Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Posts

O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#1

O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Darita

I've never done a lick of welding, but I'm feeling the bug and know how handy the ability to weld can be. Been looking at a Lincoln 125 or 140, but the cost is way to high for a casual user like me, as I have a $500 budget. That leaves me looking for a used unit and hopefully, with all the accessories, like gas bottle, leathers, etc. When I lived in So.Cal, I'd get on The Recycler and find dozens to choose from. I'm new to the Sacramento area and haven't got a clue where to look, besides Craigs List. Anyone up here know where I should be looking?

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#2

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Dick Coers

Check with a Lincoln dealer. They might have a demo or had one traded in. I'd suggest you take a welding class at a community college before buying anything. You might find that $500 will go a long ways to pay a professional to do the occasional job. My MIG can sit for a year or more at a time without being used.

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#3

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed... *LINK*

Keith Newton

You might want to look on ebay. You can find stick welders within your budget.

While you can learn this on your own, it isn't that easy to intuit all the stuff that you need to know to do a good job and be safe.

Be sure to get an auto-darkening helmet.

If you shared what you intend to make, the advice you get will be more useful.


http://www.ebay.com/p/Lincoln-AC-225-Stick-Welder/70621705

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#4

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Darita

I'm looking to make use it for the usual things around the garage shop, like carts, jigs, bases, etc. Aside from that, I'm a hobbyist and enjoy the process, sometimes more that the finished product and always wanted to be able to weld on my own.

In SoCal, I had a very local, old-school, welding shop that I had do small fab jobs for me. He was reasonable, but he'd been there for 50 years and his father before him. I've been to a couple of shops here and they want an arm and leg for even small jobs. Besides, I just want it as another capability in my "toolbox".

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#5

I think in Sacramento...

Grant Smith

I lived in Sacramento for seven years when I was in the Air Force. I recall it is against the city codes ordinances to have a welder in a home there. I sure saw plenty of them, but I think that was the official law. Might throw a wrench in things with your insurance company, too.

My vote is to either take a class, or find someone who is a pro to learn from. Even MIG welding has a learning curve and you will not likely have great results without learning from someone standing over your shoulder and giving tips. I still support your desire to learn, however, and encourage you to go ahead with that desire. Might be able to learn some via Youtube I suppose.

I have a small Hobart Handler, which I think is owned by Miller now. Mine is a ten year old 180 or 185 I think. Rated for 3/16" steel, but I have welded thicker using knowledge learned from a pro and multiple passes. I recommend C25 gas, which is probably the best choice for a beginner. I also recommend buying a large spool of hard wire when the starter wire runs out. The tanks are often rented from suppliers, and sometimes buying an old tank is not worth it. Ask a local weld shop before you buy a used tank. The tanks need to be re-certified periodically.

You will also want an angle grinder with cutoff wheels, wire brush, and grinding wheel. A hundred plus dollar helmet is in order too. It is much nicer to have the auto darkening feature.

FWIW,

Grant in Iowa

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#7

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Bill Howatt

I agree, take a class. You likely will be exposed to MIG, TIG and stick and will be able to make a better decision. You will be taught proper material joint preparation and the issues joining vertical to horizontal pieces, etc. It's more than just turning it on and zapping on the metal.

Stick is the cheapest and probably the most difficult to get proficient at.

Bill

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#8

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

TomD

I have a hugely expensive digital tig inverter machine. The machines I use the most are the Harbor Freight Inverter stick welder, I use it for everything I do around the shop, like I made a stand for a sewing machine where I welder a 3 inch square tube to a 1/4 plate top and bottom, no problem. $160

http://www.harborfreight.com/80-Amp-DC-120-Volt-Inverter-Stick-Welder-61749.html

A nice companion welder you can make bikes and aircraft with is the Tinman tech. I have mine set up to run off a BBQ propane source and to run off an oxygen concentrator which means I am free of the gas sources that might be regarded as oddly dangerous, such as acetylene which has more ways to kill you than Steven Seagal. One can actually run them off natural gas and an concentrator for no compressed gasses in the shop.

https://www.tinmantech.com/products/welding/meco-torch-accessories/meco-midget-torch.php

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#9

Get a refurbished unit.

Tom Dunlap

I have a red Lincoln buzz box/stick welder that has built some heavy projects during its life.

My more used welder is a Hobart Handler 140. I love it!

Buy a name brand welder. If you need parts for a HF or other brand you can be left high and dry.

There are other quality 110v wirefeeds too.

Once you decide on the model go looking for a tool vendor that sells refurb units. I got mine at a substantial savings!!! A clever Google search will find the vendors

Make the move to get rid of the flux core wire and get the gas bottle and plain wire. Much better weld and easier to weld.

I can't find the link to a guy who put together a real quality You Tube welding tutorial for 110v weldors. A little searching on a WoodCentral-ish welding forum and you'll find them.

