Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Test pieces?

Posts

Test pieces?

#1

JL

Test pieces?

JL

How many of y'all do test pieces in a less expensive wood?

I have a new design that I want to test out. I am happy w/ the sketches. It isn't a complicated design - it is a somewhat simple bench. The angles of the legs into the seat should be okay - the only thing that would be somewhat iffy is the angle of the stretchers into the legs. The bench would have through tenons with the legs at an angle (about 10 degrees).

If I were to do a scale model, that would be a bit of a PITA, but it could be done. If I were to do a smaller test piece (not to full length, but 1/2 length) - that would be relatively easy - and I would have something to sell or give.

Thoughts?

Re: Test pieces?

#2

Clint Searl

Unnecessary

Clint Searl

If the stretcher is parallel to the top, it's at the same angle as the top to the leg.

Re: Test pieces?

#3

Absolutely

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

the making of a maquette or scale model has been used for centuries to allow the maker to work out design details and solve any complexities that crop up in either the original design or a modification of the idea that pops up during the making of the model.

Poplar makes an excellent modeling word.

Re: Test pieces?

#4

Re: Test pieces?

Stuart Johnson

I will make up a segmented turned piece in scrap wood or plywood occasionally to see if the programmed shape is going to look right.

Re: Test pieces?

#5

Clint Searl

Maquettes are for the faint of heart


Re: Test pieces?

#6

Re: Test pieces?

AZ in Colorado Springs

Your objective seems unclear. "Test piece" to me says that you're working out the joinery or working on machine set up for individual parts. In that case, yes.

If you're thinking of a model or sample to view a new design "in the round," then yes.

But I'm wondering what your trying to accomplish.

Re: Test pieces?

#7

Re: Test pieces?

jessecloud

My guess is that if you are questioning whether you need to do a test piece, then you probably do need one.

I often rethink a design when I go from a 2 Dimensional drawing, even in perspective, to a 3D reality. Especially if there are interesting angles or curves. I often find unexpected difficulties in assembly or shaping. If I make mistakes in cheap wood, maybe I can avoid them in costly wood.

If its something truly functional like a bench or a chair, a prototype can tell you whether its comfortable. If you are building this for someone else, its wise to let them sit in it and react.

A cautionary tale though - I once made a prototype of a chair for my wife, to check the angled joinery, the location of the lumbar support and the height of the seat. Before she even sat in it, she turned to me and said "Just how big do you think my butt is???" ;^)

Re: Test pieces?

#8

JL

To be clearer

JL

Yes, I wanted to check proportions.

Chairs I have "down pat" so to speak.

I want to make sure the width of the bench (and it's thickness) look okay. I am okay w/ the angles and such - but would it look "okay".

For a better example - I have the seat width at 14" and the length at 7 1/2'. The height will be 17". This puts the legs raking out to about 16". There is no splay to the legs.

So I can draw this out - even full scale - but it doesn't tell me the feel for the piece when executed in lumber.

Re: Test pieces?

#9

Re: To be clearer

Barry Irby

I may be overthinking this, but I think a mock up might be a good idea.

A 7 1/2' bench is huge, especially for indoors. If you move the legs in too far from the ends to make it seem stiffer you could get the phenomenon where if one person gets up off one end the person on the other ends causes it to flip up and dump them. If your top is too thin then it may flex in the center under a heavy load. If you are using a plank for the top it's going to get heavy.

Re: Test pieces?

#10

JL

Re: To be clearer

JL

I would be doing six legs.

One of the reasons for doing a test piece is to see if I need to do any splay to the legs.

Re: Test pieces?

#11

Heart Over Head

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

and fools rush in leaving the angles to clean up the mess

Re: Test pieces?

#12

Re: answering the broad question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Sometimes I make a scale model and most times I don't. I built the wall cabinet from poplar to practice the new skills involved in making this thing. The model turned out ok, I painted it and it hangs in daughters hallway.


I can successfully picture what a piece without curves will look like from a scale drawing and seldom model one. However, on the china cabinet I am building with some curved door elements, I am making a full sized drawing.


For this curvy tray stand I built a model from poplar to see that the shape worked out ok. I could not picture it in my mind from a drawing.

Bottom line- model when you are unsure how it will look from a drawing. This is an individual choice/need. BTW, I scale draw everything I build.

Re: Test pieces?

