Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

I need advice/review on tools.

Posts

I need advice/review on tools.

#1

I need advice/review on tools.

Barry Irby

I have a chance to buy some tools at auction. Some of them appear very lightly used. I don't really need them, but they are pretty...so pretty.....

Anybody got anything good or bad to say about a Powermatic No 1500 Bandsaw?

(I have a 14" Delta with a Riser block)

How about a Powermatic 8" long bed jointer No. PJ882HH

(I have a Rockwell 6" Long Bed jointer I am considering upgrading to a Shelix head)

And A Dewalt 735 Planer with a Shelix head that has not even been installed.

(I have the older version with the two knife head I can sharpen myself.)

Any advice would be appreciated, even talking me down out fo the trees if you see fit.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#2

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

David Yoho

Barry, that jointer looks very close to the Powermatic 8" long bed jointer I looked at years ago before I went with the Delta 8" long bed jointer that I later added a Byrd Shelix head to. I thought the Powermatic was a great jointer but the sticker price moved me to the Delta.

As far as the Shelix cutter heads versus sharpening standard blades, the spiral cutter head does a very nice job of cutting smooth no matter the wood type or direction of feed. I would consider it more important to have on a jointer before a lunchbox type planner. My now-discontinued Delta 2-speed 13" planer does a pretty fair job leaving a nice surface on even the figured woods I've used. I don't see a need to upgrade my planer.

It probably boils down to price as to whether it makes sense for you to buy. My two cents would be since you're thinking about an upgrade for the head on your current jointer the 8" provides a better capacity, and can accommodate a Byrd head as well. On the other hand, if the extra capacity isn't important for the work you mostly do, then save the money and get the new head for your current jointer.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#3

JL

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

JL

I have a friend who installed a Shelix head on his DW735. It works well.

Opinion though - if I was going to be planing enough lumber to justify a Shelix head, I would consider a larger (15") planer.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#4

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

I rarely give input about tools. But, for what it's worth, a lot of my machines are Powermatic and I have no regrets.

T.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#5

Here's the deal.....

Barry Irby

I have tools I have had for 50 years. I have been planning to build furniture. Finally dawned on me that if I did not get busy, my kids were going to have an estate sale and get less for the tools than I paid forty or fifty years ago and use the wood I have stashed for fire wood.

So I have made beds for each of my two grand daughters and am making nightstands. And then dressers. And then.....

I bought some Festools recently at a similar auction and am liking them. And I got them cheap. Somebody else's kids got a dime on a dollar.

I have a love hate relationship with my bandsaw. If I can upgrade some of these things on the cheap....Merry Christmas to me.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#6

A different perspective

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Barry

I would utilise your funds differently.

The power machines I link as a team are the jointer, thicknesser/planer, and bandsaw.

I started with the classic set of 8" jointer and 12 1/2" thichnesser/planer. Eventually it dawned upon me that this was not a logical way to go about milling wood. Plus the thicknesser screamed like a banshee in heat, and the family protested.

You want to be able to joint what you can resaw (unless you plan to use hand planes). So a bandsaw that has, say, an 11-12" capacity requires a jointer with a 12" wide bed. Immediately you see that the 8" jointer is as ineffectual as your 6" one. What is the point of a 13-15" thicknesser if the boards you are working are only 6-8" wide?

So, what I did was purchase a combo jointer-planer. In my case I have a Hammer A3-31. This has a slightly shorter bed that the average 8" jointer, but it is the width that counts - just over 12". The model I have has a spiral head, which means it is both silent in use (really is) and easy to maintain. Plus the thicknesser is the same head, and is equally silent.

All this dovetails well with my bandsaw (Hammer 4400) which has a resaw capacity of 11 1/2".

Now I am not trying to sell you on the Hammer family - they are quite expensive. I mention them so you can refer to the machines I use. There are many other makes that do the same and cheaper, but I do not know of them in the US. What is important is that you can use them as a family.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#7

Re: A different perspective

Barry Irby

Thank you for your thoughtful reply.

