Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Filling Mahogany Grain

Posts

Filling Mahogany Grain

#1

Filling Mahogany Grain

Mark

I have a Mahogany guitar project I am finishing and would like to fill in the grain before staining and clear coating.

However here in Canada, I cant seem to find any of the dedicated "grain fillers" a google search produces.

There are lots of water based, non shrinking, stainable " wood filler" products available here but they seem to be positioned for filling cracks, nail holes, splits , etc.

I notice that some of the dedicated "grain filler" products also advertise themselves as being wood fillers with the same properties and uses.

Does anyone have any experience or thoughts on whether these "wood filler" products if diluted with water to a paint like paste would act as a satisfactory grain filler for the mahogany?

After filling I want to dye the wood and then clear coat.

Trying to understand what would be the difference between these wood fillers and dedicated grain fillers, and what the impact would be on the wood.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#2

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

Dick Coers

I'd be reluctant to add that much water to the wood on a completed guitar {to thin down the putty). I would only use a solvent based grain filler. I tried finding old recipes, and found these from George Frank;

"One common recipe: powdered chalk or

simple whiting powder is the filling agent, colored with dry

powdered colors to match the wood. The binder is rosin (or

colophony), also powdered, and the carrier is mineral spirits. The

spirits are frequently tinted (for dark walnut) with some asphaltum

paint. The amount of rosin is about 10-15% of the colored chalk.

Another recipe is talcum powder colored with dry pigment. The

carrier and the binder are shellac and alcohol. This type of filler

is difficult to use without skill and experience."

I tried to find out if you can use whiting and add that to a common glaze, but nothing popped up on Google right away. I'd definitely recommend a dark colored grain filler to add depth to the finish. Even if you are going to dye it.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#3

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

TomD

I'm in Canada also: drywall compound and black dye.

Luthier Tips du Jour - Pore Filling with Drywall Compound: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zhk6rZ2UI1Y

That should work for you. Guitars are a special case as there are all these different woods blending together. I have made mahogany guitars that were clear finished also, unfortunately the best one I made was a bit bizarre, so I think it is unlikely anyone will get past the other features to appreciate the wood. It is weird that a wood that is so precious (we are talking real mahogany here folks) is so commonly stained to hell and back.

For clear you can fill with super glue, or 5 minute epoxy. It works really well. Epoxy can yellow, but there is so little left on the wood, that does not appear to be an issue. You can also just oil and sand and fill and oil, sand and oil, which is what I do on necks.

For the authentic look you can use Potassium Dichromate. It is poisonous, but then what isn't? There were snakes in the Garden of Eden. You can get the stuff off ebay from sellers outside US, thereby keeping shipping within reason. Of course it isn't a filler, but once you get the right colour, you can fill with just about anything mentioned so far.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#4

Re: Rule number one...

TomD

of all finishing is to try a sample first, that is what the cutouts of the pieces at the waist are for. When finished they can still be further recycled to other uses later.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#5

Re: Rule number one...

GolfSteve in Calgary

I used System 3 epoxy (~20 min cure time) on an East Indian rosewood guitar with Spanish cedar neck. Worked beautifully. I applied a coat of shellac before a lacquer top coat, and have had no bonding issues.

Mix epoxy, squeegee on, let dry, and sand back. Repeat until filled. There were a few pinholes that resisted filling (due to surface tension issues???). I filled those later by drop filling with lacquer after the first coat of lacquer was applied. That was a slow process.

I once grain filled some red oak with a waterbased grain filler. It worked fine. Mush it on, wipe off, then sand and repeat. The dark grain filler accentuated the huge pores in the red oak.

Anything else I've grain filled has been cherry or fir, so a applying a few coats of finish then sanding back has resulted in a complete grain fill.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#6

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

Mark

Tom, I have heard of the Drywall /Dye Compound approach.

I am going for a cherry sunburst finish on a Les Paul style using Stew Mac dyes.

Based on your experience does the drywall compound with black dye stain the wood too Black , or does sanding it back reveal enough wood to still allow the cherry red stain to take ?

Thanks

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#7

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

don stephan

Jeff Jewitt's book and companion video Hand Applied Finishes describes using 4F pumice in shellac as a pore filler. Perhaps because of the pumice content, when dry it is very hard to sand, so experiment on scrap scraping off the excess across the grain with old credit card, plastic squeegee, . . . Study the book and watch the segment several times before beginning to practice. Adding color would have to be part of your experimenting.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#8

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

TomD

I don't have experience of the type you want, but yes, the whole thing starts out covered and as you sand back you end up with black mostly in the pores. I love answering questions here, but this is exactly the type of thing you need to test on a real sample and see where it takes you. The compound is pretty standard, the dye is probably going to vary from user to user, so your mileage may vary.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#9

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

William Duffield

Sorry for the late reply. My internet access was limited for a while.

For filling mahogany and other open grain wood furniture, I’ve always used Behlen Pore-O-Pac, thinned with odorless mineral spirits and colored with earth pigments. I’ve applied it with the most beat up brush in my arsenal and rubbed it in and rubbed the excess off across the grain with coarse burlap. You may need more than one application to fill all the pores. If it dries while you are rubbing it off, just apply some more to rewet and mobilize it. You must let the carrier and binder dry before applying your finish over it or you may get fisheye. Pore-O-Pac is available from many suppliers, including Woodcraft, Garrett Wade and Woodworkers Supply.

I built one solid body mahogany electric guitar 20 years ago, but the guy I built it for did the research on materials and processes. We bleached and dyed the body. To insure it had as bright a sound as possible, he insisted that the only finish and grain filler applied was sprayed nitrocellulose lacquer. It probably took 30 coats of spray and sand to fill the pores.

While pumice in shellac may be effective, you definitely need to practice. If the pumice isn't thoroughly wetted by the shellac, it just makes an opaque grey mess, probably not what you are looking for.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#10

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

Mark

Thanks all , I had tried the pumice and rottenstone routine before with poor results (all due to impatient me).

Part of the issue seems to be an absence of dedicated grain/ pore filling products sold here in Canada which seems ridiculous.

Even Lee Valley only sells a commonly available wood filler product better designed for patching nail holes and gouges, although they suggest it can fill grain if diluted

The product I finally found and have started using is Timbermate. Several You Tube examples of using it for filling Mahogany guitars.

After 2 applications it seems to work as advertised and my test piece which I also grain filled seems to take the stain very well.

One more Sanding session and I think the body and neck will be getting some stain.

Thanks again

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#11

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

TomD

One thing you can get from LV is french polish shellac. that can be applied in a self-filling routine.

One place you might try for product is Exotic Woods Inc in Burlington. No guarantees, but they are doing a pretty good job with woods for luthiers and they also carry hard to find epoxies and instrument lacquer. I don't specifically know whether they carry fillers.

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

#12

Re: Filling Mahogany Grain

Steve Schoene

have you tried Sherwin-Williams? in is at least they have an excellent grain filler. only in gallons and I suspect only at the Commercial stores.