Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Turning

Posts

Turning

#1

Turning

Jim Cunningham

Question for turners--Can a wood be too hard to turn. I have a piece of what I think is Australian pine. It's been sitting for a good 10 years. I decided to try making a bowl out of some of it. I cut a chunk off and rounded it on the band saw(pretty round) and mounted a face plate. I used a roughing gouge to round the outside. I could not get it to cut. The lightest pass gave me a catch.

I tried the top which is fairly flat.Same result What do you think? This stuff is very dense and heavy

Re: Turning

#2

No

Dick Coers

Wood can't be too hard to turn on a lathe. Try using a sharp bowl gouge. You should not be using a spindle roughing gouge on a bowl.

Re: Turning

#3

Re: Turning

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Jim,

While my turning has not covered a part from every tree -type in the World, I can state that I've never encountered or even heard of any wood that can't be turned, given the proper tools and techniques. I suspect, therefore, that you're doing something wrong either in tool selection or presentation.

So, questions:

1. What tool are you using?

2. You've got the blank mounted on the face-grain, right?

3. You've got the tool rest set as close to the wood as possible, right?

4. Can you post a couple of pix along with your responses?

Re: Turning

#4

Re: Turning

John McGaw

No, no wood is too hard to turn. Some woods are trickier than others to turn because of their grain structure and require different techniques to get a good surface but that is all a matter of subtlety not impossibility. I've turned lignum vitae and most of the hardest rosewoods with fine results. I'd say that the very hard dense woods are actually easier than softwoods overall since they tend to 'stick together' better. I've also turned nuts, bones, antlers, stone (well soapstone, anyway), and soft metals like brass and all of them work too.

Oh, and what Dick said. Never consider using a spindle gouge, especially a roughing gouge, on a faceplate turning. Doing so invites damage and possible injury. There is a reason that bowl gouges are made the way they are!

Re: Turning

#5

Jim I can believe it.

Keith Newton

After Hurricane Andrew in 1992, I was down in Miami for a boat auction, where I bought one which had been totaled to repair for my own use. While I was there, I passed a lot where they were piling trees. Being a turner, I stopped to see what might be interesting. Some of it was burled Australian Pine, which I believe is actually a type of Eucaliptus. I ask permission to take some, and was told to help myself. I didn't have anything but a bow saw, so I set about trying to cut off one from a 6" limb. I wore myself out without getting through that limb, and that was while it was still green. I can't imagine how tough it would be dry.

Re: Turning

#6

PS-Caution

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If, as Keith mentioned, your wood is a branch of the Eucalyptus family, you should do a bit of research and possibly wear a mask or other protection as Eucalyptus. While the leaves and extracts are used medicinally, it can interact with other medications you may be taking.

Re: Turning

#7

But Jim didn't mention any saw cutting problems

Dick Coers

He mentioned cutting a piece off and then rounding on the bandsaw. He didn't claim any issues with those steps, only trouble on the lathe. That would indicate lathe tool issues to me.

Re: Turning

#8

Re: Turning

Jim Cunningham

my skill level consists of spindle turning for furniture-moderate level ability-- using roughing gouge have ordered Sorby bowl gouge before further death defying attempt. Never tried bowl before. Never tried Australian Pine before

Re: Turning

#9

So Lucky

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

You survived the roughing gouge!!!

Jim, if you are or wish to be a member of the AAW, you'll find loads of video tutorials on the AAW site to show you bowl turning as well as bowl gouge sharpening which is quite different from what you're used to doing on your spindle tools.

:)

Re: Turning

#10

Re: So Lucky

Jim Cunningham

Thanks Mark. I'll take a look over there

Re: Turning

#11

Also

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Check in on the Turning Board here. The guys over there can point you to good You-Tube stuff (and awa-a-a-ay from the bad U-Tube idiots trying to kill themselves).

Re: Turning

#12

Re: Turning

William Duffield

The tree called Australian Pine in Florida is not a pine. It's not even close. It is Casuarina equisetifolia. In Oz, it is usually called she-oak. It is in the order Fagales (beeches, birches, oaks, walnuts, etc.). It is an invasive, planted in FL to stabilize dunes. It is much harder than pine, but it can be turned. The problem is the medulary rays are large and legion and have a lot less integrity than the cells surrounding them, and therefore are very susceptible to catching. Very sharp tools and a very light cut are necessary for success. The figure of the resulting turnings is well worth the effort.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Casuarina

Re: Turning

#13

video showing why not to use a roughing gouge *LINK*

john lucas

You mentioned you might be using it as a scraper which is a little bit safer but still not a good idea as it's just to easy to get the cut up onto one of the wings or upper U shaped portion. This then becomes what we call an unsupported edge. the forces will then pull that edge down quickly rotating the tool so even more of the tool digs into the wood and you get a nasty catch. Can't tell you how many spindle roughing gouges I've seen with bent or broken tangs because of this.

Get one of the new Hunter 1st mate or 2nd mate tools and you can use them just like a scraper but they cut cleaner, are extremely easy to use, and you never have to sharpen them. They were designed by Jimmy Clewes who is probably one of the best demonstrators out there. I just used them to teach a class with totally beginners most having never done any woodworking whatsoever and they all had great success with them. http://huntertoolsystems.com/product/1-mate-tool/


https://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=IOhHeyoZLaY