you have been misinformed
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
"Everyone says you'll never use sandpaper again" Not correct.
I use a cabinet scraper in cases where I need to remove defects that would be slow to remove by hand sanding. A scraper is between a hand plane and sandpaper in my shop in terms of rate of material removal and I use it accordingly. Sanding precedes everything I finish.
It has been proven in many studies that there is no difference in appearance whether a surface has been properly sanded, scraped or planed once a finish is applied that builds a coating of finish. Hence, it is a personal choice as to what you want to do.
In my case I can not get the effect from staining I desire unless I sand. Scraping and planing leaves the surface too open and it drinks up too much stain.
Picture is a walnut sanded and stained surface.
