If you have an iPad, have you tried using thr maps app as a gps? If what you are interested in is driving directions from point to point this works very well.
I use Google Maps on my iPad all the time. It will calculate directions and give you voice commands just like a GPS system (it is a GPS system). One of my cars has a built in navigation system that displays on the car's info screen and it gives directional commands over the car's speaker system. It is more convenient to use than the iPad, but frankly, I like Google Maps better. My wife and I navigated all over Ireland last Spring with Google Maps and an iPad. It works on your smart phone too.
Google maps on my cell phone works for me. I have a Garmin in our camper, but I prefer the Google maps. Just plug in an address and ask for directions.
I need wifi for my tablet, no data plan for it, so I have a Garmin in the car. It's a cheap one, but still very happy with it. Shouldn't you be asking a navigation device instead of GPS? Asking for GPS might just give you coordinates, navigation gives you directions as you drive. But, you can type in GPS coordinates into a navigation device and still get directions, LOL!
I have owned a couple of units and used a couple of others and never found any that were overwhelmingly better than others in the same price range. One thing I'd advise is, when you choose, make sure that it comes with 'lifetime' (whatever that might be) updates -- nothing worse than to find that the road being suggested does not exist any more or has been moved or that there is a new and better shortcut not shown in a data set several years old.
Garmin with lifetime map updates and lifetime traffic. The traffic capability can often reroute you around a trouble spot before you know there is a traffic problem. It will at least give you an advance warning so you can be more alert to an impending problem.
I use the Google Maps App on my Android smart phone. I get my cell service from Virgin Mobile (Sprint). It works automatically with Google Maps on my iMac at home using Safari, so I can use the iMac to look up addresses and routes, and check traffic and weather. When I turn on the cellphone in my car, it automatically communicates with the recent routes and destinations I researched on my home computer. When I'm on the road, it gives me real time traffic updates and recommends alternate routes when traffic gets bad. If I need to go somewhere unplanned, it accepts voice commands to find street addresses, businesses, government buildings, landmarks, etc. If I'm driving and travel outside the Sprint service area, it has pre-stored my planned route and destination and continues to provide driving instructions using its GPS functionality. Google Maps on my cell phone communicates with Google Maps on the internet in real time, so if I or anyone else using Google gets caught in traffic slowdown, we all get informed immediately of the problem and alternative routes. If I'm trying to get to a business location, it even tells me if the business is open, closed, or closing soon. The apps and the mapping service are all free if you have WiFi at home and a data plan on your smart phone.
Alternatives? I've had two different Magellans. They suck. They had battery, database and power cable failures, were always losing GPS satellite signals, and don't support updates to their mapping database from the MacOS. They also wouldn't inform me of database updates, which were few and far between at best. Unlike with Google and Android, their models with the largest screens didn't provide any higher resolution maps than their most primitive models. Their user interface was apocryphal, and they often lied about traffic detours and directions in general.
I have a Garmin Nuvi that is at least ten years old. I like it and would recommend it. My son got a newer and bigger one. He likes it also. Might want to find one that takes voice commands.
I was not aware that Google maps was as robust as others have made it sound. I am a Luddite with this technology. Not sure I have the patients to figure out WiFi, data plans, synchronization, etc. I have used my Cell phone (Apple I phone) on several occasions when my Garmin let me down. My experience was similar to several other peoples. Right when you need it, you get a phone call and the map evaporates. I'm sure we were doing something wrong, but right in the rush our is no tome to figure it out. I like the dedicated aspect of the Garmin. You program where and just follow along and the phone does not interrupt it.
I did not get the perpetual maps. I figured that by the time I wanted to update the maps I would be wanting to buy the newer version with superior features and size. I have not regretted that. The bare bones unit is cheaper. they add significantly to the original cost to cover updates. Just buy a new one and get new maps and new features.
We have a Garmin. I found it more intuitive to navigate. There are dozens of models of this product. We went cheap. It is great in cities as it tells you what lane to be in for interchanges and the like. We breezed through LA from south to north on a Monday AM and knowing which of 6 lanes to be in reduced the stress.
