Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Sliding dovetails

Posts

Sliding dovetails

#1

Sliding dovetails

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I'm building a cabinet for a friend, and it's made of solid cherry (imagine, cherry grown in MN!) Anyway, since it's of solid wood construction, the only joinery that comes to mind to join shelves, tops and bottoms is sliding dovetails.

I've done bunches of sliding dovetails in the past, but always the tapered version, always double-sided, meticulously cut using an electric router. I was lucky enough to have Bill Tindall and his lovely wife for lunch guests some time back, and Bill suggested cutting the dovetails by hand. The method he learned at the Headley shop was quicker and easier than doing it by machine, plus it didn't have to either taper or be double-sided. Sounded like a bit of a challenge.

Well, a bit of time passed, and I got around to it a couple weeks back. Following the instructions he posted here a few years back, I made an angled guide from a 2X4


and made a perpendicular cut across a test piece with a backsaw. Then I used the angled side of my guide to cut the dovetailed part. Sorry, but I didn't take process pictures. The waste got chiseled out and then bottom evened up with a router plane.

Here's the result:


I didn't clamp the joint, so it's not as tight as it could have been.

The big revelation, other than how well it went together, is how easily it went together.

This is a 15" long, straight sliding dovetail, not tapered in the least. I was apprehensive because Titebond grabs so fast I thought I'd never get the two parts slid together. So, Bill says, use liquid hide glue (or in a later email, he said also white glue).

What the heck, says I. So I grabbed my bottle of Old Brown Glue and applied an appropriate amount.

The big revelation was that these two pieces, which fit quite snugly, slid together like they were greased. That would never have happened with yellow glue.

Try it, you'll like it.

My big thanks to Bill Tindall for his generous help with my project.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#2

Re: Sliding dovetails

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well done, Bruce!

Joinery with handtools can be very fast, and on many occasions much faster than a machine, especially when there are only a few joints to make. Handtools are point-and-shoot. No, I am not going to try and convert anyone to handtools - I come here because I also use power tools. But I do strongly believe that one should be adept with both hand- and power tools to maximise one's potential in the shop.

That said, I have a number of planes and allied tools that I set up, ready-to-go to make sliding dovetails. Or it could be as simple as sawing by eye and chiseling the waste out. Yell out if you are interested in seeing these.

Planing the dovetail ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sliding dovetails

#3

Bruce, how do you cut the...

Barry Irby

other piece, the piece that slides in? I have done lots with the electric router, but none by hand.

The last ones I did with yellow glue were a panic. Tried pounding one in but soon realized yellow glue has excellent (and quick) grip and really resists impact. Using a clamp to drive it home was the answer. Do a dry fit, be ready with everything set up and at hand, apply the glue and add clamp pressure when necessary. The gently pressure seems to liquify the glue and let the parts slide. Saved my bacon. That said, next time it Old Brown Glue for me.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#4

Re: Bruce, how do you cut the...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I cut that on the router table. I don't have a dovetail plane, though I like it well enough that I'll probably make one like Derek's.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#5

Many ways ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

There are many ways to make sliding dovetails with hand tools.

Much of the time I simply saw the socket walls and chisel out the waste ...

The saw uses a fence with the chosen angle.




Level with a router plane ...


This plane can also create the walls of the socket ..


It has a nicker on each side of the body to prevent spelching. The sole is skewed to cut a flat groove when planing at an angle ..


Details here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/PlaningTheSlidingDovetail.html

I built my first dovetail plane 10 years ago: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/EvolvingADovetailPlane2.html

Here it is blinged up ...


As shown earlier, it planes like this ..


More recently, I modified a Stanley #79 to cut both the male and female sides of the joint ..





Details here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/SlidingDovetailsWithTheStanley79.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sliding dovetails

#6

Re: Sliding dovetails

William Duffield

Im also an advocate of Old Brown Glue. I keep it in the refrigerator, and decant enough for the project at hand into a small squeeze bottle that I put in my pocket at the beginning of the session to keep it warm.

Franklin's liquid hide glue performs similarly, but flows better at cooler temperatures.

If you don't happen to have hide glue on hand, there are methods you can use with yellow glue that will increase your odds of success. But remember, with aliphatic resin and most other glues, you only get one chance. Dry fit the joint to make sure it doesn't bind. Have your clamp for closing the joint set up, adjusted, close at hand, and ready to go. Close up the joint to within an inch or two of done. Apply glue to the tail at one end and the slot at the other end, and immediately close the joint with the clamp.

If you use hide glue, leave a message inside the case for your granddaughter or great granddaughter:

Hide glue only used in assembly. You can completely and reversibly disassemble it with water and heat. No steel pneumatic fasteners were used in construction. No tool belts were worn during construction.