#13

Ellis Walentine

My 2¢

Ellis Walentine

Hi JL,

Sorry, but it's still a little hard for me to imagine your bench without some kind of sketch. You mentioned that the seat is 14" wide and the legs will be 16" when set at the 10º angle to the top, so I'm assuming that when you refer to "splay" you're talking about also angling the legs towards the ends of the bench, right? If so, part of the answer would depend on how close to the ends the legs are and how much the bench weighs. In other words, if a heavy person sits at the end of the bench, will it go down like a seesaw? If so, the outward "splay" of the legs would be a great help, as it is in the Windsor chairs you make. The splay forces the piece to go over top dead center in order to tip. If you were to do a mockup, I think it might want to be almost full size to check this engineering question. If all you're after is to examine the appearance, I'd suggest mocking it up in foam core or styrofoam board or something quick and dirty -- just enough to let you look around the piece in 3D and assess all the visual weights and negative spaces.

Ellis

Re: Test pieces?

#14

On the computer

Bob Lang

Making the mental leap from an idea, sketch or 2D drawing isn't the easiest thing to do. Some people have an innate ability to do it, some people develop the ability through experience and some never do. 3D computer modeling lets you pretend to build and it lets you see your idea from any angle. If your first attempt isn't to your liking, it's quick and easy to change things. If you invest the time to learn how you'll be a better designer and a better builder.

I've gone from 2D on paper to 2D in CAD to 3D with SketchUp. SketchUp beats the other methods for speed accuracy and the value of information at the end of the design process.

Re: Test pieces?

#15

You must be kidding,

Keith Newton

Or you may not be doing much challenging concepts that you need to sell a customer. Even if I can see everything in 3D in my head, I usually need to sell the customer to get started. I've found over the years, that some people can't look at a front and side elevation and plan view, no matter how good the renderings are, because they just can't see it in their head.

JL, without any assembly, I often sketch the front and side elevations on a thick block of wood, then go to the bandsaw. You could do that quicker than you can read all of your responses.

Re: Test pieces?

#16

indeed

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

when I have the need for a model, mock-up, whatever I am not ashamed to use one. When visiting the Krenov school I have been surprised at how much they mock up projects from materials laying about, maybe almost always.

Re: Test pieces?

#17

There's A Difference

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

If you've done the piece before, have a purchased plan, or are simply copying someone else's design, the need/utility for a model is reduced, often just to mock up a specific section of joinery to be used.

Better to learn from your mistakes in "junk" wood than in expensive materials.

Re: Test pieces?

#18

Re: You must be kidding,

Robin Corell in Atascadero

I skip the drawings and go straight to designing using scale models. I use bass wood so the grain isn't distracting and I don't do any joinery. it all goes pretty quick using super glue and takes less time than drawing up a set of working drawings. For things like cabinets with doors or drawers I draw them on a solid block.

I can picture the necessary joinery in my head and make full scale layouts when the time comes. No need for full scale mock ups. I don't so some of the small details like routed profiles. that way when I get to the full scale piece I chose those details based on what the full size piece needs rather than what I drew in a scale model.

I measure my scale model but adjust for visual proportions as I enlarge. I never use a tape when doing this and make boards what they look like they should be for proper visual proportions rather than some bogus standard or 3/4" dictated by a guy that cuts and sells wood but doesn't actually build anything.

Re: Test pieces?

#19

All the time...

Tony-Memphis

I tend to use big box poplar for testing ideas. I have recently made a couple of legs and a barley twist using glued up poplar from Lowes. Nothing like seeing something in person (whether scaled or full). I have done a few things 1/2 scale. I design in 2D and 3D, but 'seeing' the design is better for me. Also, look at things in the same orientation, angle, etc. Things look much different from different angles..even lighting.

Tony

Re: Test pieces?

#20

Amen to free SketchUp as a design tool

Charlie belden

Visualizing a "flat work' design idea in virtual 3D can really help work out proportions, joinery etc. - and see things ~from any perspective. Where I've found sketchup to be invaluable is designing multi-axis turning ideas. trying to visualize the result of turning two or three profiles in a single piece, each profile on its own axis - the result being the common volume of the overlapping forms - was '"challenging" prior to working ideas out in ~sketchup. And the beauty of this sketchup design approach is the virtual 3D file(s) document everything needed for others to use - and starting points for easily do variations.

Now if you add a 3D printer, the price of which keeps dropping, you can print an actual 3D scale model. Virtual reality is really nice. But a real object you can hold in your hand . . .

We truly live in Interesting times