I have thought about this in similar fashion , but never quite put it all together. I have been thinking inside the box. Never occurred to me to joint a panel.

I have a Delta 14" bandsaw with riser. The problem is its really a single purpose tool. You can tune it up to resaw, but then its not worth a damn at cutting bowl blanks or fretwork. Have to change the blade. Takes way too long to fiddle it back and forth. I would like to have a saw set up for resawing and dedicated to that to avoid a lot of fiddling. Then I could put an excellent blade on it and not worry about mangling the blade on a blank.

As for the jointer, if I can get it for the price of upgrading the head on the one I have, I'm in. If I can get the planer for the price of either the planer or the Byrd Shelix cutter head, I'm in. Part of this is the thrill of the hunt.

Did I mention there are some Festool items at this auction?

Incidentally, unless there are two of you, your are at least four times as productive as I am. I really admire your work.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#8

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

Tony-Memphis

I have the 735. Santa brought me the Shelix a few years ago. Great tool! It was already a nice tool, but the Shelix head does have some advantages. I had an issue with breaking some inserts (I think they were over torqued). Not lately though. Also, with a fresh set of knives, the finish is like glass. With the inserts, however, there is a slight ridging effect. Can't feel it and can only see it in the right angle/light. I assume the ridges are only sandpaper deep. What I really like is that I can plane figured wood with almost zero tear out. Seems like you can feed the wood any old way and it still comes out smooth. Installation was not difficult. I was a little anxious, but the directions were easy to follow and everything seems to work.

I have a 6" Griz planer and I'd love to have an 8". I like my Powermatic tools (T-saw and mortiser), so I would not be hesitant is the planer was in good shape, etc.

Good luck and Merry Christmas and Ho Ho Ho from you to you!

Tony

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#9

Re: A different perspective

Hank Knight

Barry, I understand your cost-benefit analysis and think it is sound. Powermatic makes good machines. I agree with Derek, however, about the benefits of a wide jointer planer. I know that most hobbyest woodworkers like me and you are perfectly happy with 8 inch jointers. I started out using my father's 6" Walker Turner jointer and was constantly frustrated with the inability to joint wider stock. I bought a little Inca 10 1/2" jointer planer and loved it for 25 years. Several years ago, I upgraded to a much heavier duty Hammer A3 31 like Derek's. I am a happy camper. With that machine and my Laguna 18" bandsaw, I can dress 90% of the lumber I'm likely to need from rough stock. The ability to joint flat and plane wide stock is a real benefit and a pleasure.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#10

Re: A different perspective

William Duffield

When you consider the price of each new machine, you should subtract the price you will be able to get when you sell the machine it replaces.

Derek is usually right, and I respect his opinions and often use his advice when I purchase tools, but this time he is wrong*. Your jointer only needs to be a smidgen wider than half the width of your planer. Is your rockwell jointer a parallelogram or a wedge bed design? I have a Delta Rockwell DJ-20 8" jointer that I'll get around to upgrading with a Byrd Shelix head one of these days, unless one of those Powermatics comes along first at a reasonable price. But I wouldn't trade "up" to any 12" jointer with a wedge bed, because I wouldn't be sure of being able to tune it to my standards, or much less keep it tuned.

I also am no fan of combo machines. The more moving parts and the more often you have to move them, the more you are going to put it out of spec and the more time you will spend tuning it up. That is an especially important issue when you are processing lots of boards for a large project. Switching between jointer and planer mode as you work the boards takes a lot of time and puts even more wear on the adjustable components of the combo machine. I much prefer to arrange my radial arm saw, jointer, planer, and table saw up for an efficient work flow, because it allows me to process a lot of rough sawn lumber very quickly into S4S cut to rough length without fiddling with setup changes on any of the machines.

Your description of the work you do with your bandsaws indicates that you need two bandsaws. For example, you can set one up for resawing and roughing bowl blanks and the other for cutting curves in thinner material, but there are other configuration options that you might find work better for the projects you spend most time on.

Every one of those Powermatic machines will be more faithful to you than a labrador retriever, and will outlive you and whoever you pass them on to.

