I am building kitchen doors and drawer fronts from US Hard Maple. The aim is to keep to wood light in colour - so the plan is to use a blond shellac.
Rather than use the local Ubeaut white shellac, which requires thinning with alcohol, I am considering using Zinsser out of the can.
Zinsser comes in two forms, the waxed Bulls Eye Shellac, and the dewaxed Seal Coat. Only the Bulls Eye is available in Australia.
What is the difference between these two if the wood is not to be stained/dyed and no other finish is to be applied? As I understand, the de-waxed shellac is the choice when another finish is used against it. Is this correct?
Are there advantages/disadvantages of using the waxed version?
Waxy shellac (Bull's Eye, etm) presents problems with adhesion of top coats, especially waterborne finishes.
Dewaxed shellacs (SealCoat or other ready-mixes) allow top-coating so long as the product is fresh; as shellac ages the esterification process continues until the resin's ability to form a hard film is lost even when dry. SealCoat claims a 2-year shelf life and used to put a 'born-on' date on the cans. They have since dropped the dates so there is no way for you to gauge how old the mix is when you buy it at a store. I had a problem with SealCoat not drying properly out of a supposedly new can I got at the BORG. Company ignored my inquiry and request for replacement with factory-fresh product.
Dewaxed shellacs will give a somewhat harder film with the wax removed. Waxy mixes are preferred by luthiers for the softer "feel" of the surface on their instruments. Some even add additional wax to their coatings.
Personally, I now mix my own dewaxed shellac from dry flakes. I buy it in 1-pound quantities and mix only what I'll need for the job at hand or for use within 3 months of the mix. I used to use different color grades to even out wood parts' color, but now I just buy Ultra-Pale (lighter still than Blond) and then use small adds of TransTint dye concentrates to tint the coating when needed. I mix a 2lb cut (4oz flakes to 16oz alcohol) and then dilute as needed from there.
hth
Mixing Tip: When mixing from dry flakes, hijack your partner's chopper-in-a-hopper from the kitchen and use it to break the flakes into fines. Speeds up the dissolving big time.
I have most of a gallon from Lowes and it is drying at a snails' pace.
The Zinsser process removes acids from the shellac that catalyze the esterification with alcohol. I think the process didn't work very well on my batch.
Re: Pretty sure dewaxed is blond, the other is amb
Steve Schoene
Zinsser SEAL COAT is the only canned dewaxed shellac from Zinnser. It comes at two pound cut, which is generally a good viscosity to apply. The Seal Coat is a light shade that I call dirty blonde. The Amber and Clear both contain the natural shellac wax. Clear is made that "color" by using a Chlorine bleach and that process leaves the Clear less durable than the others. Blonde shellac is lighted by filtering through activated charcoal, though the original raw shellac does vary in shade depending on the season and local of harvest.
As mentioned shellac has a shelf life. If you must use Zinsser shellac go to the Zinsser webpage to find the date code on the cans. Since you don't know storage conditions etc. treat the use by date very conservatively and definately test each batch for rapid drying before using.
Mixing shellac from dry flakes as advantages since you know the born on date and can be assured of fresh shellac. All shellac is mixed using alcohol as thinner. Flakes can be had in a range of colors, and in either waxed or dewaxed. If it is dewaxed it will say dewaxed--you can't assume based on color.
I don't recommend shellac as a final finish for kitchen cabinets. A principal reason is that shellac doesn't handle the typical cleaning materials used in kitchens. Most such cleaning sprays are alkaline, and alkaline solutions are true solvents for shellac and will destroy it quite readily.
We had our kitchen done 8 years ago. Cabs were all shot with a 65% sheen finish finish but the doors under the sink unit get wet from splashes and are showing the white water damage. Called the maker to inquire about the finish they used. Turns out to be a vinyl acetate or something that can't be repaired like shellac or NC lacquer. I will have to sand off the old finish an the effected rail and styles and then recoat, trying to get the sheen to match.
