Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

slot mortise vs domino

Posts

slot mortise vs domino

#1

slot mortise vs domino

Joseph Piotrowski

hey all,

way back, long ago i made the slot mortise jig from a book( router magic?). i liked it. i made a baby changing dresser on a whim in a warm week in November like 15 years ago. i made it all with slot mortise tenon. i could dance on it so the joint is not an issue! lol. i'm fat!

as i eyeball a festool tracksaw, i was wondering about this domino. if anyone has used both router and domino for these loose tenons, how do they compare for ease, accuracy, speed etc.

how is the noise level on a domino? dust extraction?.

when i chose to use a power tool, i'm looking for accuracy, repeatably, dust collection and noise level.

i know its touchy subject with price but lets try to leave that out of the equation. i have a router and biscuit joiner so i'm not looking to spend money i don't have, if it's worth it, i'll save up. i rather be sorry the first time i buy a tool and not ever time i use it. been there done that, more than once :(

TIA,

Joe P.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#2

for starters ...

Ian Neuhaus

the domino is faster in use and because it jigs off itself can often be used referencing off a pencil mark -- a bit like a biscuit jointer.

dust collection is a must -- without it you can't clear the chips from around the cutter. Which points to a tool activated dust collector if you don't already have one.

I have not seen any direct load comparisons, but I wouldn't expect there to be a meaningful difference in strength between the two joint types -- slot morticer or domino re essentially two ways to create the same joint.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#3

Re: slot mortise vs domino

jessecloud

I have both tools and use both techniques.

Slot mortiser is a better tool if you need wide tenons - you can accomplish a similar result by making multiple dominos, though. A slot mortiser needs some attention for workpiece holding and lots of work

for making angled mortises.

The domino, even for simple mortises, is much faster. The dust extraction is almost perfect. I have installed

several hundred dominoes and my Domino machine looks like new. The fit is excellent. Angles are simple and fast to do. Only downside, besides price and less flexibility with mortise size, is that the Domino is somewhat sensitive to technique - not paying close attention can result in an unwanted angle on the mortise or a slightly misplaced mortise - don't ask me how I know that. ;^)

Also, domino is great for situations where you want to take the tool to the workpiece, e.g. a mortise at the end of a long board.

If you don't want to buy domino tenons, you can make your own the same way you would make a tenon for a slot mortiser.

Bottom line for me, I have both, cost to buy is sunk cost, but I use the Domino 98 percent of the time.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#4

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Joseph Piotrowski

I was thinking the opposite way on the tennons. Very boring work, I was thinking of buying the pre-made Festool (there have to be knock offs), even if I stick to my router

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#5

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

I have a JDS Multi-Router slot mortiser. I use 4 flute center cutting end mill bits in it, and find that the 6mm Dominoes fit perfectly in a ¼" mortise. The 8mm Dominoes work well with a 5/16" bit, too.

I also have the Domino machine, and lately I've been using it much more than the Multi-Router.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#6

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Joseph Piotrowski

I just looked up that JDS. Impressive machinery there!

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#7

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Jim Dillon

"... i was wondering about this domino. if anyone has used both router and domino for these loose tenons, how do they compare for ease, accuracy, speed etc."

Joe, I am a big fan of loose tenon joinery. I do not have a slot router setup although I have built the other plunge-router router jig described in Router Magic and use it a LOT. I also have used a Domino (smaller version) for maybe 5 years. Both the jig and Domino are complimentary to one another with the advantage for larger loose tenon joinery going to the plunge router with a 1/2 inch (or larger) bit. While you can cut wider mortises with the Domino, you are limited to the maximum thickness of slightly less than 1/2 inch (actually 10 mm) - if you plan on using the pre-made Dominoes. Working within the confines of the pre-made Dominoes is where the Domino shines.

I did check out the larger version of the Domino and didn't feel it met my OCCASIONAL need (even if I could afford it) for BOTH a thick and wide loose tenon mortise as in the bed I am currently constructing. Instead, I went with router template guides and a plunge router and 1/2 inch bit. For those longer boards, I wish I had a slot mortiser but made do. The guides worked fine and I learnt a new technique.

