I was looking at various sharping videos on YouTube. I at least two of them they used a cloth wheel with buffing compound as the finial step. This made me go HMMM?
At first it seems like a good idea. You seem to get a really polished surface. This is one of the goals. Two truly polished surfaces meeting produce a very sharp edge with minimal saw teeth from the grit. I have not tried it yet. Upon further thought it seems the buffing would round over the edge from both sides perhaps at a nearly microscopic scale thus dulling it somewhat. ????
Seems to me it would be a good idea to polish the backs of blades and then sharpen your way past the rounded over.
So, has anybody used a buffing wheel? Does it work well? Am I wrong about the rounding over?
One famous chip carver won't even use a leather strop on his chip carving knives because he said it will round over the edge. I haven't noticed that myself - I sharpen on very fine abrasive paper then strop with a compound on leather glued to a board.
The guy who runs the carving shop in Townsend TN (near the Smoky Mtns) uses a cloth wheel of sorts to polish all of the carving knives, said it didn't round over the edge. I bought one and it works well. It is some kind of woven fabric but quite stiff like it is laced with something, layers of the cloth are in big waves around the circumference. There are not a bunch of fibers hanging off it like on my Beale buffing wheels.
I have a sharpness tester coming in a few days to test lathe tool sharpening methods. Testing this polishing should be easy enough.
Only I use a hard felt wheel rather than a cloth wheel, and I use it in a hand crank grinder. It works best on a hollow ground bevel and stay away from the back of the blade.
Done right, it makes "scary sharp" look not so scary. Edge does not last as long as a stoned edge however, probably because it does make for a convex surface at some scale.
It is very useful to have this technique available for smoothing plane blades as you can plane the impossible grain for a short time. When it gets dull I refresh the edge on the bench grinder and polish it again - it doesn't take long at all.
I don't use this for chisels and such, just smoothers.
I have a hard felt wheel on my grinder that I use now and again. Many of my tools are Japanese, so I use the designed stones for them, or sometimes strop with diamonds, particularly in the winter when it gets cold to use water.
I started a thread in hand tools based on something I saw in a Tage Frid video. He was sharpening on a rough grind hard wheel and moved directly to buffing. My finest wheel is an 80, I went straight to green compound and a buff on hard felt. It worked. Surprising considering the huge jump. Basically people did not accept the findings here coming close to calling me a liar. But someone else with the gear tried it and said it worked. It does sorta feel like maybe you are getting a serrated edge off the rough grind and maybe only buffing the high points, but overall the whole things cuts well (just a guess).
So yeah, a buff can really work, better no doubt with a little more prep. I think a buff is what you get on most/many tools that come sharpened. The rounding issue is not serious. The main problem with rounded edges is not how they cut, where there are even some advantages, the problem is what they do to the efficiency of hand sharpening if they require more grinding to get back to the angles you want to work. But this is not an issue most of the time, and certainly not if one is otherwise power sharpening.
There are also buffing methods that do less to round edges than some other. There are buffing belts that run over platens and probably don't round much. There are tools that look like wheels of MDF, possibly something else, that you can do your sharpening on, and they are pretty hard. And maybe cratex wheels also fit the bill.
>>>There are also buffing methods that do less to round edges than some other.
>>>There are buffing belts that run over platens and probably don't round much.
Now that you mention it, I use one for knives. My knife sharpener uses two 1" wide abrasive belts and a buffing belt - they ride over a graphite plate.
The buffing belt is in fact pretty "fuzzy." To buff, the belt is charged with a compound that looks like white diamond buffing compound.
This machine gets the knives amazingly sharp in a very short time with little effort. (The guy I got it from takes one to gun shows and sharpens pocket knives all day for $4 a knife.) If it's rounding over the edge it isn't hurting anything. BTW, this machine uses a jig that puts a micro bevel on edge as the last step just before buffing.
Lots of good replies. I spent a lot of time resharpening my carving tools not long ago. I also did a test on different metals such as HSS vs Carbon steel vs Particle metal.
What I found was the more mirror like the surface the better they seemed to cut. This meant that I finished my grinds with at least 600 but 1000 grit was better. My Tormek was suppposed to be 1000 grit but I found 1000 grit sanding belt left finer scratches.
