Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

Posts

The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#1

The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! Today's post completes the Floating Credenza series. In this post I create a cabinet back, reinforced by dovetailed battens, to close the case and complete the build.

I hope that will check it out and I look forward to your comments.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/11/17/the-floating-credenza-cabinet-back/

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#2

Fantastic!

Joseph Piotrowski

more outstanding work! you certainly craft your projects. I especially like like the hand plane modifications.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#3

Re: Footnote

William Duffield

While I'm pretty sure everyone who follows Brian's blog knows who Chris Hall is, here is a link to some of his inspirational Japanese joinery for the general WoodCentral reader:

http://thecarpentryway.blogspot.com

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#4

Re: Fantastic!

Brian Holcombe

Thank you!

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#5

Re: Footnote

Brian Holcombe

Good thing to note! I added Chris' info to my post as well.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#6

A discussion of backs

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Once you put a base under this cabinet it could function effectively as a room divider. A "show" back will enable that versatility which I predict will be used in its future.

In keeping with period construction I never was concerned with what the back of a case looked like, presuming they would always be against a wall. Nailing ship lapped secondary wood into a rabbet was good enough to exclude dust from the interior. Now that I am building for family and time is less valuable than it once was I am moving toward including more attractive backs on cabinetry in the off chance that someday the piece will be considered for a location where the back will show.

It would be well to remind the reader that you put constraints on your construction that lead to novel, and often complex, construction solutions by western standards. Many would find your back solution impossibly difficult to execute.

Krenov would have solved the need for a "show back" by gluing a precisely fitted piece of veneered plywood into a rabbet of the case frame. Krenov backs are often structural in this regard and add to the strength of the doweled assembly he used. A vertical grain orientation on a room divider back would be attractive if the wood was well chosen.

In my later pieces I have employed a frame and panel back screwed into the case rabbet. It is possible to make a lightweight 1/2" thick frame with 3/8" thick panels that meets the need. For reasons I might find hard to justify I prefer a frame and panel back that can be easily removed. Otherwise I would nail the back on. This solution can be refined by choice of wood and fit to whatever degree desired and it employs common construction techniques.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#7

Re: A discussion of backs

Brian Holcombe

Exactly my logic in designing and using a back which has a nice appearance.

I do, however, strongly disagree that I need to somehow imply to my readership that what they're viewing is different from an arbitrary set of standards. I'm a contemporary studio furniture maker, not making 18th century reproductions or something that would actually require such a warning. It can be easily discerned from my tone, alone, that what I'm building is set to my own standards or goals.

I've never been impressed by nail on backs, I can't imagine why makers of yesteryear prefer the method to simply cutting a groove in the case back and slipping tongue and groove boards into said groove. The nails often split the boards or cause the boards to split at some later date. While that may not matter to many and it is the 'standard' of 18th century craft, it is not actually the only way that 18th century backs were applied.

Please have a look at Bureau Du Roi for King Louis XV by Jean-Francois Oeben:

http://www.wikiwand.com/en/Bureau_du_Roi

This desk is immaculately constructed and features an incredibly detailed back.

Here is a reproduction by Francois Linke:

https://www.1stdibs.com/furniture/tables/desks-writing-tables/le-bureau-du-roi-francois-linke/id-f_1986912/

Also featuring the back, exquisitely detailed.

The standard of make depends entirely on the purpose, furniture which is meant to divide the room or be placed out in open space is made with a detailed back regardless of time period.

20th century furniture is often made with a plywood back and most often made with a back that maintains some level of appeal. The logic, similar to my own, is that the cabinetry is often moved out from the wall or used in a large open space as a room divider or similar purpose.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#8

perhaps I didn't correctly understand....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....but I thought you eschewed screws, nails and even glue when possible. And if this remembrance is correct, you are driven to engineering solutions that are going to be different from almost everyone else making furniture no matter the century. If true, it is this fact that should be conveyed so that the novel engineering is understood.

