I read a story about German cabinet manufacturer Nobilia in FDM+C magazine. The story said they shipped 630,000 complete kitches in 2015. Just unbelievable numbers. So I found this video that has a little age on it. They were building 2,400 kitchens per day, using 43,000 hinges a day. They must haul in the hinges like gravel! A dump truck full of hinges every day! They claim a 30% market share in Germany.
some articles by William Morris and John Ruskin about the demise of traditional craftsmen due to the industrial revolution where machines took over, and men were just slaves to do the labors incidental to mass production. They had no idea how advanced it would become, and how hard it would be to compete back then, but they were so RIGHT.
Do you think it was the Industrial Revolution that killed quality craftsmanship, or a general change in demand from the public's buying habits. I saw a very low percentage of people demand quality craftsmanship when I ran my woodworking business. It had to look nice, but most had little interest in knowing it had mortise and tenon joinery. I was asked to quote many jobs in neighborhoods of very nice homes. These homes looked nice, but once inside I saw cheap cabinets, cheap windows, and stamped mdf doors made to look like solid panel doors. I probably got the job about 10% of the time. Often never in some neighborhoods. I see people accept low quality with the expectation of replacing it in 15-20 years. Same goes with Chinese knockoff machinery for hobbyists. People shop by price and accept that the machinery will have issues and will likely have to be replaced in the future. I can't imagine the Industrial Revolution kindled the throw-away society. Could be wrong though, I've not researched why experts think the consumer became this way.
The modern home buyer buys square feet, the most they can afford. And they can afford more if the furnishings are cheap. When we sold the first house I built we were forced to accept the same sq ft price as the neighboring homes in spite of the fact our house had Pella windows, solid wood doors, oak floors throughout, walnut cabinets, etc.
I expect this same attitude carries over to furniture,. Otherwise Ikea would not be successful. I think what has happened is that people aren't gaining pleasure and status from owning quality furniture. So there is little demand. One could buy quite a nice hand made chest of drawers for the cell phone cost many families pay per year- maybe not at a studio furniture gallery, but certainly at a family run shop focused on basically designed furniture to use.
When we first started selling hardwood lumber we had many custom kitchen cabinet shop customers. The cabinets were made from solid wood with good joinery and hardware. Eventually these old timers died, the shops closed and the business went to Lowes. So, I know for a fact that in the 1970's and 80's it was possible to make kitchen cabinets average people could afford. Now the only shops left are for very high end cabinetry, that most can not afford. I expect furniture suffered the same fate, just that it occurred earlier. My wife's parents, a family of 6 of modest means, had quite nice hand made mahogany furniture made in a family run shop in Utica, NY. This furniture could be made affordable in the 1930's and 40's. Probably still could if there was demand.
I think another aspect is that most people today just don't know much about wood and joinery aspects of
furniture. They neither know nor care whether something is held together with dowels or haunched tenons.
I have been working lately with a few different families who furnish their houses with very high end furniture. They look for shapes, colors, and textures - seeking that which is in vogue. They have little interest in joinery or wood figure. They nod off when I talk about finishes. Many prefer metal furniture that
is overstuffed, but in the hip colors. For many plywood is better than "regular wood" because it can take more interesting shapes, ala Eames.
Then too, there are many who long to "update" those ten year old kitchen cabinets to something more like what you see on TV.
No wonder the market for quality furniture is so weak.
The throw away society is the direct result of how easy it is to earn a decent living today. As we've become more prosperous and less active, the value of new and novel has supplanted the value of durability in the things we buy.
Back in the 1950's I opened an appliance repair shop in my home. I was in high school, but had taken a Coyne course in Electronics and was pretty handy at repairing TV's, Radios, fans, Irons and kitchen appliances. At that time, like furniture people bought once and kept what they purchased (or inherited) for many years. However a Steam Iron or Mixer cost several days work. TV's cost months of pay, very few in my small town could afford a "new" kitchen table and chair set of quality wood. Beds, chairs, Bureaus etc. were often passed through generations. Today people can have a household full of all "new" throwaway furniture and appliances for a couple of weeks pay.
It appears to me that the young couples would rather choose the new throwaway furniture and appliances of their choice rather than a quality heirloom dining set (albeit the memory scars and scratches from Grandma and Grandpaw).
In some ways I understand ~ they live a fast paced life and have more leisure time to do what they want and can afford to purchase replacement items for little money.
Obviously I closed my shop in very few years as cheap electronics became available, as I could not repair many items for the cost of new. I wasn't alone, most cities and towns had repair shops then as well as shoe repair, Butcher shops and small General stores that are now just memories.
However, we tend to remember the good times, not the bad times. I also remember sitting on the front porch, today people think we did that so we could speak to the neighbors as they passed. That wasn't so, it was because we didn't have air conditioning and the house was unbearable hot. I remember the outhouses, dental care, hospital care and deaths of young neighbors due to diseases that are now either gone or treatable. So while I long for the peace and trust of those years, there were a lot of downfalls.
I don't think all the appreciation of hand crafted furniture has disappeared, but that the middle class just can't afford to purchase a piece that costs a few months of pay, when IKEA and the like are available for a fraction of the price.
I believe there will always be a market, but that it will be limited to those that have a large disposable income.
In my experience consumers of top furniture buy design that happens to be well made. They buy this from manufacturers or individual craftsmen who educate their audience and display their process, that is why so many manufacturers now spend a great deal of time/money on documenting and displaying their process.
Design is what calls your attention, makes something novel and interesting. Something that is well made for the sake of well made is not something that many people find important. Instead it needs to solve a problem, and solve it well. People want to better understand how good design is orchestrated.
That does not mean that quality is unimportant, instead quality is a requirement and most top end furniture is fairly well made.
Someone pointed to metal over-stuffed furniture, this could be Le Corbusier which is manufactured by Cassina. As a metal worker in my youth, and someone who spent a few years working in shops TIG welding Roll Cages and then later ultrasonic equipment, I was very much impressed by the quality of fit and finish in their metal work. I've yet to see anyone other than Cassina make two hard, mandrel bent 90's immediately following one another, welded, ground flush and polished without even a dip in the metal. That along with mitered corners and perfectly coped and welded joints, it's a work of art in and of itself.
My daughter is an engineer at a plant that makes the upper part of auto doors. Flat stock is rolled into shape, miters cut and the pieces are jigged and welded into the upper part of the door that frames the side windows- think picture frame. The welds must be perfect such that no seam line is revealed once the piece is painted. There is some minor sanding to smooth the joint. Skilled welders can do work amazing to me.