Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Wood flooring question

Posts

Wood flooring question

#1

JL

Wood flooring question

JL

We share our house with several cats. Unfortunately some of them have good "floor distressing kits" - and we have a pine floor that was installed by the previous owners. So when they do the Hanna-Barbera thing, it has a tendency to take off the poorly applied finish.

The current floor also wears at the sink, stove and refrigerator.

One choice is to sand the current floor and put down a finish that would resist scratching - but I can't think of one that would work on a soft pine floor.

The other choice is to purchase new flooring (ideally wood or a wood product) that would wear better.

If we get new flooring, what would be suitable?

Wood bamboo work (less expensive, possibly more sustainable agriculture)? Should I consider a hardwood? Should I consider a laminate?

Thanks

Re: Wood flooring question

#2

Re: Wood flooring question

John Veerkamp

We put down a real 3/4 oak T&G floor in our kitchen 13 years ago. It has some wear and dings but still looks good. It has a factory applied pre-cat finish. It is easy to keep clean. I'd do it again if the need arose.

Re: Wood flooring question

#3

Hickory

John M in Mid Mich

We have 2 cats (with claws) and currently 2 dogs (previously 3: shorthair pointers, viszla). Entire main floor is in 3/4" finish-in-place Hickory. Second floor bedrooms are pre-finished bamboo. Both stand up incredibly well to various rough-housing behaviors. We settled on the hickory specifically as probably the best for handling dog claws. The finish also matters, of course. At ca. 13 years, we're into our second finish with Bona "Traffic" and think it is fantastic (would still have the original finish if we hadn't caused a flood from the kitchen sink). We do have one small room in pine that is a wreck especially where dogs launch out the door if a squirrel is in the yard. Now we try to remember to have them launch from the hickory at a different door.

Re: Wood flooring question

#4

Re: Wood flooring question

Barry Irby

Quarter sawn white oak would be excellent. I read that bamboo is harder than oak and it would work well too. Use finish developed for High traffic areas. Varathane makes one with aluminum oxide in it and I used it on steps. Its holding up well.

As an aside, how much do you need? I have about 350 square feet of 5" wide predefined hickory I would like to sell for what I have In it. It's Allen and Roth brand and the face is 5" wide. Let me know if you have any interest.

Re: Wood flooring question

#5

JL

1000 sq. ft.

JL

Really interested in doing most of the main floor of the house in the same wood.

Then there is that transportation thing :b .

Re: Wood flooring question

#6

Re: Wood flooring question

paul in AZ

Yes on the hardwood. Either solid wood or engineered.

Bamboo may not be trauma-resistant enough.

I once went the laminate route on an enclosed porch in a summer cabin. Many laminates are resistant to water; most if not all are scratch and dent proof BUT it will never sound 'right' or feel right underfoot. So only as a last resort.

Re: Wood flooring question

#7

Re: Wood flooring question

Jim Dillon

JL, we have had six cats (all clawed) over the past 20 years (currently still have six), plus four 70 pound dogs over the same time period (currently have just one). Frankly, I cannot recall damage due to the cats on the flooring. Cat damage on vertical hardwood trim (plus drapes) is another story as is damage from the dogs on some of the flooring. We have vintage oak, locust, and heartwood pine flooring that we installed ourselves. We used Parks polyurethane flooring finish on all. Only the locust has been impervious to dog damage (to be fair, the oak flooring gets little use). The soft QSWO fir vertical trim has been shredded by the cats. Maybe there is a source of vintage (recycled) lumber in your area that might have locust. It is gorgeous IMHO.

Your situation is a tough call. Sanding the old finish off is almost as much work as ripping the flooring up and installing new. I seem to remember good recommendations for the Bona Kemi flooring finishes on WC but have no experience with that finish. Based on my experience with our soft pine flooring, the polyurethane finish remained reasonable intact, but the indentations from the dog claws still created grooves in the pine flooring. So, going to a harder wood might be the solution to your problem. Hope this helps. Jim