Scrunity of a Pennsylvania House brand table
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Friend asked for advice on dealing with scratches on a gifted used table. It has been a while since I scrutinized a modern made piece of furniture. This one was made 20 years ago, by Pennsylvania House, a company with a good name in Colonial Furniture.

Picture 1 is the underside of a leaf. The wood is solid cherry, finished at 1" thickness. The top is assembled from strips of cherry more narrow than I would ever use and with no consideration of sapwood inclusion or clashing grain pattern.
The skirt is fastened to the leaf with two brackets and a table top clip. I would have not risked the brackets for fear of constricting movement of the top. The success of this arrangement must mean there is enough flex of the brackets to accommodate changes in the top size with humidity changes.

From a distance the finish looks "high end". It has been ground glass-flat and then rubbed out to a luster approximating 4/0 wool and wax. Upon closer inspection the surface preparation is crude. Scratches from the sanding belt are readily seen, even in the picture. After what I would judge "rough" sanding the wood was sprayed with a cherry stain to uniform the color and then a wiping stain. The edges of the table are dark where the wiping stain was not wiped sufficiently.
The scratches were like I have never seen before. Turns out they were made by a cat. There was not any material missing from the scratches. Rather the scratch was a series of closely spaced compression fractures. The interface of the fracture and finish scattered light and showed up as a "scratch". They would not fill and disappear with pigmented wax and wool. They also would not consolidate with a lacquer consolidating spray.
Turns out the finish has degraded from 20 years in Florida sun. It was now brittle and not entirely soluble in the consolidating solvent. Hence, the scratches remained visible, though improved, after these treatments.
Stripping and refinish will be made more difficult by the deep sanding scratches. I am hopeful the friend becomes satisfied with it the way it is and I never see it again.
The table illustrates why I learned to make furniture. Factory furniture is often not made to a standard tolerable by anyone that appreciated quality woodworking. Custom made furniture is priced way beyond most persons means. I recently saw a smaller table in a galley and it was $5000, but nicely done.
I decided to refinish my mother's "mahogany" silverware chest. The whole chest was poplar!


