Re: slot mortise vs domino
Jim Dillon
"... i was wondering about this domino. if anyone has used both router and domino for these loose tenons, how do they compare for ease, accuracy, speed etc."
Joe, I am a big fan of loose tenon joinery. I do not have a slot router setup although I have built the other plunge-router router jig described in Router Magic and use it a LOT. I also have used a Domino (smaller version) for maybe 5 years. Both the jig and Domino are complimentary to one another with the advantage for larger loose tenon joinery going to the plunge router with a 1/2 inch (or larger) bit. While you can cut wider mortises with the Domino, you are limited to the maximum thickness of slightly less than 1/2 inch (actually 10 mm) - if you plan on using the pre-made Dominoes. Working within the confines of the pre-made Dominoes is where the Domino shines.
I did check out the larger version of the Domino and didn't feel it met my OCCASIONAL need (even if I could afford it) for BOTH a thick and wide loose tenon mortise as in the bed I am currently constructing. Instead, I went with router template guides and a plunge router and 1/2 inch bit. For those longer boards, I wish I had a slot mortiser but made do. The guides worked fine and I learnt a new technique.
"...how is the noise level on a domino? dust extraction?."
I wear ear muffs but the noise level is not bad - about like a small router. Dust extraction is absolutely necessary to pull the chips from the mortise. Fortunately, my dust collector (not Festool) fits the intake on the Domino.
".. i'm looking for accuracy, repeatably, dust collection and noise level."
Excellent on the first three and noise level is, like I said, like a small router. In fact its accuracy can become a problem as the size of the pre-made Dominoes changes somewhat as the humidity changes making the Dominoes too large to fit the mortise. Sanding the Domino, or subjecting the Domino to the micro-wave oven removes some moisture but that sorta defeats the "ease-of-use" of the Domino. It should be noted, I have had this problem only with certain sized Dominoes.
Bottom line. As mentioned above, the Domino shines when used within the confines of what it was intended for. Would I buy it again after using it for 5 years? Yes. Hope this helps. Jim