Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

end mills

Posts

end mills

#1

end mills

Bruce Mack

I have been asked to make a 5" long, 1 1/2" deep, 1/4" wide slot in an elongate piece of cocobolo (12 x 2 x 2) to house the narrow end of a steel plate. The plate has three 2" holes drilled it it. My friend, a craftswoman, will use stained glass in these small portholes.

While I have a router and table, I don't think this is the solution for such depth, even with successive 1/4" passes. I don't want to make blind cuts and don't like the idea of cocobolo dust filling the shop.

I can use a 1/4" Forstner bit in the drill press, with many overlapping holes followed by chisel work to smooth the walls as best I can. Or, can I follow the Forstner with a side-cutting end mill, mounted in the drill press and slide the cocobolo back and forth against a guide edge?

Questions: Would the lateral pressure against the chuck damage it (probably not)?

What kind of end mill should I buy to assure lateral cutting?

At what speed should I run the drill press?

If you have other suggestions, I welcome them. Thanks.

Re: end mills

#2

Re: end mills

Hank Knight

This sounds like a job for a hollow chisel mortiser. They don't sling fine dust everywhere like a router, and you can easily drill 1 1/2" deep mortises with one. Know anybody that's got one you can use?

Re: end mills

#3

Re: end mills

Bruce Mack

No, Hank. I'll have to do a work-around.

Re: end mills

#4

Re: end mills

Hank Knight

If you wete closer, you would be welcome to use mine.

Re: end mills

#5

Re: end mills

AZ in Colorado Springs

How about drilling a series of 3/16" holes with a Brad point and then cleaning up at the router table? Still a deep & blind cut at the router table, but just cleanup work. A feather board would be helpful. You'll likely get straighter, cleaner walls, unless you're good with the chisel.

Re: end mills

#6

JL

Re: end mills *LINK*

JL

I would still use a router with a vacuum attachment if I were doing it. Whiteside has a 1/4" spiral upcut bit in solid carbide.

If you do want to go the endmill route, try MSC.


1/4" endmill

Re: end mills

#7

Re: end mills

John in NM

I do side load my drill press chuck fairly often, making three 1/4" holes into one 3/4" slot. I've never had any problem doing it, but I do know that the risk with side loading a chuck is not in damaging the chuck, but having it come off the Jacobs taper if that is how it's mounted to the drill press. Not all Jacobs chucks are on a tapered shaft but many are.

I would bet you would be ok doing it this way, especially pre-drilling with a forstner and overlapping those holes. I would just be careful to capture the piece between two fences so it can really just slide back and forth to make the slot.

Re: end mills

#8

Re: end mills

William Duffield

Festool Domino DF700 XL. A minor issue is that it's end mills and depth stops are metric, so you would need to shim the sides of the mortise with some veneer, or fill it with epoxy or other adhesive.

Re: end mills

#9

Ellis Walentine

Couple things

Ellis Walentine

I personally would not rout a 1/4" slot by 1 1/2" deep in anything, much less cocobolo, at least not with a hand held router unless you jig it up so there is no chance of tilting or tipping the router. That's a pretty dangerous cut. If you make a couple parallel guides and attach them to your router base to keep the workpiece centered, that might work, but you'd want to do it before you cut the piece off to 5", otherwise you won't be able to hold it adequately AND flank it solidly with your guides.

I also wouldn't try a hollow-chisel mortiser because of the density of the wood. You'll end up smoking your chisel and bit.

If the hole doesn't have to be dead smooth, which I can't imagine it does, I'd plunge side-by-side holes with a Forstner bit as someone else suggested, and clean out the mortise with chisels. The curved walls of the drill holes act as a depth gauge that make it pretty easy to chisel the opening straight and smooth.

Ellis

Re: end mills

#10

Re: end mills

Pete in Holland MI

Generally, a drill press chuck doesn't have a stiff enough quill to keep the cutter steady. Your cutting action is several inches away from the bearings, unlike on a milling machine. You may experience chatter if you get too aggressive on your cut.

Re: end mills

#11

Re: Couple things

Barry Irby

I agree with Ellis. (not only is he the boss around here, but he is also right in my opinion.) My thought about using a router was "Somebody is going to lose and eye".

I have a hollow chisel motiser and the same type attachment for a drill press. This is not a job for that. It would wreck the bit.

A router bit would have too much whip and break.

Cocobolo? I'm itching already

I would use the Forsner bit and drill it as described and use a very sharp chisel to "slick" the sides. And I would rig up a vacuum to suck up the crap. And take a Zyrtec.

Another approach. Why not cut the piece apart, remove the offending material and glue it back together. Carefully done the joins would be nearly invisible.

Re: end mills

#12

Re: end mills

john B

What if you use the router to cut a slot 1/8 deep and use the slot to guide your forstner bit. john b.

Re: end mills

#13

JL

What Barry said

JL

Why not cut it in "half" and do a rabbet on one side.

You could use your router table or a table saw.

Gluing it back up would be "interesting" - but there are glues that would work with cocobolo.

