Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Follow up on the tool Auction.

Posts

Follow up on the tool Auction.

#1

Follow up on the tool Auction.

Barry Irby

I posted a few days ago looking for some help with a tool auction and got some good advice. I went to the preview and checked out the stuff. There were several major Powermatic tools that appeared essentially new. The Hollow Chisel mortiser, Bandsaw and Jointer looked as if they had never been used.

I wanted the jointer. It was an 8" long bed jointer with a spiral cutter head that sells for about $3K. Including the auction fees it went of about $1800. Considering it weighs about 750 lbs and is in a basement with a long up hill trek across a squishy yard, I passed. It would cost me $400 to rent a truck and some guys to move it. I was afraid we would knock it out of alignment manhandling it.

I took a swing at the bandsaw, a PM 1500. It sells for about $2800 retail and it went for almost $3000 at the sale. I passed.

The Hollow Chisel Mortiser Went for pretty much retail. Passed.

There was a Festool TS 55 REQ track saw that sells on Amazon for $660. It sold for $750 at the Auction. There was some track and parts that looked to retail for $700+/_ and sold at the auction for about $750. There was a Multifunction Table that may not have been complete and it sold for more than new.

Lots of other stuff. I bid on some but got outbid.

My goal at an auction is to get the stuff for a third or maybe half of retail. There were some exceptionally nice things here, but I am still not going to pay full retail.

Aren't Auctions grand?

Re: Follow up on the tool Auction.

#2

Re: Follow up on the tool Auction.

Lee Schierer in McKean, PA

My experience at auctions where tools are involved is that many buyers don't know what the tools actually sell for and they end up paying full retail or more. You also have to be careful at trade shows because sometimes "Show Specials" really aren't so special.

Lee

Re: Follow up on the tool Auction.

#3

I love/hate Auctions

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I love tool auctions. But hate them all at the same time! If there are 1,000 tools for sale and only one that I want, that's the one everyone else wants too.

We are in Amish country where I live. Many years ago I went to a tool auction where there were a lot of powermatic machines and other tools of all kinds. The auction was largely attended by Amish guys. I was younger and naive back then. I arrogantly assumed that Amish guys were tight with money. I was sure I would be winning bids all day. Boy was I WRONG!!

The Amish guys all showed up with wads of cash that could choke a horse. They bid top dollar and often surpassed the retail prices. All I ended up getting that day was an education. ;-)

T.

Re: Follow up on the tool Auction.

#4

OT Continuing thought on auction post.

Gary Smyth

Few get into auctions and house sales more than me. I can get caught up as much as anyone for something I want and/or is difficult to find, but it got me to thinking. What is considered a good deal? I'm NOT talking art or cars or one off. Those subjects are a completely different matter. But for normal stuff, clearly, retail price is useless, and even 80% of it is nothing to me.

I don't live in a major urban area so prices aren't artificially high and the number of buyers is limited. Question. What it the general consensus of what percentage of retail would you consider a good deal for a good condition used item?

20% for me is great, and around here achievable. 60% would be on the high side of a good deal. I don't set sale prices and never try to negotiate a good deal even lower (except to maybe say is that your best price?) as my personal code of "fairness" is such, but what is "good"?

Re: Follow up on the tool Auction.

#5

Re: I love/hate Auctions

tom

I also live close to Amish country. Went to an auction at a high school where they were selling off the Industrial Arts equipment. 30+ year old equipment that was pretty beat up going for more than new. Crazy!