*There's nothing wrong with being wrong; :) it happens to the best of us from time to time. What is important is that we are willing to change our opinions when experimentation and experience show us that something else works better.

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#11

Re: A different perspective

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek is usually right, and I respect his opinions and often use his advice when I purchase tools

Of course. :)

, but this time he is wrong*.

What! No!

Your jointer only needs to be a smidgen wider than half the width of your planer.

William, this needs explanation. Are you planning on reversing the board to plane the other half? What do you do with the guard?

But I wouldn't trade "up" to any 12" jointer with a wedge bed, because I wouldn't be sure of being able to tune it to my standards, or much less keep it tuned.

More explanation needed. Different construction types? Advantages and disadvantages?

I also am no fan of combo machines. The more moving parts and the more often you have to move them, the more you are going to put it out of spec and the more time you will spend tuning it up.

I can only speak for the Hammer. It has not lost a setting in the three years I have had it. This particular machine is built like a tank. I am sure that Hank would say the same. It is interesting that so few, if any, of these machines come onto the second-hand market (in Oz, at least). Either they are too poorly made or they are too well made.

That is an especially important issue when you are processing lots of boards for a large project. Switching between jointer and planer mode as you work the boards takes a lot of time and puts even more wear on the adjustable components of the combo machine.

William, the wear issue is hypothetical, however some indeed do not like switching between setups, and prefer separate machines. I would have separate machines if I had the space. If I were a pro, I would absolutely want the extra efficiency that comes from separates. I accept the limitations of a combo because, again I can only speak for the Hammer, the change over is quick. What one learns to do is plan work and become efficient that way.

I really value the 12" jointer. As mentioned earlier, it makes it possible to process wide boards. This aspect just cannot be stated frequently enough. In the case of the Hammer, the Euro Guard (in contrast to the Lamb Chop type) promotes a safer work process.

The carbide bits on the spiral head are outstanding for their longevity. The head may be doing double duty but the carbide outlasts the HSS blades by an order of 10 times or more.

The reason I have come back to reply to your post is that I find this machine, with the wide jointer, is as much of a game changer - for the amateur like myself - as the CBN wheel has been for sharpening among flat woodworkers (and you should see how that is taking off now!).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I need advice/review on tools.

#12

Re: A different perspective

Hank Knight

William, I'm going to agree with Derek on this one. The space limitations of my shop dictate that if I'm going to have powered jointing and planing capability, it has to be combination machine. I've had and used J/P combos for over thirty years. Apart from the inconvenience of reconfiguring the machine between functions, the "shortcomings" of J/P combo machines you describe are nonexistent. Reconfiguring the machine between functions, while a nominal inconvenience at worst, is nevertheless an inconvenience. It is the price I happily pay for having powered jointing and planing capability in my tiny shop.

The differences between the two machines I have owned are huge. My little 10 1/2" Inca 570 was light weight, on a wooden stand and looked to be delicate. But the design of that machine was a masterpiece. For all it's light weight and apparent delicacy, it was a work horse. The change-over between functions was quick and easy. It returned to its correct settings with absolute reliability and no fuss, and it consistently produced excellent surfaces. It had a Tersa quick-change cutterhead, and blade changes took all of about a minute. I owned and used it heavily for over 25 years and I never experienced any wear-related issues with the machine. My best friend now owns and still uses this machine.

My current 12" Hammer J/P combo is a tank. I cannot imagine wear ever being a concern with this machine. It maintains its settings faithfully between changeovers, requires little, if any, adjustment once it it tuned up. It does everything that my little Inca did in spades. The only practical difference between the two machines is that the Hammer has a more robust power feed mechanism than the Inca. That, and the additional 1 1/2" capacity, are the reasons I made the switch. I love it.

Like Derek, and probably most other combo machine owners, if I had the space and the dollars, I would opt for separate machines. But I don't. Nevertheless, I don't feel at all deprived. In fact, I feel particularly privileged to have had two such a fine machines in my shop.