Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Posts

OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#1

OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Don Orr

Looking to the brain trust here for some help/advice on silver soldering-actually brazing I believe. I have some JW Harris filler and flux that I have used before but not for quite a while. The flux-Stay Silv White-has gotten somewhat dry and I want to know if there is some way to reconstitute it back to a useable paste. I read through the SDS info on their site but it does not indicate any kind of solvent or diluent or carrier to keep it soft enough to spread. Does anyone know if I can just mix some with a little water to soften it or would something else work or is it just not worth it ? I'm making small hollowing tools from HSS and mild steel Like Bob Rosand uses.

Thanks.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#2

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

John K Jordan

Don, I'm only familiar with white brazing flux that can be thinned with water as needed. I understand it can be difficult to reconstitute if it dries hard. The water is only to keep it in place on the surface. The water boils off quickly, then at a higher temperature the flux melts, then the sliver.

I always used an oxy-acetylene torch with a neutral flame. It's been a while since I've done any brazing/sliver soldering so my flux is probably dried out too. I've never brazed carbide to steel.

I also have some that is powder. Heat the bronze rod and dip in into the powder to get a glob on the rod, braze a bit then repeat. I was told the powdered flux can be mixed with water to make a paste. I think distilled water is supposed to be better but not required.

Some of my brazing rods have a coating of white flux.

JKJ

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#3

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Keith Newton

I don't know the answer to your flux question either, but would just like to say that back when I was experimenting with making some small turning tools, that I found mild steel to be too flexible, and prone to chatter. I switched to stainless, and got much better results.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#4

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Forrest Addy

I'm frequent user of the silver brazing process. The white flux sold by Harris contains sodium flourite, sodium hydroxide, and possibly a Harris secret sauce. Not human skin friendly. The solvent is water.

I've reconstituted crusty Harris flux with a few drips of hot water and a lot of stirring. Add a few drops at a im. The difference between too think and too thin is only a few drops. You want it like mayonnaise. Cruch the chunks with the blunt end of a rod or a wood stick. Needless to say with those two reactive components use non-reactive vessels and utensils.

I have a mortar and pestle that I scoop the crunchy flux into, grind it up, add water, and etc until I get the consistency I want. A silicone spatula cleans the flux from the mortar back into the original jar. Everything cleans up with hot water ready for and other use.

Dont heat the cheap plastic flux container in the microwave. Even mild heat shrinks the jar so the lid wont fit.

The white flux doesn't have much staying power. Use plenty, heat quickly, and avoid over-heating like the plague.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#5

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Don Orr

Thanks everyone for the excellent advice.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#6

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Chuck

You can go to the grocery and buy Borax and use it. I used it for many years when I was working. heat your rod, dip it in the Borax and go!

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#7

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Robin Corell in Atascadero

I've been using the same little jar or stay-silv for over 25 years, in that time its gone almost bone dry a couple times. I just add a bunch of water and put the cap on and let it sit for a few days, then mix it up the best I can with a scrap of welding rod. I don't worry too much about getting all the chunks mixed in or a perfect consistency. I use a bit of 1/16" brass brazing rod that is flattened on one end into a spatula like tool to apply the flux where its needed. Its very easy to not pick up any chunks and just use the paste portion in the jar. In use very little flux is needed, a thin coat on the mating surfaces is all that's necessary. The silver will flow to wherever the flux is so by using less flux you waste less silver. Having a big glob of braze filler around the Joint does very little to add strength.

it is similar to soldering copper in that you can heat the joint and then apply the sliver to the opposite side of where the torch is and the silver will flow towards the heat. That way when you see a thin line of silver show up where the torch is you know the joint is soldered properly rather than moving the silver around the joint and taking a chance of getting voids.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#8

Success!

Don Orr

I dug a little of the flux out of the jar-it is still a little soft-into a separate container and added a little water and mixed it til was about like toothpaste and everything worked quite well. Thanks again for all the excellent advice.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#9

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing *LINK*

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Years ago Forrest Addy and I wrote articles for Woodcentral about silver brazing. Cleanliness is very important. Slowly boil off the water from the flux, you want a 100% white haze before the flux melts.


http://http://woodcentral.com/articles/shop/articles_186.shtml

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#10

Sorry, but those look like an accident waiting

Dick Coers

to happen! Is that just one piece butted to the other? That's a ton of overhang, be very careful!!!!!!!

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#11

Re: Sorry, but those look like an accident waiting

Don Orr

I understand that it seems to be a lot of overhang relative to the centerline of the tool, and your concerns. However, these tools are used to hollow very small globes for Christmas ornaments and therefore do not experience tremendous torque. In the wrong hands, if they engage too much material they can grab and twist in ones' hand without much trouble. The intent is to take small bites and not go through the side of the globe. I have been using these exact tools for many years with no problem but I certainly appreciate your input. Many others have made and used these tools since Bob Rosand described them in an "American Woodturner" article many years ago. His article is where I got the instructions for making these tools.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#12

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

Don Orr

Thanks Bill-the link didn't work but I found the article. I remember meeting you at the last 5 Barns event a few years ago if I recall correctly. Everyone has been very helpful as always. Gotta love WoodCentral

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#13

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

John C Lucas

I used tools like that for years after seeing Bob demo that technique. Eventually i went to bent drill rod soet of question mark shaped with the cutter aligned with the center of the shaft. Redu es the gwisting motion tremendously so its much ldss tiring on the hands. I heat treat the tip so its hard enough to hold a good edge.

I now have a tool custom made that holds a small Hunter carbide tip. it uts really fast and if course never needs to be sharpened. i do mosg of the under cutting with that tool.and then switch to the straight Christmas ornament hollowing tool that Mike sells. He zells a sdt of ornament hollowing tools. They arent like mine. He looked at it but it would be too expensive to build unless you bhild them by the thousands.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#14

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

John C Lucas

I used tools like that for years after seeing Bob demo that technique. Eventually i went to bent drill rod soet of question mark shaped with the cutter aligned with the center of the shaft. Redu es the gwisting motion tremendously so its much ldss tiring on the hands. I heat treat the tip so its hard enough to hold a good edge.

I now have a tool custom made that holds a small Hunter carbide tip. it uts really fast and if course never needs to be sharpened. i do mosg of the under cutting with that tool.and then switch to the straight Christmas ornament hollowing tool that Mike sells. He zells a sdt of ornament hollowing tools. They arent like mine. He looked at it but it would be too expensive to build unless you bhild them by the thousands.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#15

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing - fixed *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

fixed the link

Bob in NJ


//http://woodcentral.com/articles/shop/articles_186.shtml

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#16

Question, why don't you.....

Barry Irby

Just bend them? I made some out of round stock and heated and bent them. The smooth curve makes inserting them easy. I heated and quenched the tip, but they do so little cutting I don't know if you need really superior steel.

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing

#17

Re: OT-Silver Soldering/Brazing - fixed

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Thanks.BT