I found that the yellow bar that carvers use was more aggressive at removing metal and worked better for honing the particle metal steels. The green bar worked well for others. For the polished edge the leather strop worked well on most tools. The hard felt wheel with the yellow bar worked much better for the particle metal steels.
I tried only briefly using a courser wheel (180 CBN) followed by buffing with a soft wheel. The idea was that the soft wheel would buff down to the bottom of the scratches where I hard wheel or leather would only buff the top. It seemed to give a good edge but I didn't really spend the time necessary to really test it. Need to try it again and do it seriously.
I interviewed for a job sharpening scalpals. It was an interesting interview. I didn't persue it any further because the pay sucked and I couldn't imagine doing that every day all day. Anyway, they grind the tools to almost a mirror finish before going to hard felt wheels with an unknown compound. They used 2 different wheels and 2 different compounds. The compound bars were different colors that I had seen anywhere else so I assume it's something they have custom made. The fact that they ground to a mirror finish on abrasive belts stuck with me as the ultimate way to get to a good edge.
I can't remember if I mentioned it but are you familiar with the sharpness testers Mike at EdgeOnUp makes and sells? I learned about these from gentleman from another forum who has been using them for some time. It appears this could be one way to help to objectively evaluate sharpening on lathe tools rather than the method I use now: "man, that's really sharp, that one ain't so sharp". :-) From what the guy told me these things are very repeatable.
I was fairly skeptical at first but I talked with Mike at length on the phone and he had believable answers to all my questions.
One thing I want to do is sharpen two skews or spindle gouges made from different steel (say Thompson's and Sorby's) and test the sharpness before and after making equivalent cuts on the same piece of wood. (I realize the testing problems here.)
I also want to evaluate some different sharpening techniques. I am especially interested in just how sharp my chip carving knives are compared to other knives and tools sharpened other ways.
I have a PT50b coming in a few days. I'll let you know what I think.
At the risk of being a complete wet blanket - is such a tool really necessary?
Strikes me as just the thing for people who don't use tools often enough to be able to evaluate sharpness empirically - and thus have no need to actually know how sharp something is in the first place.
No offense intended, it just seems to me that the best way of evaluating an edge is to use it in your accustomed work - use it for tasks you do all the time.
No worry - one man's wet blanket is the basis for another man's sling psychrometer!
I agree that very few people will see the need or have a use for an edge sharpness tester. Some exceptions are the those in the knife-making business. Mike at EdgeOnUp had a pallet of 1600 of the upgraded "B" instruments waiting for calibration and package, some to restock Amazon - the demand has far exceeded their expectations.
When I discovered such an instrument existed I immediately wanted one, if only to evaluate and play with it. I have never been sorry for the test equipment I've acquired, from precision Starrett instruments to oscilloscopes to voltage and frequency standards, to laboratory grade thermometers, scales, and microscopes. Call it a hobby, perhaps honed by working at a large science/R&D laboratory.
I think everyone will agree that comparing methods or materials benefits from empirical analysis by experiments (with controls), careful observations, and above all, a way to measure things.
I can say "it seems like that LED light looks dimmer that it did three years ago" but without a good light meter that observation means little when evaluating lifetimes. I can say "my llamas look plenty healthy this year" but without taking fecal samples (a fun job) and a having a method of making consistent parasite egg counts with a microscope it is difficult to objectively evaluate our wellness strategies.
I do agree the simple subjective evaluation, say of the sharpness of this gouge I'm using now, is useful and sufficient for the craftsman.
-----
BTW, I ran into a small group of like-minded people who are experimenting with and attempting to evaluate lathe tool sharpening methods. There is plenty in the technical literature about sharpness but I know of nothing rigorous specific to the brutal requirements of lathe tools. The research on double-edged razor blades doesn't help much! They don't hold up so well cutting dry hickory at 3000 rpm. :-)
I have a friend with SEM access if needed, but with any kind of microscope I think it is hard to get the full "picture" of a sharp edge. With too much magnification any edge from the side looks like a mountain range.
Do you plan on selliing one of the scopes? I know a guy who might be interested.
I've have two at the moment but one (a Heathkit I built decades ago) needs a simple repair and I haven't cared enough to fix it.
I can't believe how inexpensive digital scopes are now. A few years ago I bought a small 2-channel 100 MHz digital storage scope. It's not a Tektronix but does which does way more than I need. However, it would be fun to have a pocket-sized battery operated scope - they are available for just a $100 or two now! But then, I don't really need it as long as I have an extension cord. The scope I use now is pretty small: about 12 x 5 x 6 inches, 5 pounds.
