Possible stoopid question
Terry Alexander
I am cleaning up 2 old planes that I inherited. I need to remove some scratches from the sole. Q: Do I use the emery cloth wet or dry?
Terry Alexander in West Texas.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Possible stoopid question
Terry Alexander
I am cleaning up 2 old planes that I inherited. I need to remove some scratches from the sole. Q: Do I use the emery cloth wet or dry?
Terry Alexander in West Texas.
Re: Possible stoopid question
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
How deep are these scratches? If they're really deep, trying to sand them out can make the sole of the plane irregular; even if they're light, hand sanding enthusiastically can affect the sole's flatness.
Scratches rarely have any functional downsides, in my experience. If there are burrs, yes, remove those; but don't worry about the "depressed" part of the scratch.
But, to answer your original question: Emery cloth, if you have actual emery cloth, is usually used dry. Wet-or-dry paper smooths best, and loads up least, when used wet. Put gloves (latex, neoprene, nitrile) on and use mineral spirits (paint thinner). If you've got an old dishpan or kitty litter pan (cleaned out), work in that, so you can keep dipping your paper in the mineral spirits, and also so you can easily recycle it when you're done.
We 40?
Joseph Piotrowski
Can you wet sand using WD 40? Or I should say should I have?
Re: Possible stoopid question
Jesper, Denmark
Hi Bill,
Why mineral spirits? Water seems to do the trick.
Re: We 40?
Bruce, a MN Galoot
Wet sanding with WD40 works well. Messy, but it works.
Don't worry about scratches
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
A user plane is not a beauty contest. And in any case the perfect sole will soon be scratched. The only thing important about the sole is whether it is flat. If it is not flat an inexperienced flattener has a good chance of making it worse than better, as evidenced by the experience of some in our club.
Clean off the grime, sharpen the blade and put it to work.
I use water for wet/dry paper
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Not sure why one would use a solvent.
Re: Possible stoopid question
Jack Guzman from Maine
If you are determined to remove scratches in the sole use the emery cloth on a known flat surface. I have a granite flattening plate I bought years ago. Thick glass or tile also works. Also use care when doing this. As Bill says,it's easy to do damage to the shape.---Jack
Re: I use water for wet/dry paper
William Duffield
I have enough problems with rust in my shop without exacerbating it with water on cast iron plane soles and surface plates. If you have to use a solvent, choose one that is less toxic than paint thinner, and wear nitrile gloves. I usually use odorless mineral spirits or WD-40.
Re: Possible stoopid question - Update
Terry Alexander
This is an inexpensive Stanley G12-247 plane. Heck, they can be purchased on eBay for under $15. I "inherited" another big Stanley plane that the sole measures 9 3/4" long (I will ask for assistance on identifying it from y'all later). Both are rusted and suffer from just lack of use....not necessarily abuse. I am "practicing" on the G12 so that I "might" know what I'm doing when I start on the bigger Stanley plane.
I started with regular 150 grit sandpaper (I didn't have any of the black/emery stuff) and I can see where it is not flat. I have a pretty much polished front and back, but the middle part of the plane still shows obvious scratches (not real deep.....but you can see them).
Thus the reason for my original question. I have a flat piece of 1/4" plate glass and I intend to start with 200 grit and keep working up. What I am hearing from y'all (and I do trust your knowledge) is that I should wet the emery first.
I hope to post pics (hopefully) later this week. Darn but I wished I had taken before pics.
Thanks to you all!
Terry Alexander in West Texas
Re: Possible stoopid question
Ralph Lipeles
Jack's approach is best. I restore several dozen planes a year. I usually use a wire brush spun on a lathe or drill press to remove most of the rust. Then sand, dry, on a flat surface, to remove stubborn pitting and raised areas caused by scratches. If you don't have a surface plate a glass shop usually will have a scrap of thick glass which is ground flat on both surfaces. In a pinch, the cast iron surface on a table saw, or other tool will do.
Re: Possible stoopid question
Hank Knight
I have found lapping plane soles on a flat surface with sandpaper to be a very slow, labor-intensive process, the results of which are iffy at best. I found a guy named "tablesawtom" over on WoodNet who reconditions and sells planes. For a reasonable fee, he will flatten the sole of your plane with his surface grinder. The grinding is very precise, and it not only perfectly flattens the sole, it removes all but the most severe cosmetic blemishes. He has done two of my planes, a 604 with a warped sole and a 604 1/2C. He did a great job on both. I highly recommend his work.
Re: Possible stoopid question
Joe Mohnike
I use old sections of belt sander, various grits. I use spray adhesive to adhear them to a piece of plexi glass. I use them dry. When necessary I will touch up with a fine grit (220-320) also on a longer flat surface or on a small hand held block. I have at times buffed the sole and sides with various jewlers compounds. The higher the polish the less rusting in the future. I have over 200 planes, all acquired/purchased in rusty, some siever, and been able to restore them all. Good luck and have fun.
Re: Possible stoopid question
Jim Hoeller
I have beem using about one-half of a granite tombstone that I bought from a monument dealer. It had a flaw in it and dealer used a chisel to break it in half. The back is dead flat and the dimensions are about 15"X15"X4". The cost was $5.00.