Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Ash Borer

Posts

Ash Borer

#1

Ash Borer

don stephan

For some time I've been wondering how the ash borer galleries or tracks in the cambium layer actually kill the tree. The larvae don't venture deep into the sapwood, so the tree's existing moisture carrying capacity is not greatly diminished. The tree can't make new sapwood or bark, as the larvae seemingly eventually crisscross the entire cambium.

Granted, as the tree tries to continue growing it is trying to add an ever increasing leaf load, which would require an ever increasing moisture carrying capacity, so I wonder if the tree is essentially starving after many years of cambium loss?

Thanks.

Re: Ash Borer

#2

Re: Ash Borer

Keith Newton

Don, you are right that the sapwood can still carry moisture up, but the phloem which is in that cambium layer, carries sugars and other metabolic products downward, enabling cell growth. Once they tunnel out these galleries, so air gets in, then mold and fungus set in and stop that process.

Re: Ash Borer

#3

Re: Ash Borer

Martin from Texas

The "living" tissue part of the tree is a relatively few cells thick. There is xylem, phloem, and the cambial layer, which together form the inner bark. Each growth ring is one year's growth. Sometimes they are very thin, sometimes a little thicker, depending on species and moisture for the year. For example, in drought years, the rings might be very thin, with many per inch. This is also dependent on stand density. Many stems per acre results in crowded trees with thin growth rings. So you see, several factors contribute to growth ring size.

The bark beetles, as a group, bore into the inner bark to lay their eggs. Once the eggs hatch, the "very hungry caterpillars" eat the inner bark, to consume the sugars it contains. Then they pupate, and emerge, sometimes after winter, to attack new trees.

After enough eggs hatch, the tree is girdled, and dies due to the inability of the roots to transfer moisture to the leaves. This is why pine trees will turn yellow first, then brown, as they die. It works the same way in ash trees.

The sapwood that you see is not all living. Only the inner bark is alive, and that is where the growth takes place, and that is what the beetles eat to kill the tree.

So, the lesson here is, if you like ash baseball bats, buy a dozen or two and put them in your closet so your grandkids can play with them or sell them on ebay. The ash trees are going the way of the chestnut and elm, and it is happening before our eyes.

Martin S, former forester, BSF, 1983, MSF, 1986.

Re: Ash Borer

#4

Re: Ash Borer

John Pappas

Good write-up on the subject. Question: We have an ash that we are having treated for the ash bore on a regular schedule. Will trees that are properly treated survive, or is it just a matter of delaying the inevitable?

Re: Ash Borer

#5

Re: Ash Borer

Martin from Texas

Good question.

One arborist told me if you follow the treatment schedule, the tree should live because the beetles won't infect it.

Another arborist told me it was like betting on the slots at Vegas, eventually you are going to lose.

I am not an arborist, so I really don't know.

Best resource is your state forester. He should be up to date on the latest treatments and if they are successful or not.

Re: Ash Borer

#6

Re: Ash Borer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The answer to this question is obvious. If you keep the poison in the tree the beetles can not thrive in the tree and the tree will live. Long term, one can hope the beetles all die when the untreated ash trees are dead. Bad luck would be for the beetles to find another host that would keep at least some of them going.

Re: Ash Borer

#7

Re: Ash Borer

John M in Mid Mich

I would urge careful consideration before treating your ash trees for borers. The standard active ingredient in the recommended insecticides is Imidicloprid, which is in the class of chemicals called neonicotinoids, sometimes shortened to "neonics". The problem is that neonicotinoids are implicated in the collapse of honey bee populations. As unfortunate as it is to lose a cherished Ash, it probably isn't worth putting the bees at risk to save it.

Re: Ash Borer

#8

Re: Ash Borer

David Bair

I have ash trees that have been "dead" from borers for 7-8 years, yet they still sprout from the stump and grow till the beetles make a return and start the cycle over again. I told an Agriculture Dept. rep (Agriculture heads up the borer program in Michigan) that they were just institutionalizing the beetle by not really killing the trees but he maintained that at least the species remained alive in the state, even if it will never again thrive.

Re: Ash Borer

#9

irrelevant worry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The piddly amount of pesticide that is used to treat ash trees pales in comparison to what is used on ag crops.

The last I read on the subject it was still not known what causes colony collapse. For example, there is very little grain crops grown in my area and hence little to no use of this pesticide, yet the bees still have suffered this problem.

Re: Ash Borer

#10

Re: irrelevant worry

John M in Mid Mich

Well Bill, I agree that one person treating one Ash tree may be fairly minor, but where do we draw the line, and how many "piddly" amounts does it take to become significant? What if I and all my neighbors treat the Ash trees? I think this falls in the category of "think globally, act locally". I choose to take personally responsible actions when I can. I _had_ at least 50 ash trees on my 18 acres, and now my woodworking projects lean towards ash. And the next threat? Some of my Burr Oak are dying...