Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Ash compared to Sassafras

Posts

Ash compared to Sassafras

#1

Ash compared to Sassafras

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


Sassafras is sometimes graded in with ash after it is sawed. You can see why in this picture of the two species. For the future, we may be building with sassafras when the ash all dies.

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#2

Which is which in picture?


Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#3

Re: Which is which in picture?

William Duffield

The one on top is sassafras.

Bill's comparison is a little misleading. Comparing sassafras, Sassafras albidum, with black ash, Fraxinus nigra, finds many similarities especially the color, but the preponderence of ash used in this part of the world is white ash, F. americana.

http://www.wood-database.com/sassafras/

http://www.wood-database.com/black-ash/

http://www.wood-database.com/white-ash/

Comparing the physical properties, it is easy to tell the difference between a board of white ash and one of sassafras, even blindfolded. Ash is much stronger, much harder, much denser, and doesn't smell like root beer. You'd never make a successful baseball bat from sassafras. Black ash's properties are quite a bit closer to sassafras, but still significantly different. The biggest difference is in hardness. White ash is more than twice as hard.

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#4

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

John K Jordan

I don't think I'd want to make an axe handle or baseball bad from sassafras.

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#5

Sassafras makes a dandy boat paddle

Keith Newton

Due to the light weight and durability, or resistance to decay. I made a few about six years ago for the boats down at the cabin. I left them unfinished, and even though they have weathered, they are still light and holding up well.

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#6

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

don stephan

JKJ

Given the relative softness of sassafras, might have to hit a baseball many many more times to make it go bad (sorry, couldn't resist)

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#7

Re: Sassafras makes a dandy boat paddle

William Duffield

You might want to try catalpa.

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#8

That would make a good paddle too, except

Keith Newton

Around here all that I ever get my hands on are so twisted an gnarley, that if I sawed it to follow the grain, it would look like one of Norm Sartorius'a spoons.😐

Re: Ash compared to Sassafras

#9

Re: That would make a good paddle too, except

William Duffield

I've had the honor of actually holding one of Sartorius' spoons, turned from Amboyna burl, in my hands. They are art of the highest order, IMHO at least. And, most of them will even hold soup :D

http://www.normsartorius.com