Love,

Grandpa

Re: Sliding dovetails

#7

A reason not to use Old Brown Glue

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It has a shorter shelf life than Franklin due to the different way it is made liquid. But, if you can accommodate the shorter shelf life and prefer to support a small company it is a preferred choice.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#8

Re: A reason not to use Old Brown Glue

William Duffield

How does Franklin do it? IIRC, Patrick Edwards adds urea to liquify OBG. As I noted earlier, that's why I keep it refrigerated, but I'm sure cycling the temperature through the refrigerator and glue pot multiple times puts some "wear and tear" on it. No matter what hide glue I use, I test it periodically with the pinch test, or whatever you want to call it. I also prefer the Franklin for repairing small chips and bubbles in veneer, because it is very runny, and wicks under the veneer very easily. A piece of blue tape will clamp it down until it dries.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#9

hide glue chemistry

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Patrick Edwards adds urea to liquify " Something needs to be added to protein to turn it from insoluble solid into something that will dissolve in water. Urea is the classic.

Urea reacts with water to yield ammonia. If it didn't it would be pointless to add urea fertilizer to whatever needs nitrogen to grow. Ammonia reacts with protein to break the protein into shorter pieces. The shorter pieces can't entangle, think elbow macaroni vs spaghetti. It is the entanglement of the long molecules that results in the glue's toughness. To break the glue one has to break apart molecules rather then just separate them from one another. Breaking molecules apart requires greatly more force than simply separating them.

You can pull strings from "good" glue because the molecules are still long and entangled, just as you can lift the whole plate of entangled spaghetti by lifting a part of the entangled mass. If the molecules have become chopped up from the ammonia the strands are not entangled and they break between the molecules.

It is often not appreciated how much technical horsepower a company can devote to solve a problem or improve a product. In the case of hide glue a chemical other than urea was found that would do the job of making the glue water soluble. This chemical does not degrade the protein.

The protein can still degrade by attack from mold and bacteria. If it does it will smell bad, very bad. And the water will slowly chop the protein into smaller pieces, but much slower than ammonia. Kept in the frig the Franklin hide glue will stay serviceable a very long time. For this reason I prefer it.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#10

Re: hide glue chemistry

AZ in Colorado Springs

Does this mean that the longer strings cannot reconnect at a later point, say when the solvent flashes off?

Re: Sliding dovetails

#11

strings explained- glue good to go test

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't understand your question but I will take a guess at an answer. Not sure what "strings" you are referring to.

A test for liquid hide glue is as follows: Rub some glue between thumb and 1st finger until it begins to dry some, then pull thumb and finger apart. Good glue will make "strings" connecting thumb and finger as they separate. What is happening is glue fibers are being spun from the dissolved protein polymer. Spiders would be impressed.

To spin a fiber the fiber molecules, protein in this case, must be tangled up one with anohter. As the glue, in this case, is pulled apart the tangled up molecules stuck to the thumb pull along the molecules that were in between creating a fiber connecting the thumb and finger.

For example, if you had a bucket full of long yarn strands all tangled up you could grab a small group of strands and pull it out of the bucket. All the tangled up rest of the strands would follow because of entanglement. However, if the strands were short, think shorter molecules, as a small group of strands were pulled they would break loose from the rest.

This example is analogues to pulling a fiber made of long polymer molecules. As some of the molecules start to be pulled they connect to the rest of the molecules by entanglement and the rest are pulled along making a fiber.

I made fried eggs this morning and the long egg white "snot" that hangs down from the broken egg shell is held together by the entangled egg white protein. Liquid composed of short molecules like water would just separate into drops.

To make a tough glue you need the glue to have long entangled molecules. To break the glue requires breaking the entangled molecules apart, and that takes a lot of force. So any test of long molecules will show if the glue is good or it has decomposed into shorter useless molecules.

Franklin suggests making a film from the hide glue and letting it dry. When dry the glue is "good" if the film is tough. If it is brittle its molecules are too short and the glue is breaking between the molecules, and not breaking apart the entangled molecules themselves. The spinning fiber test is quicker to perform.

When you get a new bottom of glue, spin some fibers to get calibrated as to how good glue performs. Test periodically and when the fibers between the thumb and finger break prematurely, buy new glue.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#12

Re: strings explained- glue good to go test

AZ in Colorado Springs

You did answer my question, Bill. What I meant by "strings" were the longer protein strands. You wrote that the ammonia breaks them into shorter strands. I was wondering if they could reform longer strands. Alas, no, otherwise there'd be no need to test the glue's performance.

Working off the small screen of the Android phone makes difficult to go back to review so as to ask a coherent question the first time.

I appreciate your comprehensive answer.

Re: Sliding dovetails

#13

Re: strings explained- glue good to go test

William Duffield

Me too, Bill! Thanks for another very lucid and scientific explanation. Your glue chemistry research should help all of us to choose the most appropriate glue for each application.