Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

Posts

Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

Jack Guzman from Maine

I finish my chairs with a "wipe-on" finish. It consists of equal parts of BLO spar varnish and mineral spirits. I apply a heavy coat,let is set for awhile,then wipe it till there's no liquid left on the surface. I then let it dry 24 hrs and repeat for a total of three coats. I started this process using a small absorbent rag dipped in a bowl of finish. After a few chairs I noticed this method was messy so I started applying the finish with a 1" chip brush that I dipped in the bowl as needed. I seemed to get good results so I do it this way all the time.

I was wondering if it makes any difference which way the finish is applied. Is there any advantage to rubbing it in with a rag? All the brush does is lay it on,there is no rubbing except when wiping it off. Does wiping with a rag help get the molecules of finish into the pores better? I'm thinking that the absorption process happens regardless of the rubbing but I am no scientist or finish expert.

So, does anyone know the answer to this?

It's funny how the mind wanders when applying finish. ---Jack

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#2

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

Ralph Lipeles

Years ago I restored a bunch of vintage oak furniture for our summer/winter vacation home. I used tung oil. Initially I used a small scrap of rag to apply it. Then I switched to a 1" brush. The brush was much quicker and the brushed pieces held up as good as the ragged pieces.

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#3

no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Does wiping with a rag help get the molecules of finish into the pores better? ...No The molecules are so tiny they have no idea what is moving them around. They will wick and diffuse to wherever they are not, mindless of how they got started.

Similarly, there is a lot of mumbo jumbo about French Polish. Some claim that the act of applying the shellac with a "rubber" performs some magic, that no polymer chemist will affirm. It is immaterial how the finish is applied, the molecules will, on a time scale unimaginably quick, conform to whatever configuration they prefer in the solvent environment they find themselves. Those that want to get on with it brush or spray on the shellac to build the necessary thickness, then polish to get the surface luster of French Polish. One can get to the same place by rubbing on lots of thin layers.

For durability you should be using a finish formulated for wiping. It will not be a finish compromised by the addition of oil that will lead to a soft finish once cured. Fine Woodworking published an evaluation of such finishes scoring such properties as durability, color, etc.

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#4

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

Dick Coers

Curious why you added BLO. Most varnishes already has some oil variant, and are pretty strong amber color already. I'd think your finish will become much darker with age than just using the thinned varnish. As long as the finish you use has some driers, wiping or brush makes no difference.

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: no

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks Bill. That clears it up for me.---Jack

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#6

Jack Guzman from Maine

Why the oil?

Jack Guzman from Maine

Every time I mention this recipe I get advice against it. I have no idea why the oil. I don't know Jack about finishing.It is a recipe used by both Curtis Buchanan and Peter Galbert. I learned of it from reading their blogs and such. I am just following the recipe. BTW it leaves a nice finish over the milk paint.thanks---Jack

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#7

Mr. Tindall - question

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

Bill, you said:

"For durability you should be using a finish formulated for wiping. It will not be a finish compromised by the addition of oil that will lead to a soft finish once cured."

Knowing that I am always challenged with finishing :b , what do you mean by the part above that is in bold?

Aren't wiping finishes primarily oil based varnishes of some sort with oil and thinner added? Like the recipe Jack mentioned.

Are you saying the addition of more oil (like BLO) will make it softer, hence compromising it? As I recall, Spar varnish is a 'long oil' varnish with a higher amount of oil already. Maybe I just answered my own question.

Thanks!

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#8

Re: Mr. Tindall - question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Let us start by defining a "wiping varnish". This finish can be wiped on, wiped off and leave behind a thin coating that will cure to a protective, beauty-enhancing film. Ordinary varnish tacks up and becomes too viscous too quickly for the wiping off part to be easy.

The ultimate wipe on finish is to just use oil. It cures so slow that it can be wiped off hours later. But the result is a soft finish. One can become convinced of the poor mechanical properties of this finish by poking at the cured oil that accumulates from drips around the cap. That said, it is preferred by me for user gun stocks because it can be (and needs to be) renewed so easily.

Adding oil and thinner to varnish makes it less viscous and slower to cure, just the ticket for a wipe-on finish. This formula dilutes the hardness and toughness of the varnish by addition of the oil. For some reason this solution to the wipe-on need is attractive to many finishers in spite of the fact that it leads to a poorer finish, a finish slower to build thickness and the need to keep on hand three materials to formulate the finish.

Meanwhile back at the lab the varnish company has more options to achieve wipe-on performance without compromising the durability and hardness of the final cured film. I expect they use lower molecular weight resins, but that is speculation. Fine Woodworking evaluated a bunch of these products a couple of years ago. When I need a wipe-on varnish I choose from these products. It would appear that one can obtain the performance of a good varnish with wipe-on application properties.

BTW, when Curtis Buchannan demonstrated to our club he used raw linseed oil for the finish.

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#9

Re: Why the oil?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

When Curtis demonstrated chair finishing for our club he used raw linseed oil, stating that he avoided materials with synthetic ingredients and driers. However, he was having problems doing the buffing required for this finish as ti was hard on the wrists. Maybe he has overcome aversion to synthetic stuff to save his wrists.?.

Re: Brush-on Wipe-on finishes?

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Why the oil?

Jack Guzman from Maine

I'd like to ask him but it doesn't matter that much to me. All I know is he uses it on chairs for his clients and it works for me too.I really like the end result. ---Jack