I find that Sealcoat still needs to be cut. I cut it 50/50 for a sealer coat and put it on in straight strokes with a natural brush. Cover completely but move on. Do not revisit. Second and most of the time my final coat of shellac is at full can strength. Mostly but not always. Depends on that can. TEST! For the kitchen I would use a Poly or a more resistant finish as the final two coats.. Sealcoat can be hard to find in a Qt. size and easily in the gal. size. Unless you are a full time cabinet shop I suggest you buy the lesser size or go to falkes. For flakes I believe in mixing only a bit more than enough for each project. Guaranteed fresh every time. Shellac is my alltime best furniture finish. Most versatile and easy to use. Just don't expect good wear resistance.
What I am after is a durable finish that remains clear and retards yellowing, and that can be applied by brush or, preferably, wiping. I am not interested in a two-pack finish that requires spraying with special masks and protection. I would consider a suitable spray can option.
One of the reasons I ask here is that the Hard Maple is a wood known to the forum members. It is not a wood commonly used in Oz.
I have started building the doors for our kitchen. Hard Maple is so nice to work. Planes beautifully and easily. I cannot believe how easily!
The design is a Shaker style, chosen for a clean, simple look. This will replace a 22 year-old existing kitchen in Tasmanian Oak with a more traditional raised panel style.
Unfinished and even not yet glued - first door ...
Derek, Here's a picture of some Maple turned in 2011. The two pieces in the back were finished on the lathe with a mixture of 50% Sanding sealer and 50% Lacquer thinner. The piece in the foreground was finished with Watco Danish Oil "Natural" color. The pieces have stayed close to the same color for 5 years maybe just a hint of darkening on the Watco piece. The Sanding sealer mixture was wiped on with the lathe turning and then smoothed with a Scotchbrite pad and buffed with White Diamond and waxed. The outside of the large one is still the same color as the inside. No change.
I love the colour of the rear pieces. However "a mixture of 50% Sanding sealer and 50% Lacquer thinner" sounds like the Zinsser seal coat (or similar) I asked about originally. The problem is that it is not durable enough for a kitchen.
The danish oil likely is durable, but I would prefer to find a finish that does not darken the Hard Maple.
I recommend you use a light application of the lightest dewaxed shellac you can find, then apply 3 coats of General Finish's Enduro clear Poly in your choice of sheen. You finish will stay water-white, and Enduro is KCMA approved for kitchen cabinetry. While Enduro works best with HVLP spray, I've hand-applied it (good bristle brush only) with good results. Used as directed, you'll get nearly 100% burning in between the coats with no sanding in between.
Cheers
ps: Reason for the shellac first is to prevent the waterborne Enduro from raising or puckering the wood grain as waterborne finishes are prone to do, even if stated to be "self sealing". It will also add clarity and depth to
As I recommended earlier, to get water white you need an acrylic finish. General Finish's Enduro is an acrylic lacquer.
I expect that every finish company makes an acrylic product to fill the need of a non-yellowing finish. Some are more durable than others. If products from Target are available I can recommend what I used on ash kitchen cabinets to keep the ash from yellowing and provide a durable kitchen finish.
I don't have vast experience but any water based finish I have used can be applied with a foam brush and the result is glass smooth.
Shown is a maple pepper grinder made some years ago. It sits in a sunny dining room. Finish applied with foam brush, no post application sanding, or rubbing out. The maple has turned light brown, which is unavoidable; the finish remains clear.
The door looks great. One comment: I made some doors like that for our kitchen cabinets several years ago. My wife really liked the Shaker style, but... dust, dirt, etc. collected on the top ledge of the bottom rail and was a bear to clean. If I were going to make any more I would put a small angle (slope) on that ledge to facilitate easier cleaning. It may not be perfect style, but it would be more functional, and easier to clean. My 2 cents.
