Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

OT Saving plaster ceilings.

Posts

OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#1

OT Saving plaster ceilings.

TomD

I am on the east coast of Canada again, taking the 90 year old folks to some surgeries.

At the same time, part of one of their ceilings fell in, and I want to re-plaster it and shore it up, and one other small room.

I need focused help, the ground rules are that I can't use anything that Home Depot doesn't have, none of then around here have plaster. Despite the fact that all the houses around here are 19th century and plastered they don't have specific plaster products, including plaster itself, or ceiling repair stuff/stabilization or bonding stuff. I have to start clean-up and repairs in a few hours, though probably won't get to the actual work till Tuesday. I will not be drywalling the repairs because there isn't any appropriate structure for that. If they go that route they have two quotes. If I blow the repair, the worst case is a few square feet more for the anticipated tear-out if they have contractors in.

There are three things I need answered, and if anyone can cross-post on places like the JCL that might help.

- The area to be re-plastered is about 4x4 feet. There is lots of good looking lath above, with particle glass insulation above, which seems to be staying in place (but I can't wet the plaster in from above). The repair strategy these days seems to be to drill holes through the plaster and inject a glue. I have done this kind of repair on fallen drywall ceilings, and I use great stuff foam, in this case it might be too likely to squeeze the plaster off the ceiling. You drill pairs of holes on either side of the crack and inject your glue, and put a temp fastener up the crack, once stable you take the fastener out, and patch. Seems to be preferred to setting screws and then repairing a forrest of screw heads. So the main question is has anyone used simple to get materials to do this; what did you use; any better proven ideas that don't rely on stuff you can't get in HDs that just sell paint and drywall. We are talking gorilla PU glue; PL premium; no nails; or great stuff which is a PU foam

- The exposed lath looks pretty easy to plaster, my approach will be clean lath; prime with cement bond and water; "brown" coat with Durabond or sheetrock 90 (any ideas which), 2 coats, some bonding agent in the mix of that stuff and it sticks to plastic, it will be worked between the lath like the original coat. Then finish the surface with light conventional drywall compound as it is the only thing I can work like a finish plaster, though it will be soft, sorry no skimcoat plaster, maybe use some glass cloth to solidify the ceiling joints.

- Third question is on a new plaster jobs guys will tape the ceiling to wall joint, but there is no tape here. If I embed tape I will destroy finishes on the wall and have to deal with all of that.

The idea is to do a good job, that we could live in, but the fact is they are selling the house.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#2

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

Barry Irby

I googled "Plaster Washers" and it suggests Home Depot has them but apparently they have to be ordered in. You might check and see if your local store with get them in for you in time to help on your job. I assuming you know that the idea is to screw through them into the lath and support the plaster and then finish over them. I have used them with mixed results. I also used a piece f plywood on top of a flexible stick to help press the plaster back up.

I have used 90 minute mud to do drywall repairs. Tried the twenty minute version. Don't. It's twenty minutes from mixing to set. About five minutes to install it. I have never tried to rebuild or repair plaster with it. I am skeptical. I suspect it will crack without reinforcement. I would bed fiberglass drywall tape in it in every direction. In fact, I would buy fiberglass window screen and bed that in it for 100% coverage. I have used that before on large drywall repairs and it work well.

I don't think I would try the plaster route. Personally not that skilled with a trowel and still skeptical. I would check the thickness of the plaster and buy drywall the same or slightly thinner. Cut a piece of drywall like a piece of a jigsaw puzzle and glue and screw it into place, screwing to joists where I could and lath every where else. Then tape and repair the seams like a drywall repair and then maybe skim coat it.

Good luck with the surgeries.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#3

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

TomD

Thanks. My plaster skill are good, but this is my first ceiling repair. Most seem to suggest gluing it back up which doesn't really create confidence in me. Glues eventually shear. But they say it is better than screwing.

That is what I like about great stuff, it can get up into the lath, it is seriously sticky, and seriously structural. Normally when doing celings with it (fallen drywall) I screw it back so there is a screw pulling the drywall against a sticky hardened foam spacer.

I agree with you about he scrim, I will do that.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#4

JL

Been there, done that

JL

I had to plaster a section of ceiling as well as behind the radiators in my first house. It was plaster and lath construction that had many layers of paint on wallpaper.

What I ended up doing was cleaning off all the old plaster in the damaged, crumbled sections and take out some of the lath strips.

I fastened sections of expanded lath. I then put a brown coat and a finish coat.

The expanded metal lath retains the brown coat much easier (IMO, YMMV) and I found it to be a reasonable repair.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#5

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

Barry Irby

Just can't visualize using Great Stuff in this situation. It is seriously sticky, but the expansion is very powerful. I was building a house for a friend and he wanted to put it under his cast iron tub to spread the load onto the floor. So we did. Picked the four hundred pound tub up about 3/4 of and inch. Took hours to get it back down.

Wonder if the low pressure stuff would work? I just can't figure how to get it there from below without blowing the plaster off the ceiling. I can see doing it from above, but then you would have to move the insulation. I hate touching insulation.

I do like PL400 and PL500. Good stuff.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#6

Kneale Brownson

I've used furring strips and ceiling tiles.

Kneale Brownson

If you have failing plaster somewhere in a ceiling, most likely you'll eventually have failing plaster elsewhere in that ceiling.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#7

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

William Duffield

For scratch coat, use Structo-Lite or Gunite (Shotcrete). Mix it by hand, so the keys have enough strength to stick between the laths.

