Dummy me, I let the tops of my table saw and lathe develop a light rust sitting in my garage without use. I need to remove it, but really don't want to spend hours sanding, particularly with two bad shoulders. Is there a "magic solution" to help me deal with my laziness and dumbness (is that a word???)
I just spent a day doing the same thing. What I used was Rust Free and 000 steel wool. It took a while to get to a good surface. Good enough for me. There are many ways to get that rust off but I don't want to change the surface of the machines. Maybe a slightly courser steel will would have been faste.
i use this stuff and never no rust on none of my items and lots of them , sears carries this i don't like sears but i have to go their for the quick buy
My goal for this problem is to remove loose rust and leave what isn't. I don't recommend that you grind on the metal. If you have a Scotch bright pad I would use it with some light oil or WD 40 as a lubricant. The loose rust will come off easily. The stain will be there forever so just live with it. As an alternate to a Scoth-brit, a fine wet or dry paper will work, maybe about 600 or so. If you have none of these just try some steel wool and lube, or a wire brush on a drill or by hand. The idea is to dislodge the loose rust and leave hard metal and discolored metal behind.
I had the same issue last week - I left a thin piece of freshly cut white oak on my bandsaw table for a couple of days which made a big rusty mess. I used a scotchbrite pad with a little C.L.R. - took the rust right off. (I use rubber gloves with this) Then I cleaned and used a little WD-40 with a paper towel then with a fresh abrasive pad. In this case, the cast iron table looks like new again, or at least as good as the rest of the table.
I am not the least concerned with any tool discoloration in steel or cast iron from corrosion but I do want a table flat and smooth. If cast iron is pitted from severe rust or another reason I make it flat by squeegeeing JR Weld epoxy into the pits and then sand smooth with a sanding block. I did this years ago with a cast iron lathe tool rest that had some annoying tool-catching pits on the top. It has been fine since then.
Rust is, of course, iron oxide. So the trick is to stop the oxidation. Sanding won't do that but phosphoric acid will. Sold under different trade names (Rust-Off, CLR, The Must For Rust, etm) it gets applied to the surface after loose rust is removed with wool of some kind. The acid breaks the oxide bond resulting in free oxygen and tiny dark gray crystals of iron phosphate. The benefit here is that the acid penetrates all the way to the bottom of the tiny pits to stop the oxidation reaction. The crystals then act as a sealer to prevent further rusting for a while. Rub down with stool wool or Scotchbite and some paste wax and you're good to go, although a bit of WD-40 rubbed in before the wax coat won't hurt.
All well and good if the black residue of iron phosphate is not objectionable. The iron oxide gets turned into iron phosphate as you said, the oxygen from the rust becomes water. This treatment could be useful for a severely rusted surface.
However, a cast iron surface will be always coated with iron oxide. But the coating will stop at the surface so long as there is not excessive moisture. Rust does not beget rust; moisture begets rust.
Indeed, a coating of iron phosphate becomes a barrier to further rusting. I am fond of the phosphoric acid treatment for outdoor exposure, and then follow it with paint. But for an indoor saw table, removing loose "surface" rust that might rub off on your maple drawer front is all that is necessary so long as the humidity of the shop stays moderate. The corrosion that occurred when the table was wet will not continue once it becomes sufficiently dry.
>>>50% relative humidity to be safe. Sometimes difficult to achieve in a shop environment.
I have a Robland sliding table attachment for my PM66 table saw. The table is cast iron.
In their manual, Robland recommend a different method to protect their cast iron: periodically use a blackboard eraser and rub pure talc powder into the surface. They say the fine talc worked into the pores keeps out moisture and prevents corrosion. I've been doing this for several years now instead of using wax or some type of metal protecting film. It nicely "lubricates" the surface too.
The only problem was finding talc that didn't have perfumes and additives for use in the baby's room. Amazon carries talc for billiards players: https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B005U4A9KW
Is the substitution of the result of litigation for the result of scientific study.
To return to the actual topic under discussion, in many cases manufacturers have been substituting corn starch for talc in baby powder type products. I would imagine that the results on cast iron would be somewhat different for each.
Unless the talc in question has oil in it, talc by itself will do nothing to prevent corrosion. There is no table top chemistry that I can think of that talc would participate in. It is about as inert as sand. Formulated talc for baby bottoms and girdles could be another story. What is in the talc might do something beneficial. But why even consider talc.......
The best thing to put on a saw top that will not compromise woodworking is a buffed coat of wax. For storage, use Boshield T8 or a layer of grease.
It is hydrophilic on the molecular scale and hydrophobic on the liquid scale. Pretty neat really.
I would expect that it is an effective barrier for condensation in very humid environments, though perhaps not as good as wax. I don't imagine that the hydrophilic behavior with airborne moisture would be a benefit however.