Unless you're going to need to weld heavy iron...skip the stick!

And...like has been said...get an auto-darkening helmet, you'll be a better weldor!

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#10

Re: Get a refurbished unit.

TomD

Tom, one problem for the small user with the name brand units is that they often have great service and all that, but they are set up to work for the pro. When it came time to upgrade I was all for buying a miller Dynasty, but they were north of 4 thousand dollars at the time, and the guarantees are not set up to support the small shop user where basically I will never recover the cost of my welder in several lifetimes, let alone a few years. The result is the guarantee may expire before I have even pushed all the buttons, so to speak. These new welders are like laptops, often when something goes wrong the whole machine is shot. In the old days when welders weighed more than their owners, and were largely big balls of copper wire, you could be pretty sure they would last decades and any repairs would be worth doing. That just isn't the case with the new welders. The machine my HF replaced, cost more than 10 times what I paid for the HF. If when a problem shows up you have to replace the whole unit anyway, I don't see the advantage to sinking ten times the money into the machine. For a variety of reason, inverters are ideal in small shops, and over time that business, at least for amateurs, is going to be taken by the Chinese.

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#11

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Larry Clinton At Frankfort, (Central) Indiana

I have a 295 AMP AC stick welder, an Oxygen/Acetylene setup on a wheeled cart, and a light duty 125 Amp Mig. In reality the Mig is far easier to use and is adequate for 90+% of all small woodworking shop needs. I do occasionally braze and silver solder with the gas unit, but use it more for cutting than anything else (could use the stick for that but the gas does a neater job).

Both the gas and stick welder were bought used at auctions stick wasn't working so paid around $100 (10~15 years ago) for it with a Kennedy tool box full of electrodes and a helmet. It took about 30 minutes to repair, as the problem was in a splice in the cord where they had added about 50 foot of #10 cord.

The oxy/Acetylene unit cost me about $100 (again 10~15 years ago) and included several tips, both tanks and the cart.

I exchanged the tanks for "Thoroughbred" units. They charge a nominal fee to exchange owned tanks for their units (in my area in Indiana), you then own the tanks and can exchange your empty's for filled tanks for a fee.

If I had to choose one system for a small shop it would be a small mig. It is far easier to become proficient using the Mig, does a great job on almost all the jobs found in a homeowners shop.

I purchased the 125 amp MIG at Tractor supply during a great sale for about $200 ~$250 not including the gas tank. I can't remember what the tank cost (purchased from Thoroughbred") think it was about $75. If mig was my only choice, I would opt for a somewhat larger unit in the 175 to 200 amp range.

If money were not a concern (sure is to me) I would have purchased a Miller TIG system. Cost for a good Miller system runs several thousand dollars though. A good friend, since passed away, did own a great Miller Tig with all the bells and whistles, I believe he said it cost more than $5000, that was about 15 years ago!

The tank exchange program is ideal for shops like mine as I may not use some tanks in 2~3 years. The exchange (refill) cost is quite a bit higher than for a leased tank but with the lease you pay a fee each year.

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#12

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Don Orr

I'm on a different coast than you so can't help with where to look for used units. I have a Hobart Handler 140 MIG and it works great. I don't use it a lot though. I got it on a special deal through Northern Tool catalog. It had free shipping and cart-good deal. I used the flux core wire til I could afford to buy my own tank of Argon/CO2. I still haven't used up my 1st tank in several years.I have the auto-dark helmet from HF. I got gloves and a nice welding jacket from Northern Tool as well at very good prices. I took a "hobbyist" class at the local welding school but there was very little actual instruction other than hold the gun and pull the trigger. There are some excellent videos on Youtube-just watch out for the scary ones. Videos from welder manufacturers are a good place to start. I think you will enjoy being able to weld for yourself and friends-it's a lot of fun. Good luck and be safe.

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#13

TIG

John K Jordan

>>If money were not a concern (sure is to me) I would have purchased a

>>Miller TIG system. Cost for a good Miller system runs several

>>thousand dollars though.

I bought a Miller TIG (Diversion) a few years ago, my first TIG. I love it. The author of one of my welding books said TIG the only type of welding you can do in a white suit and not get dirty. Well he doesn't know me, but I can image a careful person staying clean!

I use the stick for big farm things (btw, an AC/DC model is my favorite) and the MIG for almost everything else, thick and thin, but I like the TIG for finer control and super clean welds, especially on smaller things like tools, brackets, fittings. I think I posted this before - I wanted a hand saw that uses the smaller blades than my coping saw so a few pieces of steel rod, the TIG, and a touch of milling gave me this:


(For alignment I used an uncut 3/8" straight rod with a couple of shallow holes drilled to align the 1/4" bent rod, welded, cut the center from the straight rod, then milled flats for the blade holders. I made the bends on the 1/4" rod with a MAPP gas torch.)

