Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

Posts

Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#1

Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

Darita

I recently got into welding and found that my old miter saw, with an abrasive blade on it, just wasn't cutting it. I have a Festool Kapex and use it for all fine woodworking, so I thought about a chop saw with abrasive blade and started looking online for info. I saw lots of Youtube vids on the Evolution Rage 3 and it seemed to be able to do both wood and metal, so I figured it might be a good replacement for the old miter saw.

The ER3 comes in pieces, although it requires little assembly and only takes a few minutes to get it up and running. My first couple of cuts on 1/8" x 6" hardboard showed that some adjustment would have to be made to the fence and bevel angle stops, in order to get an acceptable cut. After repeated attempts, the best I could get was a barely acceptable 90* cut with the slider. Even with the workpiece clamped down, the cut seemed to waver from end to end and could be due to slide action, blade arbor runout or both....at least, that's all I could figure. The 45* cuts are again, acceptable, but not optimal. Dust collection is minimal at best.

As for the laser, I was not able to get it adjusted to be accurate in any way. I could not get the laser line 90* to the fence. Also, as you pull the blade down for the cut, the laser line travels from left of the cut, to right of the cut, but not so it was accurate on either side. It's beyond me how to accurately adjust this laser.

In the past, I've had a Makita 12" slider and a Hitachi 10" slider and have been able to get these saws to perform very well. This ER3 is definitely not in the same class, for sure. Weight and fit and finish alone, keep it from being at the same level. Throw in the barely adequate cut quality and it's clear that I would not be using this saw for any fine woodworking. All that said, I got this saw to be able to cut light metal and junk wood scraps and it will likely do both. I certainly wouldn't consider keeping this saw if I were using it as my primary miter saw, however as a secondary saw that doesn't need to cut dead on, I'll keep it for it's versatility alone.

If anyone has had better results with this saw, please chime in. Thanks for reading.

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#2

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

Darita

By the way, all cuts were checked with a Starrett square.

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#3

Sounds Like

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

a thin kerf (or cheap) blade issue.

Cut quality on my LS1211 improved substantially when I put a full-kerf high quality blade on it.

If the saw was designed as a break-down/rough cut machine, chances are good the mfgr put an ElCheepo blade on it the save a few bucks. Thin kerf blades are also used to reduce the size or demand of the motors. Thin kerf blades tend to wiggle in chop saws giving a wavy cut. A better blade or even a smaller one (if the arbor will take it) will likely improve your cuts.

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#4

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

Darita

OK...A LITTLE UPDATE...I got tired of trying to adjust this saw to cut 90*, with the laser adjusted properly, so I returned it and exchanged it for another unit. One of the issues was, when installing the blade, I had to tweak the blade guard to the side, in order to get the blade in position. I think there was an arbor problem that was causing multiple issues.

Well, the new ER3 was much better, with regards to getting the blade mounted. The blade to table squareness was way off, so that had to be adjusted. With that done, the blade to fence 90* had to be adjusted and tested for a 90* cut. I found that there's a big difference in cut when plunging alone, as compared to sliding alone. I suspect that its' cause could be due to flex in the slide runners. Since I couldn't get the cut adjusted in both, I adjusted to the slide cut and got it fairly 90* and straight.

Once all of the that was done, I was able to get this laser unit adjusted pretty close.

Strange note here...the laser in blade up position, sits to the left of the blade. When the blade is lowered, the laser line moves from left side, to right side. Is that on purpose? I don't think so, as how far right it moves depends on how low the blade is lowered, so it's not like you can use the laser to align a right side cut. That said, there's no way I could get the laser adjusted so that it wouldn't move. Weird????

So now, my final assessment really hasn't changed much. I would not use this as my primary saw for woodworking, however for metal work, it's close enough for sure. I'm still scratching my head, wondering how all those Youtube reviews could call this a bang on saw, cuz that it ain't. What it is, is a decent metal/wood miter saw that is convenient for it's capabilities, albeit not a dead on miter saw.

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#5

Why are you putting up with this?

Gary Smyth

I know that you are writing a review and being thorough pointing out the finer points. but for your $350-$400 why are you putting up with a crappy machine. In my view a tweak here and there might be manageable to get it as near to perfect as you need, but this saw appears to be an exercise in futility. Did you contact the rep? Did you get particulars as to specs? If the overall + or - is not within both their and your tolerances tell them to keep the thing and spend what extra you need to get what you need. If it's a different manufacturer then do that. A miter saw needs to do two things -- cut and be accurate.

You shouldn't have to devote as much time as you have to get something to work correctly. Tell the rep that as you turn it in!

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#6

what exactly do you want vs what you need

Robin Corell in Atascadero

I believe the evolution is the only saw being marketed as both a metal and wood miter saw. It is a couple hundred bucks less than its nearest carbide tooth metal cutting miter saw competitor and almost 1/3 the cost of the top metal miter saws. Everything I have read about it is that compared to an abrasive metal saw it rocks! I would not expect it to compare favorably to a wood miter saw solely based on blade tooth design. the necessary tooth geometry to cut steel is very different from the geometry for clean cuts in veneers and that is different from the tooth geometry for cutting green wood like 2x4's.

I have an old Jepson and it is very accurate in the vertical plane but it leaves a lot to be desired in its fence. It is accurate in the vertical plane but has no angle markings, being similar to the old abrasive saws in that two bolts need to be loosened to move the fence for angle cuts. I could save a lot of time on angled set ups by upgrading to a new Jepson compound miter saw, but their prices make Festool look inexpensive. I guess the short version is how many dollars worth of accuracy do you really need? I mean doesn't you work only need to look straight and flat and square, or are you building jet engines?

Re: Evolution Rage 3 Sliding Miter Saw Review...

#7

Re: Why are you putting up with this?

Darita

Gary, honestly, this is an extra miter saw that will be used for rough cutting wood scraps and metal cutting. Dead on accuracy is not as important to me as versatility, in this case. Also, for $199, it's worth it to me. I wrote the review for anyone else who is considering this saw.