It is time to refinish the top of my Sjoberg workbench. I have light sanded it and now need recommendations for the sealer. They use Lacroma Clear 25 from Sherwin Williams on new benches. I have not checked with SW to see if it is available. Has lasted an amazing long time.
Why do you want to put a finish on the bench? What do you want this finish to accomplish for you- looks, abrasion resistance, solvent resistance, etc. ?
The is nothing special about the SW finish. I expect it was used mainly because it meets the air quality requirements for where it was applied, and not because it has some performance attribute that makes it best for a bench. If you just want a varnished bench that looks close to new put any finish on it.
If I was making benches I would finish them with a high performance floor finish. But these are expensive finishes, too expensive to put on something that just needs to look good to get it sold.
Personally I have never added finish to my bench. I put a piece of 1/8" Masonite on it and change it every few years.
My bench was made to be used so I just put on a coat of some polyurethane to retard stain splotches and glue drips, and it looks like it. But I'm careful to try to not cut into it with a saw or chisel , but it looks like that also. I would just go with some poly and call it good.
When I finished building an ash version of the Klaus bench, I wiped on two or three coats of boiled linseed oil to warm up the wood a bit. There is a ring from a wet coffee cup, but I have a separate bench with a melamine surface I use for gluing, staining, et cetera.
Ivan, as a predominantly handtool woodworker, my bench is the most important tool in the shop. I check it periodically for flatness, since this provides a reference for working on pieces. It also makes items more stable. When you noted that you had sanded your surface down, did you also check it for flatness? I would correct mine with a handplane. I would not use a sander, which is more likely to leave a depression.
Once flat, some like to leave it without a finish, or even rough up the surface a little for grip. I wipe on a thin coat of danish oil to aid in removing glue or finish than my drip.
Actually, it is time for me to do the same as you.
Flatten routinely and plane a new surface when the current one gets too ugly. Clean is important, but scratch and dent is fine so long as it does not create an effect which can damage the work.
If a tabletop, most people would suggest a similar finish treatment on both the upper and lower surfaces so moisture moves into and out of the surfaces more equally.
Thanks for the replies. I just ran over it with a fine flat sponge so as not to mess up the flatness. Just need a new topcoat to seal it from the usual spills.
I do not sand the top of my benches, because the abrasive left in the surface will dull plane and scraper blades, which I use as needed to clean the tops. Whenever I get glue drips or other stuff above the surface of a bench top, I scrape it smooth with a card scraper. I do not put poly on bench tops, because I don't keep poly in my shop, because it is inappropriate for fine furniture. They are work surfaces, so whenever I'm finishing a project with danish oil, varnish, wax, or even shellac or epoxy*), I wipe whatever finish is left over onto the bench top (unless I need to use the bench top before the finish would have dried).
*I seldom have any epoxy left over, because I try not to mix up any more than I need for the task at hand, and I try to select a hardener with an appropriate cure time, so it has usually started to kick by the time I would be ready to wipe it on the bench top.