Our local gas supplier doesn't sell the larger tanks but sold me some smaller, the Q size I think for argon, oxy, CO2, etc. (Their price for tanks is a lot less than what I see on the internet) You also have to buy a regulator for each type of gas. I don't weld that often so these tanks last a LONG time in the shop.

BTW, an advantage of having extra tanks: I keep one full of nitrogen in my wood shop, great to displace air in containers of finish, help preserve my vanilla bean stock, and modify the lifestyle of rodents caught in live traps.

BTW2, I've had several autodarkening helmets and my hands-down favorite is the Jackson, very light weight, adjustable shade levels, excellent visibility:

https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00AAQ4ZPK

JKJ

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#14

Welding stuff needed

John K Jordan

I know there is a fixed budget for this thread. Unfortunately, the welding machine is just the start - like woodworking this hobby can be another financial vortex. For the long haul it might be interesting if people shared the weld shop tools and things they consider needed and those useful.

My list for a general-purpose hobby weld shop is:

NECESSARY:

Welding machine (of course)

Good electrical power

Gas cylinders as required

Welding rod, wire, etc.

Extra tips, etc. for welder

Helmet (best is autodarkening)

Close-up glasses as needed

Gloves (different for mig/tig and stick)

Hand-held wire brush (with chipping hammer for stick)

Clamps ("C" and vice grip welding clamps)

Hammer, pliers, file, chisel

Wire cutters for MIG

Measuring tools, squares, chalk, markers

Welding handbook

SAFETY:

Means to secure pressurized gas tanks

Fire extinguisher

Fire-proof floor (can cover wood with tile/cement board)

Good ventilation! (weld outside if possible)

Respirator as needed

Face shield for grinding

Hearing protection when grinding

Welding cap, jacket (or at least sleeves if welding overhead)

An extra person for fire watch if possible

USEFUL FOR CUTTING:

Hacksaw (minimum) or Sawzall (better)

Bandsaw (at least a Portaband, large horz saw better)

Abrasive cutoff wheels for angle grinder

Abrasive cutoff saw (my least favorite)

Oxy-acetylene torch

Plasma cutter (once tried you can't go back)

GENERAL HANDY STUFF:

Cart for welding machine/gas cylinder

Heavy steel vise

Hydraulic press

Bench grinder (dedicated wheel recommended for TIG)

Drill press (separate from wood shop)

Drill bits, taps, dies, cutting fluid

Steel welding/cutting table

Fire: MAPP gas, oxy-acet better

Alignment magnets, weights

Angle grinder (hard to do without)

Extra angle grinders (I keep wire brush in one)

Sanding and polishing wheels

Rand orbital sander

Belt sander

Wire wheel in bench grinder (need powerful motor)

Heavy extension cord for welder

Second autodarkening helmet for visitors/students

Welding blankets (to protect things)

Degreasing supplies

Lots of primer, paint (cold galvanized for outdoor stuff)

Storage space/racks for steel stock

Good shop lighting

Bright flashlight

Welding books

JKJ

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#15

Re: Welding stuff needed

TomD

A lot of good points there. You can get cheap second hand tig units if you are happy with machines the size of a small dishwasher, and have twice the power you would require in an inverter. (though some inverters need high initialization power, whereas if you weld light stuff with conventional tig it is a straight through process.

MIG is the winner for most general uses these days. But just a few cautions:

I is easy for beginner welders to get results that look good, that is a lot different than results that are good. This is because it auto feeds the wire, and this tends to automatically produce good beads but they may or not have penetrated. Welding is super strong and there are lots of applications (including, apparently, Chinese 2T shop cranes) where bad welds get the job done. The reason I have TIG and the MECO is because of aircraft and bicycle parts

MIG is a gas shield welding process ($$) or you can use shielded wire, the latter being an expensive way to get a stick welder.

MIG has cold start issues which is why the best welds tend to be done with TIG, or some even fancier process.

I agree that the simplest way to deal with safety is to weld out of doors. Stick is the best process for that. Processes that use shield gas are hard to control with a breeze, but maybe wire shielded MIG is as good.

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#16

Good post JK

Keith Newton

I was looking to see if there was anything I could add to that, but couldn't. I guess I need to get a welding cap instead of just wearing my ball cap. Do those welding caps all have the brim on the back? ha

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

#17

Re: O.T. Welder Help Needed...

Darita

Well, the hunt is over! I decided to order an Eastwood 175 Mig and cart. Price and great reviews led me to it. I really didn't want to do what I normally do when I buy machines for the first time. That is, I buy low, soon regret buying low, then eventually move up. I think I got a good starter hobbyist mig welder and one that will do me fine for years to come. If I love welding, I may look closer at the plasma cutter as well.

Now, all I have to do is save up for a gas bottle and helmet. Thank you all for your help.