Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

Posts

Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#1

Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Friend asked for advice on dealing with scratches on a gifted used table. It has been a while since I scrutinized a modern made piece of furniture. This one was made 20 years ago, by Pennsylvania House, a company with a good name in Colonial Furniture.


Picture 1 is the underside of a leaf. The wood is solid cherry, finished at 1" thickness. The top is assembled from strips of cherry more narrow than I would ever use and with no consideration of sapwood inclusion or clashing grain pattern.

The skirt is fastened to the leaf with two brackets and a table top clip. I would have not risked the brackets for fear of constricting movement of the top. The success of this arrangement must mean there is enough flex of the brackets to accommodate changes in the top size with humidity changes.


From a distance the finish looks "high end". It has been ground glass-flat and then rubbed out to a luster approximating 4/0 wool and wax. Upon closer inspection the surface preparation is crude. Scratches from the sanding belt are readily seen, even in the picture. After what I would judge "rough" sanding the wood was sprayed with a cherry stain to uniform the color and then a wiping stain. The edges of the table are dark where the wiping stain was not wiped sufficiently.

The scratches were like I have never seen before. Turns out they were made by a cat. There was not any material missing from the scratches. Rather the scratch was a series of closely spaced compression fractures. The interface of the fracture and finish scattered light and showed up as a "scratch". They would not fill and disappear with pigmented wax and wool. They also would not consolidate with a lacquer consolidating spray.

Turns out the finish has degraded from 20 years in Florida sun. It was now brittle and not entirely soluble in the consolidating solvent. Hence, the scratches remained visible, though improved, after these treatments.

Stripping and refinish will be made more difficult by the deep sanding scratches. I am hopeful the friend becomes satisfied with it the way it is and I never see it again.

The table illustrates why I learned to make furniture. Factory furniture is often not made to a standard tolerable by anyone that appreciated quality woodworking. Custom made furniture is priced way beyond most persons means. I recently saw a smaller table in a galley and it was $5000, but nicely done.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#2

i once rebuilt a table for a friend

Bruce, a MN Galoot

using the wood from an existing table, i.e., taking the parts from the original and making something decent from them. My friend said not to worry about matching the construction or finish, since they were built back then and to higher standards.

So when you say, "Stripping and refinish will be made more difficult by the deep sanding scratches. I am hopeful the friend becomes satisfied with it the way it is and I never see it again."

I say Amen, and I hope to God I never see another table like that again. My finish was easily the equal of the original and my construction was vastly superior. But he was the customer, so he was free to think what he wanted.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#3

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

Brian Holcombe

WRT to manufactured furniture, you've got to go pretty far up the chain before you start seeing modern makers using methods that you might look at and enjoy.

Most of which are going to be making famous designs because the weight of that the design carries. The good will of the design will allow a bit more margin to adhere to quality construction. Many architects and designers were smart in that they required manufacturers to adhere to their specifications entirely.

Rud Rasmussen comes to mind for casegoods.

You often have to make your way to the blended line between studio and manufactured furniture to find that. BassamFellows comes to mind as a modern maker of top quality.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#4

What I found lacking....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....was quality of materials and finish, not construrction. The joinery in the table is excellent as evidenced by the fact it hadn't suffered structural failure in use. Modern factories excel at assembling stuff with precision cut joinery and methods. I find it impressive that they can make stuff in North Carolina, or China for that matter, ship it anywhere, and the joinery survives. This feat is enabled by precise humidity control during manufacture, robust and precise joinery and optimum gluing.

However, panels are randomly assembled from cuttings from as low a grade lumber as can be economically turned into these cuttings. For example, this table top is assembled from 2-3" cherry strips, cut no doubt, from a #1 Common grade of lumber. The striped "butcher block" result is disguised with stain applied to a sanded surface scored by parallel line panel sanding scratches which uniform the surface appearance. The result is a panel that looks uniform in color and grain, from a distance.

Were I to finish this panel with my sanding and staining schedule the result would look like a finely finished butcher block, even from a distance, because my finishing schedule enhances the grain and clarity of whatever surface is there. I must rely on pretty lumber to get a pretty result.

We have furniture made before 1940 from my family and my wife's family. Our factory-made ordinary, for the day, table is assembled from 10-12" wide maple boards and it refinished beautifully. The table is as good as I could make. My wife's family furniture was custom made in a small shop in Utica, NY. Her father was a middle class insurance salesman, yet the family could/did afford handmade mahogany furniture. Again, the furniture is as good as I could make. Not sure why this quality of furniture is priced way beyond the range of middle class now days.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#5

Re: What I found lacking....

Dick Coers

We bought a vintage mahogany dining set years ago. Very high style, magnificent crotch figure veneer on the side board doors. It had been neglected and I decided to refinish it. When stripped, I could see that the top of the sideboard had not been edge banded with mahogany, but had a solid core of poplar which was now showing all around. It was contoured with a serpentine front, and large radii where the front transitioned to the sides. So hard to get a mahogany edge with the veneer. I had no choice but the stain the piece. My point? Even in the 40s or 50s when this was made, the finisher had his methods to blend and conceal.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#6

Reliability rather than appearance.

Brian Holcombe

The manufacturer is prioritizing reliability over appearance. Thin strips are much more reliable than wide boards because with wide boards the maker must be careful and select wisely.

With thin strips, just swap grain direction every other and paint it with that red stain....all set....looks good from 50ft as they say and not likely to cup significantly.

With wide boards if you get one that doesn't behave itself, then you're sending a repair person out to replace that table top.

This is OK with top end furniture because we're willing to take the risk and also willing to build counterbalance into the product.

The other downside to wide boards is that they cost considerably more money now and are very difficult to purchase in quantity. They also significantly increase your waste because you're cutting away the junk.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#7

I can top that one

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

:) I decided to refinish my mother's "mahogany" silverware chest. The whole chest was poplar!

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#8

Re: I can top that one

john lucas

I bought a walnut table when I just got out of college. Got it from a junk store. Needed refinishing. It was butternut dyed to look like walnut. I was too new at woodworking back then and never got it to look like walnut. I did look good and we kept it for many years.

Re: Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table

#9

Butternut

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is one of the few woods I don't stain. It is a handsome wood varnished. With the increasing rarity of butternut that table would be worth some more than you paid for it.