Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

dust collector blower orientation

Posts

dust collector blower orientation

#1

dust collector blower orientation

Eric Kuehne

I've just about made the decision to modify my 2hp Jet dust collector by adding a Super Dust Deputy. I've scoured the web and noticed that all of the installations show the blowers in their original horizontal alignment. This is less than optimum as they all have a fairly long length of flex hose between the top of the SDD and the blower inlet so there is a fair amount of built in efficiency loss where you want it the least. My alternatives seem to be:

A. Leave the blower orientation as is (the center line of the blower impeller is horizontal) put a long radius rigid elbow.

B. Do approximately the same thing with two 45 degree elbows.

C. Orient the blower so the center line is vertical and couple the inlet directly to the top of the SDD which would be the most efficient solution.

The potential problem with the C. solution is the blower won't tolerate this. The reason is that, in my experience (I'm a mechanical engineer and have a fair amount of experience dealing with blowers professionally which is how I know about this issue.) the overwhelming majority of blowers will not tolerate having the center line in the vertical axis due to the bearing type and that is my concern here. In at least one case where the manufacturer said it was OK but was wrong. (And I have reams if data to prove it.)

So with that background my basic question is whether anyone has any knowledge or experience with this issue. I'd really like to do this vertically but I won't unless I can confirm that it's safe for the blower. I'd try Jet but I'm sure this knowledge is buried far to deeply in the corporate engineering group for me to access. Also, I know there are dust collectors in that have their blowers configured with the center line vertical but these are obviously engineered for this.

Thanks for your help.

Eric in Los Gatos

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#2

Re: dust collector blower orientation

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I'm glad you brought up this issue because I have the same question. Yesterday, I spent all afternoon changing the blower orientation (motor shaft is vertical) because it would save a lot of room, but I didn't think about the bearings, just whether the impeller might eventually come off the shaft due to gravity. I saw pics of the Dust Deputy with the blower mounted on top, but as you said, it must be engineered for this. BTW, my blower is a 15 y.o. Delta which I would think is not much different (engineering-wise) from your Jet.

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#3

Re: dust collector blower orientation

David Bair

When I questioned JET about reorienting my blower, they indicated it made no difference which way I wanted to place it. It's been working fine for about 15 years.

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#4

Re: dust collector blower orientation

Eric Kuehne

Hi David,

Well you certainly can't argue with 15 years of life. Good news for me!

A lot of my concern is that in my professional life I worked on a product that used a blower the manufacturer said could be oriented vertically but we had a ton of infant mortality failures and generally poor life. I did some research and found that no competitive blower made the claim that their blowers could be oriented vertically. This made me pretty suspicious and I redesigned and tested that part of the system so that the blowers would be oriented horizontally. We went from crisis levels of failure to zero.

So now I'm curious about your configuration. Can you post a pic?

Thanks,

Eric

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#5

Re: dust collector blower orientation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Works just fine with the motor vertical.

Avoid the 2x45 inlet ducting. Your blower's impeller will get a better "bite" on the air if you have a piece of straight duct (smooth, not flex/ribbed) that's at least 5-6 times as long as the inlet diameter. This works to negate the air turbulence caused by turns in the piping so that the impeller blades 'enter" the airstream smoothly.

If your blower's inlet is larger than your ductwork, use a reducer but connect it, if possible, on the upstream end of the straight piece.

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#6

Re: dust collector blower orientation

Alan Marchbanks

Eric, this is how I did mine. I don't have the instruments to measure the flow before and after, but I can tell that the flow definitely increased. You can see that the bag on the collector is about 1/4 full, and the catch can has been emptied 4-5 times. The Super Dust Deputy does a very good job. The blower unit is mounted on french cleats and is very solid. The tie down strap is used to raise the dust deputy to empty the collector can. Kind of a jury rig setup but it works well. The upper hose goes overhead to the cnc machine and the lower one goes along the wall to all the tablesaw, jointer, planer, bandsaw, etc. Hope this helps.

Alan

PS Wasn't able to load images. If you send your email i'll send them to you.

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#7

Re: dust collector blower orientation

John b sw Chicgo burbs

I also did what you want to do. I built a metal frame from 3/4" square tubing that slides in i" square tubing(if i were to do it again i would go up one size in tubing). Mounted motor and blower with shaft vertical to 3/4" frame. Then came 12" of straight 6" ducting into the top of the Dust Deputy. The DD was attached to a new lid that was made from 3/4" particle board to fit top of 35 gal. metal garbage can. Only thing connected yo the metal frame is the blower assy. There is a 1/2" bolt mounted on the 3/4 frame to act as a jacking bolt to give about 3/4" lift to be able slip out garbage can. to attach the DD to the filter assy. i just used the original 5" tubing with an additional 5" metal 90* bend. It has been going strong' pun intended' for over 2 years.

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#8

Re: dust collector blower orientation

John b sw Chicgo burbs

I should also note that i shortened the dust bag to less than half. there is about less than one cup of dust in the bag in the time it has been set up this way. John b

Re: dust collector blower orientation

#9

Re: dust collector blower orientation

Eric Kuehne

Thanks all for the responses. They are very helpful. It looks like I can go with the vertical orientation which is great news.

And, Alan, I would love to see your photos. You can send them to me at erkuehne@gmail.com. If anyone else has photos that they would send I would be very interested in seeing your solutions.

BTW, I was thinking about a container and leaning toward the metal Oneida version but choked a bit on the price. Amazon has a plastic container that others have used and liked. As I have to schlep the container up from my basement I don't want too big/heavy a solution. The Amazon stock number is B000LDEP0C.

Cheers,

Eric

Thanks again everyone.

Eric