For finish coat, use either Dura-Bond (90 minute) or Easy-Sand.

To reattach loose plaster to the ceiling, use drywall washers with drywall screws. If you have wood lath, probably the 2" screws will hold best. Cover the washers with the finish coat.

https://demandproducts.com/OWA/Product/Keyword?__r=0.291575586093392&keywords=DP525


Demand Droducts DP525

www.demandproducts.com

1-800-325-7540

They deliver very quickly, 2 days using USPS. You can't find these at the Borg.

They cut down the white oaks to hew my house's timber frame 290 years ago. With a house that old, you can learn a lot about how to, and how not to, fix plaster. I am not a professional plasterer myself, nor do I play one on TV, but I have one sitting right next to me as I write this, and my father, my uncle, and both grandfathers were professional plasterers.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#8

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

TomD

Unfortunately not in Canada.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#9

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

TomD

Barry I have done it both with the expansion foam when a ceiling got wet and sagged off a row of fastening in the middle of a panel. I drilled holes, injected foam, and then when the foam expanded and set, I drove screws though the holes or maybe just to one side. 20 years and running. Of course I had to fair in the bulge, but that was easy.

On this I will use low expansion stuff. Shoot it through the holes and press to ceiling with t supports or screw. Around the Collapse a good deal of the ceiling seems attached. But some is loose, an there there is some access from side. Anotherr room has a big central crack, you can't see throug it, but I think with a little work I could get the foam in through that, then fender washers.

I got back from the store with 4 different kinds of glue. All but one of which I have some experience with: Gorilla in a cartridge. I intend to see if I can glue the channels since shear in stronger.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#10

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

William Duffield

Sorry, I was afraid that might be the case. There should be some source of plaster or drywall washers in Canada, but I just don't know where to look. I can't imagine that Canadian restoration plasterers don't demand these essential fasteners from their suppliers.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#11

Re: I've used furring strips and ceiling tiles.

William Duffield

That depends on the extent of the water leak above the ceiling. IF you can stop the leak and secure the solid part of the ceiling before too many of the keys fail (before the neighbors upstairs have their next wild party :D ), it can last indefinitely. But every key that fails puts more stress on the keys next to it.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#12

Re: Is it even possible?

TomD

https://www.nps.gov/tps/how-to-preserve/briefs/21-flat-plaster.htm

A little less reliable, but closer to what I have

http://www.oldtownhome.com/2013/11/8/How-To-Fix-Plaster-Like-a-Boss-Sand-Baby-Sand/

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#13

Re: Is it even possible?

Barry Irby

I am assuming you know this, but the plaster does adhere to the laths. At least not in the long run. The "secret" is that it oozes through the cracks and bulges or curls around the laths and holds on mechanically, forming "keys". Over time gravity works its magic, along with seasonal changes in the size of the laths, vibration and whatever and the keys break off. Worse and more detrimental on ceilings. I'm not sure you can actually glue the plaster to the laths successfully over a long period of time.

Of course, a "long period of time" is relative. Depending on your attitude a few months may be enough. You are selling the house, right? If you only have to give the buyer the "out of sight" guarantee, how good is your conscience?

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#14

Re: Is it even possible?

TomD

The articles note that it is possible and the better option, so conscience is not the issue. Plus if people want real plaster, as some do, they can't assume to much. Let's say my repair works, which so far in this life has always been the case, but this is a new one to me to some extent, some totally different part of this or another house could fall on them. It is always assumed that maximum disclosure is what consumers want, which can amount to talking them out of a sale for something they actually want to buy, and lead to them buying their second favourite house from a less honest person who did repairs and had no skills. (Though in this case it isn't my house. I think it may be sold this year, but my folks have tried that one before several times.)

Not sure that is how it worked out this afternoon. There is a large gap in places, which I think I can deal with, but as usual best laid plans didn't survive the first contact with the enemy. I shot a whole can of foam in an area about 3x3 feet, no problem, next will be to rig some fasteners.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#15

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

don stephan

Guess I'll be the contrarian. Glue and expansion foam are not the proper products to use. And if they fail, the next repair will so much more difficult because of the glue and expansion foam. Plaster washers can pull back against the wall plaster that is coming loose, but you have to slowly tighten several in an area to slowly ease the plaster back in place.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#16

Re: Is it even possible?

Joseph Mulherin

Tom, you said the place will be sold soon, so my suggestion is to buy a piece of drywall thick enough to fill the area properly; lay out a pattern on the ceiling and sabresaw it out. Add new insulation as needed; the make the same pattern on the sheet of drywall, cut it out with beveled edges and screw it to the rafters.

Install some fibergalss seam tape, sticky, then install three coats of mud and build it up to finish layers...

sand even and vacuum up everything.

Before you start doing the demolishion of the ceiling patch, remove all furniture or cover with visqueen, and lay visqueen on the entire floor for future cleanliness.

Re: OT Saving plaster ceilings.

#17

Re: Is it even possible?

Joseph Mulherin

addendum: Tom, you have said there is no suitable structure for screwing the drywall to.....so again I make this suggestion... buy some 1/4" wingnut fasteners long enough....insert the screw into a coned washer, detent it into the drywall for covering later with mud.....drill into the the present ceiling structure with the wingnuts and screw the drywall up in place as needed.....do the edges as I said befre and sand until it looks nice......then repaint.