I took inventory of some of test and measuring instruments in the shop:
- the oscilloscope (along with good power supply and frequency generator)
- LUX/FC light meter
- color calibration device
- 40-130 db digital sound meter
- optical tachometer
- dual-probe thermocouple reader
- laser measuring "tape" and levels
- numerous mechanical things for measuring distance
- Fluke IR thermometer
- calibrated laboratory mercury thermometers
- Fluke 87v (in constant use!)
- other multi and current meters
- calibrated current, frequency, and voltage reference standards
- wind speed meter
- numerous digital scales (.1 g to 800 lbs) and lab balance scale
- Dylos laser particle counting air quality monitor
- liquid and gas pressure gauges, vacuum pressure gauges
- optical refractometer for measuring moisture in honey
Do you think I have a problem?
Maybe I need a 12 step program. Or maybe just one more instrument. I don't have an easy way to measure the speed of a projectile, a gamma (etc) radiation detector/monitor, or a wood or metal hardness tester... :-)
Wow, an impressive collection of fine stuff. And, of course, one never really knows when it will be important to have at the ready!
I don't think I'd sell a scope. The good one looks like a small Tektronix but isn't and I can't recall the brand. My other one is an old tube-model Eico 460 that I built from a kit about a year after high-school. It takes me back about 55 years when I see it.
Some of us along with the science teacher built the same model for the school when I was in grade 12 and after that I just had to have a scope. I already had an interest in electronics. It's power transformer has been replaced with a third party model and I regulated the power supply to some degree.
>>>Some of us along with the science teacher built the same model for the school when I was in grade 12 and after that I just had to have a scope. I already had an interest in electronics.
Bill, you sound a little like me - as a pre-teen I took apart everything mechanical and electrical I could get my hands on, fixed what I could figure out, and salvaged parts otherwise. Besides an occasional library book it was blind experimenting until I met others with similar interests in high school.
Science fairs were king of the year and things really ramped up as we got older. A good friend of mine built an electron microscope from scratch in 11th grade, one guy developed a new way to put a hold circuit on phones and eventually got hired by Bell, another friend created a continuously-operating cloud chamber and sold the idea to Westinghouse, and one friend built a CO2 laser after learning some glass blowing. My accomplishment were not nearly as exciting but I did win my share of science fairs. :-)
Even a scope kit was unattainable then but I had a friend with one. It wasn't until I had a wife and a job in the '70s that I built a dual-channel from Heathkit. I about wore that thing out! I used to be the guest science guy at the elementary schools and sometimes hooked a microphone to the scope and let kids sing and make waveforms! (I did short hands-on programs with electricity, gases, light, astronomy, computers, etc. Good clean fun!)
These days I play with Arduinos a little, troubleshoot and repair, and build a few little circuits. And feed the llamas. They don't seem to care about much else!
Pretty impressive list of projects that were done in high school.
I started an electronics club in my HS and we used to build circuits often from magazines like Popular Electronics, Radio-Electronics and then tried to improve them or simplify them- frequently with less than the intended result. This was at the time when tubes were still king.
It seems to me that youngsters who are into technology as an interest are much more sophisticated probably because there is so much available at a very reasonable cost in the way of microcontrollers, integrated circuits etc. Your work with Arduino is probably an example. I don't hear anybody saying they built a 1 tube super-regenerative receiver anymore . A fellow I worked with was going around the building collecting empty toilet paper tubes; he was a cub scout leader and was all excited about having them build crystal sets for the evening project. Next day, I asked him how it went thinking what a great project and remembering my dabbling with a crystal set. Disaster, he said, they didn't have much interest - the problem is that they were all used to playing with CB radios (at that time).
I often wonder what they teach in electronics courses these days.
I still dabble a little with electronics if I want to do something specific but it really is getting to be quite infrequent. I did fix our microwave/convection oven on New Year's eve afternoon. I should say I hope I fixed it. Nothing obvious and not easy to troubleshoot since it is over the stove and very heavy. I unhooked the control panel and changed two 15V and one 5V 3 terminal regulators on the board since I had some. So far so good but not really confidence inspiring. Unfortunately the circuit diagram that comes with it just shows the control board as a blank rectangle with connections going to relays etc.