Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

Posts

A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#1

A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

Keith Newton

I was wondering if any of you saw this? I'm a little surprised that so many had a reaction.

Seems to me, that rather than dust, there must be some chemical out gassing that might could be taken care of by heating it up in a kiln for a while. Otherwise, I would imagine it would never come out of storage.


http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/cedar-sculpture-fbi-hospital_us_5841c06ae4b017f37fe46827

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#2

Western Red Cedar

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

is a known and very common irritant, and, in persons sensitive, can cause severe reactions. Mostly caused by the dust or bark, but with a hunk the size of that piece in an enclosed space, the extractives and native aromatics could easily have produced the reported symptoms.

Dumb choice of material. Sculptor should have known better, researched better. Return for a refund and let her sell it somewhere else. Like maybe to a pencil factory

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#3

also...

John in NM

I bet the ratio of surface area to mass and lots of exposed end grain didn't help!

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#4

Am I the only one offended by this????

Barry Irby

Does no one look at the possible consequences of these things? They spend hundreds of thousands of dollars of taxpayer money and don't look at what happens next. What could possibly go wrong? This looks like a "Here, hold my beer" moment to me.

The subject of wood allergies comes up here often. We rely on data probably published by the Forest Products Laboratory, another less glamorous part of the government. Perhaps the FBI should have investigated a little.

Dust? Lots of people have dust allergies. Perhaps the artist should have cleaned it thoroughly and sealed it before cashing the check. Or chose a less toxic wood.

On top of that, the thing looks like it might fall over and kill me.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#5

Barry, Lets face it, we don't really live in today

Keith Newton

In today's world. Did you see the hat Lady Gaga wore in the Victoria Secret deal? It had a price tag of $1,000,000.00 and supposedly took 300 hours to make. I want to be the mad hatter that makes $3,333.00 per hour.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#6

Re: Facing it

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

"Those people" live in a different world than us.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#7

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation

Paul Blackwell

"More than a million taxpayer dollars" for this piece of trash. Have these people have no conscience at all? They probably considered it a bargain at only a million or so.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#8

Re: Am I the only one offended by this????

Robin Corell in Atascadero

whoa! hang on a minute. The artist is extremely well known and has been working with cedar for over 30 years, mostly making large scale pieces similar to the one in the article. She has work in just about every big name collection and art museum in the world, the met, MOMA, the Smithsonian.... I have never heard of any previous issues with her work causing allergies.

Reading a few other articles about this there seems to be a contentious history between the GSA, who owns the building and the FBI. I wouldn't be surprised if this was a case of "male appendage sparring".

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#9

Re: Am I the only one offended by this????

Barry Irby

I do not know the artist. Perhaps I am jealous.

This may be a case of sick building syndrome. One person gets sick and many others follow suit. Sometimes there is a direct and real verifiable cause. Sometimes its psychosomatic. Or a mix.

If this artist is as well known as you say and paid as well as it appears and as experienced as you say, it seems unreasonable they would deliver a piece with enough dust on it to make people sick.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#10

Maybe a couple 55 gal barrels of shellac will help


Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#11

Nah, Needs More Than That

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

With the expressed inspiration of a tornado, there are two major deficiencies in this piece.

First is the situs. Why put this themed in the FBI lobby when it would be far more appropriate in a NOAA building. While it may, indeed, somewhat "activate" the tall atrium, it doesn't fit the space particularly well, and dies out at railing level on the second floor.

Second, the execution of form is unusually static for invoking the whirling violence that is a tornado. The is no sense of the prodigious rotational forces that do so much damage on the ground.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#12

Supporting living artists

Brian Holcombe

Is something the government can do as part of these types of installations. I don't see anything wrong with it.

Something like this, that has value as a art object which may increase over time, may actually do well for the government.

Good change that the building itself costs many multiples of that number and will be replaced at some point.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#13

Re: Nah, Needs More Than That

Robin Corell in Atascadero

I agree with you. I would think a hurricane would be more appropriate for Florida and I'm not sure it is what should be "memorialized", It's kind like making a big artwork of an earthquake for a public space in San Francisco, or a flood in New Orleans. kind of morbid and more importantly not really stretching the bounds of creativity.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#14

I used to think that way....

John in NM

Now I just see waste.

I'm sorry, but that money would have paved a few miles of road that desperately need it. Perhaps just one mile if they did it properly (I'm not impressed with new federal roadwork I've seen out here). I live within my means, I see no reason that the government cannot learn to do likewise.

Now if there were not a huge debt and crumbling infrastructure, I would have no problem with it. The piece in question is not to my taste, but tastes vary widely when it comes to art. I've even found myself getting fond of pieces I did not initially like once I've seen them often.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#15

Re: Nah, Needs More Than That

William Duffield

a hurricane would be more appropriate for Florida

I can assure you that a tornado is an appropriate weather symbol for the Sunshine State. I lived there for over 40 years and go back to visit regularly. In my time there, I've seen more tornados, funnel clouds, water spouts, peeled off roofs, flipped airplanes and disassembled mobile homes than I can count. They aren't the F5 monsters that terrorize the Okies, but what they lack in strength they make up for in numbers. The hurricanes and tropical storms usually spawn several.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#16

Re: Supporting living artists

Mark Hennebury

Government support them....How about they get jobs like the rest of us.

Personally, just about all art and the nonsense about it makes me sick.

But i can see their point; why slog your guts out forty hours a week for a measly hourly wage, when you can call yourself an artist and make millions for just about anything, good bad or ridiculous. No skill requirements, just keep repeating that you are an artist, and quote a few lines from some philosophy book.

Here is another great work of art paid for by your tax dollars, generously planted hear in Canada's capital city for our enjoyment. Its at the US embassy, and i for would love for you to come and take it back as it makes me sick as a dog every time i see it.


Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#17

In That Case

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Don't look at it. Feel better.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#18

Re: Supporting living artists

jessecloud

Actually most of the artists I know work pretty darn hard, and way more than 40 hours a week.

They sell a lot more on the market than they do to the government, and for what ever reason, the market values their work highly, hence big dollars sometimes.

On the other hand, I can't say that I like that sculpture at the embassy either. Best I can say for it is that it is no uglier than the building behind it.

I agree with John, though, probably not a wise use of government funds when so many other priorities are

starving.

One more nit to pick, even if the theoretical value goes up, its next to impossible for the Government to sell it and make a profit. If the FBI tires of it, federal regs require GSA to offer it to another agency. If no other agency wants it, it sits in a warehouse for many years and is eventually auctioned off for pennies on the dollar. BTW, a great way to get a deal on some beat up but repairable woodworking machinery. Google government surplus auction.

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#19

Re: Supporting living artists

Brian Holcombe

If they commissioned you to make tables and chairs, or commissioned a timber framer to build and they bought your equipment, would you still feel the same way?

Re: A big Whoops! Wood Allergy situation *LINK*

#20

Re: In That Case

Mark Hennebury

The problem is not just looking at the garbage, which is easy enough to ignore,

but the knowledge that the government is throwing outrageous amounts of our tax money away to the most undeserving, untalented con artists.. (and i say "our" tax money because they do the same in Canada.)

That fact is not easy to ignore.

The world is filled with many tradesmen and women that do incredible work, with skill and knowledge gained over years of experience and study, getting paid by the hour that are far more deserving and productive members of society.