Please have a look at Bureau Du Roi for King Louis XV by Jean-Francois Oeben:

The vast majority of professional American cabinet makers were unable to indulge in refinements where cost was no concern. Louis could have asked for the back to be gilded and it would have been gilded. Years later we could be impressed by what money could buy. Fewer would be inspired to build that way.

On a personal note, that last thing that is done to a cabinet I make is install the back. When possible I install the back after delivery and set up. Access to the back enables the piece to be moved easily, and it makes adjusting drawers easier, when required.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#9

Re: perhaps I didn't correctly understand....

Brian Holcombe

"....but I thought you eschewed screws, nails and even glue when possible. And if this remembrance is correct, you are driven to engineering solutions that are going to be different from almost everyone else making furniture no matter the century. If true, it is this fact that should be conveyed so that the novel engineering is understood."

Bill, you are correct, however I'm surprised that you seem to be asking me to point out exactly what is pointed out already in practically every post I make.

This is my about page:

"Hello! My name is Brian Holcombe. Welcome to my woodworking blog.

I design and build furniture, drawing my main influence from Japanese sashimono and carpentry as well as furniture of the Chinese Ming dynasty. My focus is on cabinetry and tables, as well as small boxes and framing.

In constructing my furniture, I use primarily hand tools and traditional methods of work. I feel that hand tools connect the maker to the work while allowing freedom of form, encouraging the maker to constantly push to reveal new facets of the material and continuously hone personal ability and skill.

A hallmark of my furniture is the use of interlocking joinery to minimize reliance upon glue and mechanical fasteners. The methods of joinery are both traditionally-used in furniture and adapted from timber framing.

I build furniture on a commission basis, tailoring my efforts to the fit the unique needs of my clientele. If you have a project in mind and are interested to know more, please contact me. If you are interested in visiting the studio, please see this page for more details. Thank you for joining me in my journey. I hope that you enjoy reading my blog."

I link directly to my blog posts here, for convenience, but anyone clicking on my blog from sources other than those linked or emailed and this is the page that comes up.

I feel it's excessive to further disclaim my posts by adding some comparison or contrast to a specific era of furniture making that really I make no effort to replicate. I may pull from it on occasion, pretty much unknowingly, but my study is certainly in Ming Chinese furniture, Sashimono and Japanese Timber work.

FWIW, the great majority of important work are commissions from the state, government officials, religious institutions and the wealthy, if we should discount all of those things than one could easily toss away the best woodwork from literally every era dating back to the beginning of civilization.

Good point on leaving the back off, I thought to do that when delivering this cabinet, but instead carried it by the legs.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#10

Re: Is that legitimate?

TomD

Does the glue free joinery exist to be glue free? Was it a stunt, or did they choose their methods based on what they thought would be the best approach. Often when this glue or no glue thing comes up it sounds sorta infantile, in the sense that there was wonder, I felt it back in the days of discovery, when I first discovered that glue joints could be stronger than the surrounding wood; that laminated wood could be stronger than solid wood; that joinery could be stronger, or somehow otherwise better, than a joint using nails or fasteners; or that some joinery could succeed without glue. But once the original rush of comprehension and wonder passes, there has to be something more to fall back on than whether something has or doesn't have glue. Which is sorta a riff on the expectations of the otherwise ignorant. There is perfectly good joinery that is nothing but glue, and perfectly good joinery that is nothing but wood.

On the flip side, there are some people who will only be pleased to accept glue free joinery if it is pointed out that it cost less in raw materials.

Re: The Floating Credenza - Cabinet Back

#11

Re: Is that legitimate?

Brian Holcombe

There is a difference between glue free and minimizing reliance upon glue. Modern glues are supposedly stronger than the surrounding wood, but for how long? How does the piece, which is reliant upon glue, age? How easy do you want the restoration work to be?

I'm sure the people who restore Ming furniture are glad that it is made to be taken apart with ease. The same applies to those who move it.

I built a table last year that could be knocked down to flat parts in about a minute, makes life much easier if you are moving or want to transport it.