Re: end mills

#14

Re: end mills

John McGaw

Honestly, for a one-off, if I thought that it was beyond accomplishing with a good sharp carbide spiral in the router table (small cuts!) I'd just go to a real machine shop and ask them to do it. Yes, I know that isn't metal but if you tell them that the wood isn't much different than soft aluminum they could probably be convinced at a price. With no lubricant spray but with somebody holding a shop vac hose right at the cutting point it wouldn't be too messy. With a real milling machine you could be certain of the accuracy.

If I was doing it I'd be using the sliding-table mortiser on my Robland X31. I've done the equivalent cut many times in various hardwoods although not with cocobolo. The Robland uses standard plunge-cutting milling bits and can easily plunge 3"+ deep and is very repeatable as long as the work and stops are locked down properly.

Re: end mills

#15

Re: end mills

Bruce Mack

Thanks everyone. I'll go with the Forstner and chisel. I might have played with the end mill also, but it's too expensive.

Re: end mills

#16

And another thought.....

Barry Irby

Got a table saw and Dado set?

Put your 1/4" set on, set the fence, clamp the piece in place and raise the blade into the work. That will give you a lot of it. The slot would have a crescent shaped bottom, but you could then drill that out and clean it up. You would have to experiment to get the right placement and number of times to crank the blade up, but it would work.

Be extremely careful if you do this. Keep your hands clear and stay out of the line of fire just in case. Clamp the work. Do not try to hold it with your hands.

Re: end mills

#17

comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I can use a 1/4" Forstner bit in the drill press, with many overlapping holes followed by chisel work to smooth the walls as best I can." That will work with little risk of screw ups so long as the piece is securely clamped.

"Or, can I follow the Forstner with a side-cutting end mill, mounted in the drill press and slide the cocobolo back and forth against a guide edge? " I suspect this approach will fail. Drill presses make poor milling machines.

I would chop it out with a hollow chisel mortise on a drill press. The dedicated machines spin too fast,....I don't know why. I throttle my drill press to the slowest speed to run the hollow chisel mortise. Don't have the attachment? Have I got a deal for you. I have an extra.

Re: end mills

#18

Re: end mills

EdSnow

I would encourage you not to use the end mill in your drill press. Most drill presses do not have a drawbar to hold the taper of the chuck in. Any radial vibration will potentially loosen the tapers and drop the chuck out likely ruining you cocobolo.

Re: end mills

#19

I'd go with the router first, *LINK*

Keith Newton

But with a router bit, not an end mill. Even if you can't get that deep, it will give you a good guide for the drilling that you may need to finish up with. .

If you are using a plunge router, you should only be dropping about 1/8" per pass, so as to not have bit flex. Here is a link to a bit that I would choose. The spiral blade is only 3/4", so beyond that, the shank would act as it's own guide or rub collar. A regular touch with a paraffin stick would keep it from burning.

Otherwise, if you had a bunch to do, I'd use the Ts with dado blade, then use a filler strip which is a little taller than the depth, as a simple detail.


http://www.toolstoday.com/p-5178-solid-carbide-spiral-flute-plunge-for-solid-wood-2-flute-upcut.aspx

Re: end mills

#20

Re: I'd go with the router first,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

And if you decide to go with a router, at least for the first part, try to find a 1/4" bit with a half inch shank, as it's much more rigid.

Re: end mills

#21

Re: end mills

TomD

I would farm it out to someone with a milling machine. I used to have a foot powered single bevel chisel mortiser, and that would probably work, you can convert any mortising machine into a single bevel manual mortiser.

Not exactly the same, but I use a dowelling jig and a twist drill to gang holes for the really deep mortises one needs for the end of a stretcher on a trestle table.

For some reason the Krenov clan was enamored with the davis and wells horizontal boring machine and a four flute end mill. hand fed. One can make something similar out of a lathe if you have one. Speed has to be low. A better set-up is a horizontal mill which can be very cheap and can be used freehand or all hatches down.

Davis and Wells:


Burke Mill ( like that I use):


Re: end mills

#22

outcome

Bruce Mack

I trapped the cocobolo between 2 fences glued to a piece of masonite, allowing it to slide over a 5" range. The 1/4" Forstner bit I used had difficulty getting deep. The chips impacted in the slot and required physical removal and vacuuming. The bit did best with incremental depth changes until I reached 1 1/2" depth.There was some chattering and loss of registration between holes as I overlapped, but a narrow profile chisel removed the ridges and a mortise chisel squared the ends. The metal plate was readily driven to 1" depth with a hammer to a snug fit and could be removed by striking the cocobolo with a rubber mallet.

Next time I would get a quality Forstner bit as mine, from an inexpensive set, had a rudimentary rim in that small size. A mill would have been perfect but as it was, the Forstner left just a slightly irregular shadow line at plate edge which disappeared with dark filler.

Re: end mills

#23

Glad it worked out

John in NM

And you're right, a quality bit makes a big difference. I've bought acceptable import bits from Woodcraft and a couple others, but I've also gotten unusable imports from various other vendors. I particularly like the Famag bits from Traditional Woodworker.

Even the best forstner bit can wander to a surprising degree, especially on a deep hole where the bit gets clogged. Sounds like you quickly came up with a work around though.