My son is renting an apartment in Alexandria, VA. the Building is about 70 years old and three stories and has 2 1/4" Oak T&G flooring. He lives on the third floor and his neighbor below counts the squeaks. He has carpets everywhere including the hall but the hall is still noisy. He takes his shoes off, but they seem to like to complain.
I know lots of things to try, but I was checking to see if the Brain Trust had some really good ideas.
Though I haven't tried it I heard it works. Use baby powder and dump it on the floor, work it into the joints and cracks. The idea is it is suppose to "lubricate" the wood where it is rubbing.
Barry, surely this is a problem to be addressed by the owner of the apartment?
The best fix for the job would be to contact the owner and explain the situation (that your son is being badgered by a neighbour). This problem would have been present for some time prior to your son moving in, so it is likely to be a well known one.
Your son should not be tip-toeing around to appease his neighbour - that is as as intrusive for him as the noises are for the neighbour. Complaints from the neighbour should be directed to the owner, not your son.
Buy your son a basketball to dribble around for a few weeks. When the neighbor moves, the problem is gone. ha
70 years old, probably means diagonal ship lap pine subfloor, so lots of potential movement down there that I don't think you can fix.
Some squeaks are due to flex between joist, where tight substrate parts rub against each other. If this is a top layer, running a circular saw down them to widen that space will help.
I always tried to make sure all nails go into the joist. Some squeaks are due to flex in the floor and subfloor moving separately causing the nails to rub / resonate.
Gluing during assembly is the best way to avoid this. If the subfloor was shot down with a gun, but the shooter wasn't backing away from the line he's shooting, the nail can pass through parts without pulling them down, so there is a space under that a person's weight will make it ride up and down on the nail. I'm always riding my helpers to stand close to where they shoot, so their weight pushes the parts together tight. I used to hold a small scrap of wood between my thumb and finger, then shoot a nail through it, without knocking it out to demonstrate the need.
If the landlord will not do the repair for both your convenience and the neighbor.....then I can suggest this: Go to see Tom Silva on the home repair program he is on and he has a method of using a break-off screw that does the floors really good using a break-off screw.
My 1970’s bungalow had 1x4s laid on the diagonal nailed to the joists (16” on centre) as subfloor. 3/8” particle board was nailed over that as base for linoleum. It squeeked everywhere. Luckily I had lived there for 40 years, so knew where not to step when I didn’t want to wake the baby
Three years ago I ripped up the old particle board. I used about a thousand floor screws to eliminate every squeak in the house, screwing the diagonal 1x4’s tightly onto the joists. I then laid a new layer of ½” plywood down over the 1x4s, using another 1000 screws (a screw about every 8”). Hardwood flooring was nailed down over the plywood.
Voila, no more squeeks…but it’s not a job that can be done without ripping up the floor.
Barry, did you get the chance of going to "ThisOldHouse.com" and type in fixing a squeaky floor and see what Tom Silvas did to quiten the floors using the break-off screws?He also used two different screws both longer and shorter depending on the subfloor and floor joists locations and structures.
You do NOT need to rip up the old flooring to quiet the existing floor! And a color crayon will fill in the holes.
I did. I have bought the kit with the gadget and the screws, etc. I will take to my son's place in Alexandria during the Christmas break and he and I will do our best. and you are right, I have quieted many floors without ripping them out. My son does not want managment in his apartment any more than necessary. He works and it difficult to take time off to meet them. Rather spend a few bucks and do it myself than wait on them.