It is also handy locally, I needed to find someone locally. Rather than receiving a string of directions they just gave me an address and Balinda (her name) found it.
Also, we use it to eat. Find yourself in East Overshoe OK needing lunch? Just search local places to eat. We lucked upon an outstanding BBQ lace.
But, it can do stupid routing. It is bewildered by Ashville, NC. Always check a route out before committing.
We have a Garmin Nuvi with voice command. You can speak to it and it generally finds what you are looking for, which is pretty handy if you are alone. Just remember that the GPS is most useful when you don't know how to get there. If you already know the route, the GPS may find a shorter route, but it may not be as convenient as the one you are used to.
The advantage of a GPS over a tablet or phone is that it works from the satellites and does not depend on cell signals. There are lots of places where the cell signal is not sufficient for navigating. The GPS will also calculate a new route if you happen to miss a turn. Google maps doesn't always do that and can't if you downloaded a map at home.
Over the years I've had at least 8 Garmins, two TomToms, and one I bought at the dawn of civilization that didn't even have maps. I have three Garmins now in various vehicles and the new Jeep has Garmin nav built in. I like the Garmins better than the TomToms. (Any new GPS is far better than even the most expensive years ago!)
I've used these all over the US and in Mexico and Europe.
I prefer a dedicated GPS over using the phone. The mounts, power, features (such as lane detail - do the phone apps to that now?), controls, speakers, and operating speed are designed for automobile use. (And it is expensive to use a lot of cell phone data traveling in Europe.)
We do plan routes ahead of time and save maps as screen captures on the large screen ipad, overall route and successively closer views at critical junctions and destinations. This is our primary route guidance. With the saved maps no cell services is needed on the ipad. Besides, we have been in many places such as far in the mountains on both sides of the Atlantic where there is no cell service anyway.
We were delighted to find that the Garmin even had the National Forest dirt roads available, at least in WY and CO. That was handy going across the Big Horns where roads branched off periodically and the correct through route was unclear by eye.
The advantage of a GPS over a tablet or phone is that it works from the satellites and does not depend on cell signals.
In Oz my TomTom on the iPhone works from the satellite. No Internet connection is required. I cannot recall if this was the case in the USA when I was last there a few years ago.
I haven't looked into any tech data, but I'm certain my Androids (I had a Samsung S4, now using a Motorola moto) uses GPS satellites. It can tell just a few feet after I didn't turn where it told me to turn. I just type the destination address into the Google search, and it finds the location, then there's an icon for a route, then a navigate icon. I have only used this in a few places in the US, but its wonderful.
I also have an older Garmin, with free lifetime map updates, but the memory is insufficient. I have to pick a favored quadrant of the country, and then in the other quads the information is quite limited.
I have had Magellan and Garmin, I would not do without one in my vehicle. The Magellan did not have free map updates, in fact the cost to update (one time) was a significant amount of the cost of a new unit. So I purchased a Garmin about 6~7 years ago and have been very satisfied with the unit. You do have to update the unit in less than one year intervals or you lose the lifetime free map features. I have had to purchase a memory chip as I ran out of memory a couple of years ago.
The battery is just about gone, but really doesn't affect the unit as I always keep it energized when the vehicle is on. I may purchase a new Garmin soon as they have a bigger screen and a lot of new features.
I find the GPS to be a safety feature as I don't have to watch for road signs or try to figure what lane I should be in (shows on the screen). This allows me to watch traffic more closely and eliminates the "last minute" lane changes. Mine has the voice instructions so don't even have to look at the screen often.
From what I have experienced the Garmin does have excellent maps, in my opinion better than the competition (but I haven't compared for several years). The software is very easy to use when updating, When I plug the unit into my computer USB port, it takes over and searches the web for all updates, both software and maps, then auto downloads and installs. The only issue is that it does sometimes take quite a long time to do the update. I usually do this when I will not be using my computer for some hours (yeah hours). When I purchase a new unit it will be another Garmin.
I used a Garmin for years. Even made a little plexiglass pad for it to sit on in the car console. I find Google maps on my iPhone to be just as effective and much simpler to engage and I don't have to update before every trip.