"...how is the noise level on a domino? dust extraction?."

I wear ear muffs but the noise level is not bad - about like a small router. Dust extraction is absolutely necessary to pull the chips from the mortise. Fortunately, my dust collector (not Festool) fits the intake on the Domino.

".. i'm looking for accuracy, repeatably, dust collection and noise level."

Excellent on the first three and noise level is, like I said, like a small router. In fact its accuracy can become a problem as the size of the pre-made Dominoes changes somewhat as the humidity changes making the Dominoes too large to fit the mortise. Sanding the Domino, or subjecting the Domino to the micro-wave oven removes some moisture but that sorta defeats the "ease-of-use" of the Domino. It should be noted, I have had this problem only with certain sized Dominoes.

Bottom line. As mentioned above, the Domino shines when used within the confines of what it was intended for. Would I buy it again after using it for 5 years? Yes. Hope this helps. Jim

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#8

Great input

Joseph Piotrowski

I appreciate all the answers. I feel armed with enough information to make decisions down the road. So thanks Everybody

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#9

Re: Great input

Larry

Has anyone made there own Hand-Held Mortiser like the one by Stumpy ?

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#10

Re: Great input

Joseph Piotrowski

Interesting jig. I made the jig from router magic and it worked very well.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#11

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Joseph

I am not sure if this will help ... perhaps push you down the slope ... :)

Generally, I build with traditional mortice and tenon joints, and make them with handtools .. chisel and saw. If there are many to do, or it feels tedious (it's meant to be fun, right?), then I have a router I can use to do the mortices. Tenons are just too easy to make.

Now I am about to re-build the kitchen doors, about 20 Shaker frame-and-panels in Rock Maple. My wife wants it done before Christmas! So, I have purchased a Festool Domino 500 to help with this. I am practicing using it now building a bed head. I am fortunate to also own a Festool vacuum cleaner (CT26) with automatic on-off. The VC is an essential part of the set up as the cutter will otherwise bog down. It does not have to be a Festool.

I guess that the point is that some tools are better suited to certain tasks. The Domino seemed to me to be the obvious tool, not just because it can make a mortice as easily as a biscuit cutter, but because it is part of a system that makes this task efficient. You can make your own dominos (loose tenons) if you want, but the beauty of the system is that they are available ready made and quite cheaply. Its all about saving time. That's my rationalisation :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#12

A kitchen done before Christmas......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

and you haven't started! There won't be much time for WoodCentral :(

BTW, the term "Rock Maple" is not in common use in the trade. This species is marketed as "Hard Maple" and that is the name most commonly associated with this species. "Soft Maple" is the other maple lumber marketed from eastern US forests. It comes from the Red Maple tree. Another eastern maple, Silver Maple, is not a species of commercial interest.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#14

Re: A kitchen done before Christmas......

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

It is Rock Maple to Australians. The timber (wood to you) was imported from the USA, so is also Hard Maple (your terminology).

No, have not started the kitchen yet. Lynndy and I have been painting the inside of the house, renovating rooms, and doing all the small chores that have been neglected for some while (while someone-we-know was building you-know-what).

Just the livingroom to finish, and then I can begin.

Does this look like 20-odd kitchen doors? (Maple on lower shelves. Boards are 1-2" thick and 10" wide) ...



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#15

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: slot mortise vs domino

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

It is an impressive machine, and with the various templates can cut very tight tolerance mortises and tenons. It'll also so box joints and dovetails.

Set up can be fidgety and take a bit of time, but the instruction manual is pretty good.

It's pricey, though - about the price of three Domino machines, but once you set it up, it's really in "Production Mode," and you can really fly through a door job, etc. I've had mine fo quite a few years, and I really like using it.

Re: slot mortise vs domino

#16

Beep   Beep

Ian Neuhaus

That's the sound of a truck backing into Derek's driveway

I hope those garage doors are locked :)