as allways, greatly appreciated

Re: Lathe needs

#2

Re: Lathe needs

Dick Coers

I would not recommend any mechanical variable speed lathes in that price range. The reeves drive is noisy, and needs regular maintenance to keep the cheap cast pulleys in good service. If you really want that style, watch Craigslist, they go for half or less of new because of those kind of issues. If you need a new lathe, look for electronic variable midi lathe with a bed extension.

Re: Lathe needs

#3

Re: Lathe needs

Bill Howatt

Best to post this on the Turning Forum which is listed under Messageboards.

You should include what size objects you need to turn and specifically why this lathe is lacking. Usually for turning spindles a large, heavy lathe is not really required - they are more important for turning items like large bowls from heavy blanks and where the maximum speed needs to be in the 300RPM range to start.

Bill

Re: Lathe needs

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Lathe needs

Jack Guzman from Maine

I bought a 1224vs jet and a bed extention about three years ago. I use it exclusively for spindle work. Making chair legs. I love it. No problems as yet. I use it constantly.

The price is 700-800 and the extension is a few hundred more. No idea how it would work for bowls. I don't do any of that.

You can get more replies if you post on the turning forum. Click on messageboards above and then turning.---Jack

Re: Lathe needs

#5

Re: Lathe needs *LINK*

Hank Knight

Jim,

I'm not a turner, but I wanted a lathe for spindle work and miscellaneous other projects. Some years ago I bought a Conover lathe with all the trimmings. It was a fine machine and way more than adequate for my needs - overkill, actually. It was a large machine and took up more space in my shop than I could justify, given the limited use it saw. I dismantled it, gave it to my son-in-law and replaced it with a much more modest Myford ML8 that I found on eBay. The Myford is an English lathe built from the 1950s until sometime in the '70s. I upgraded it with a VFD and a 1hp DC motor. It is perfectly adequate for my needs and even has an outboard tool rest for turning larger work off the end of the spindle. The VFD setup is wonderful and, as others have said, it is an enormous improvement over the mechanical belt-changing method for changing speeds. There are lots of small to medium sized lathes out there that sound as though they would suit your needs, and the older ones are easily upgraded with a VFD setup. They come up on Craigslist and eBay all the time. Keep your eyes open and you can probably snag one for a reasonable price.

For example, here's a Nova Comet II with an electrical speed control that is available near me in Sumter SC for $500.


Nova Comet II - Craigslist

Re: Lathe needs

#6

Clint Searl

Delta 46-700 for sale

Clint Searl

Near Quakertown, PA. Call me if interested 215 529-9329

Re: Lathe needs

#7

Re: Lathe needs

john lucas

I owned a the Original Nova Comet and it was a fabulous lathe. Just too small for all my needs. I looked at the new Nova Comet 11 yesterday at Woodcraft and it is an excellent lathe. You can get bed extensions for it if you need something longer than 16". Great lathe.

The Jet 12/24 is also a good lathe. We have one of those in our club.

Re: Lathe needs

#8

Re: Delta 46-700 for sale

john lucas

I hate to step on someone's deal but I owned a 46-700 Delta and it was the worse lathe I've owned. The Variable speed pulley's on the Reeves drive break and were hard to get when the lathe was new. Probably impossible now. Do a search online for comments and that lathe and you will hear nothing but bad news. While waiting on the pulleys that were back ordered I bought the Nova Comet mini lathe. Even though it was smaller and lighter than the Delta it was so much smoother my turning improved overnight. I sold the Delta as soon as I got it fixed and kept the Nova Comet for many years even after getting a larger lathe. It just ran so smoothly it was pleasure to turn on. I upgraded to the Nova 3000 which you do see used every now and then. That is an excellent lathe. We still use one of those in our local club for demos. I upgraded from that to a Powermatic 3520 which is well over your price range.

Re: Lathe needs

#9

Go to Grizzly for replacement pulleys


Re: Lathe needs

#10

Re: Lathe needs

TomD

I think you are better off getting a second hand deal on a real machine. For instance, up here the General, bigger lathe comes up for sale for as little as 1200 can. I owned the smaller version as my first lathe, after seeing Del Stubbs use it. Then I bought a Union Graduate bowl lathe, and a Conover, both of which I still own. In a lot of ways the Conover is the bomb, though my tool rest stand recently broke, and was never that good. I can fab up a good one. It can be stored in a few milk crates, or built into any size of monster you want. But hard to find. I think it is too bad that none of the Chinese sellers took over the Conover. But aside from the Conover, if you get a "real" lathe you will be able to sell it for what you paid for it, or nearly so, and have the pleasure of the use of a real lathe.

When you upgrade, normally you don't stay the same. Having the better machine may push you in the direction of more ambitious projects so what seems like a natural occasion for a 50% upgrade can end up being a stealth 75% upgrade need.

Lathes are the limiting factor in lathe work. Sure an expert can push the boundaries. As a non-expert I turned my first bowl on a sheet metal lathe diagonally placed on my table saw to use it's motor. But why would one want to. But the flip side to that is you need to call it quits at some point as the demands can be unreasonable. A 12/24" solid lathe with a decent motor is a good place to take a stand.

The US equivalent of this, that is 730 dollars. There is a general 160 for 500 dollars, though it isn't as nice a looking lathe.

http://www.kijiji.ca/v-power-tool/ottawa/general-260-wood-lathe/1213082791?enableSearchNavigationFlag=true

Re: Lathe needs

#11

JL

Reasonable power, etc.

JL

I've turned on a number of lathes.

For furniture turning - IMO - you need at LEAST a bed length of 36". If you get a smaller lathe, you need a bed extension.

For spindle turning - again, IMO - you don't need that much power - but at least 1/2, preferably more.

For bowl turning - again, IMO - it would be nice to have a throw of at least 16" - though you can make do with less.

For bowl turning - the more power, the better. Figure at least 1 hp, preferably more. If you turn using a face plate, you can get by w/ less power. If you turn using a chuck, you need more.

Electronic variable speed is well worth the price.

If I were getting a smaller lathe - it would be either the Rikon 70-220VSR or the Jet 1221VS. If I were getting a larger, it would probably be the Jet 1642 EVS.

Go take a turning class and see which lathes suit you. Some places use minis and some use larger lathes. Buy once, cry once - so test out a few.

Re: Lathe needs

#12

Re: Go to Grizzly for replacement pulleys

john lucas

These are split pulleys that are only made by Delta. It is possible that someone makes them but I've never seen them. I looked about 2 years ago for some for a friend. He ended up tossing his.

Re: Lathe needs

#13

Re: Go to Grizzly for replacement pulleys *LINK*

Dick Coers

Maybe I'm thinking about the wrong lathe, but I thought all the reeves drive lathes came from one factory, same as Jet and Grizzly. Is that a generation that Delta made in USA? Edit; Included a link to show replacement parts. A Lovejoy pulley was used to replace the motor pulley, but it did require a little rework. A Grizzly set will replace the headstock set.


http://www.woodtalkonline.com/topic/13918-delta-1440-46-715-lathe/