I certainly can say shellac is far more "durable" than many seem to think. My son remodeled an old house and we made all the trim from rough sawn white oak, planed and sanded in the shop. We applied a wipe on oil based stain, then sprayed shellac we mixed from flake. This was about 8-10 years ago.
He has always had cats, dogs and is raising 2 grandchildren. The finish has held up admirably ~ there were a few scratches on some of the baseboard, luckily not deep enough to penetrate the stain, so wiping a new coat of thinned shellac repaired them quickly and the areas matched perfectly.
I am 75 and can remember when "spring cleaning" included wiping down all the woodwork with a thinned shellac to renew the finish.
Of course I am a proponent of renewable finishes in wear areas. We built his kitchen cabinets from some beautiful cherry I had obtained from an Amish estate sale. These were finished with Behlen Qualalacq Lacquer, it too has held up quite well, although we did have to "wipe on" a coat where water had whitened the doors under the sink. Again the renewal was no problem and left a beautiful finish.
I sure would purchase some flake shellac as some had suggested, I purchased mine from Talas ~ it does appear they don't carry as complete a line as they used to handle but do have both de-waxed and regular. I believe the brand name was Liberon, but doubt there is much difference from other brands. Amazon does carry an extensive listing of shellacs, but don't know what shipping would cost to your area!
.....to apply at least one coat of finish to the panel before assembly. Otherwise when the panel shrinks even a little bit there will be a discontinuity revealed at the panel edge.
However you wind up finishing, applying finish to that sharp step at the frame-panel junction will be tricky. This project invites investment in spraying capability at a cost substantially less than the loose tenon maker.
Indeed maple is a timber used for furniture since colonial days. "We" have centuries of experience finishing it. "Colonial" maple wound up looking yellow or orange depending on the details of the finish. Oiled or varnished it wound up yellow and not the color you are desiring. Then maple fell out of favor and relegated to industrial usage. We sold mountains of it for bumpers in warehouses and other industrial applications.
More or less 25 years ago fashion became tired of oak kitchens. The development of non-yellowing finish and application of white glaze enabled kitchens to be done in a light colored wood and maple became popular for kitchens. I used to keep track of kitchen cabinet finishes and at the time every manufacturer touted a "water white" kitchen finish. Maple also became popular in studio furniture. In this application blond shellac and non-yellowing lacquer such as CAB lacquer were practical.
What you see in studio furniture and 25 year old kitchen pictures is wood freshly finished. A friend did a maple kitchen 25 years ago. It is still white but I think the finish has been tinted white to overcome the natural browning of maple with age. What the studio furniture looks like 10 years from finishing I don't know, but I'll bet that at least the wood has browned some similar to what I showed in the picture. I have never seen maple as white as shown by Doug even before it was finished. Don't know his secret but it involves more than generic sanding sealer, which would be the lest durable finish you could apply.
Doors are difficult to refinish. Just had that experience with my 22 year old ash cabinets. Were it not for the irreplaceable wood I used in the panels it would have been easier to rebuild them. So get it right the first time.
Thanks for the comments Larry. I use both waxed and unwaxed shellac a fair bit for furniture. The unwaxed is clear/untinted (I use Ubeaut white shellac), however I would prefer something more durable (that may be washed down).
I took the plunge - probably pretty safe (albeit it pricey!) - to use General Finishes QTHS High Performance Water Based Topcoat. Via Amazon as it is not available in Oz, and I cannot find something similar.
Bill alerted me to a review done by FWW in 2006. This, along with recommendations from a few others, really supported its choice as the top finish that was clear (non-yellowing), non-plastic finish, maximum protection, able to be applied with a foam brush, and quick drying for re-coating.
The "plastic" look results from the finish thickness, not the finish properties. A thick build will provide that plastic look. Getting a "close to the wood" appearance would be easy by spraying. I can spray polyurethane and it will look equivalent to shellac or lacquer or even oil, for example. It is all in the thinning and application of thin coats, easy to do with spraying.