Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

re-introduction to everyone. long winded

Posts

re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#1

re-introduction to everyone. long winded

Joseph Piotrowski

Woodworking hobby part duex!

The first time around I jumped into woodworking in adult life. Never used hand tools much growing up but when i did it was probably wrong. I was prompted by a fixer up home and a few episode of new yankee workshop. Toss in a few bob vila's and i was enticed. My opinions and option were swayed at the time by the loudest voices. Things like you need a table saw. Those awesome shop tours from seasoned woodworkers. Magazines like wood, then fine woodworking. Too much chatter and not enough experience. I’m a technical person, maybe over analytical in designing things. Ideas turn into the most fantastic, complicated designs that account for very factor under the sun. so i bought tools because i thought i needed them. I never look at alternatives and options. I never went through a process to proof i needed something.

I did make stuff. Never great stuff. But life got in the way of my hobby, so 10-12 years ago i shut down cutting wood. Now i’m back with a new attitude. Since my blackout there are some new (to me terms) movements “maker” and “hybrid woodworker”. Maybe add a third. Tiny house nation(all about downsizing)

I doubt these ideas themselves are new but they are now more front and center in the world. And let me tell you they are liberating! Maybe some maturity on part has lead me change my opinion and options on what i need, what i want to do and how i got about doing it.now i look at a task and evalute what i want, what the level of refinement i need and get it done! In the past i would look so far down the rabbit hole trying to be perfect and make the absolute best thing ever. Then it never gets off the ground or turn out poorly anyway.

This becomes evident in my effort to reclaim some shop space from my garage. Being what things are, i'll never have access to all my garage. In the past i would try and make the ultimate bench or mobile station etc. or making a cabinet for shop tools i look to make perfectly sized space for exact tools. Maybe consider dovetail joinery or other finer quality joint. There are some youtube video where people are all making a certain mitersaw station. I look at that and start to tweak it to i can optimize it and build it for my shop.

I caught myself!

It a slow process but turning to a makers mindset Now i look at what am i building? What is the most time i can spend on it? What the easiest and most functional joint i can use to make it? I may think modular and look at making grooves every 2” inches to divide it up along the way.

So i say, I have some overhead space to use. Let's make cubbies.. I have maybe 4 hours sat. so i say forget dado grooves. Lets use screws/pocket holes to build it.

So this saturday i’ll put it to test. Its relief to get it done and move on. There shop cabenits for a hobby woodwoker. I’m not show casing anything. Why waste money and time wood and high end joinery.

I also am beginning to look at my tools with the same vision What am i cutting, how much am i cutting? Is this tool what i need right now? Experience with my tools shows me i don’t need as much as i have. And that a big mental hurdle! I look at my table saw and really, having set up well, lots of jigs, it is an excellent tool to anchor around. But for the one off here, one off there, i spend too much time making jigs and etc that i’m not getting the benefits from the space it takes up.

So I put it up for sale. The amount of room it frees up is substantial for me. Should i find myself in the need for a table saw in the future, i’ll buy it. I’m not going to be stuck in my current state(going table sawl-ess) out of any pride or duty to an ideal of how i should work. If i want to use a hand tool, i will. If i need a $3000 table saw, i will. And even power hand tools are an option. When my circular saw fails to give me the performance i need, i’ll look at getting a tracksaw.

I do admit a certain appeal to hand tools right now. I think it will give me a closer more intimate relationship with the wood. Understanding its nature and how to work it properly instead of just over power it with machines. And if i chose to use power tools, it make influence how i use them and set them up. But for certain i am favoring the idea of low noise, less dust and some exercise too boot!

Enough rambling. I thought i introduce myself again and vent out this giddy feeling of a new process. My mind is aglow with whirling, transient nodes of thought careening thru a cosmic vapor of invention.

Later Joe P.

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#2

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

ben d.

Look on u-tube for Carl Holmgren and he has a lot of space saving set up's that might be something you could adapt.

Not affiliated with him but it is interesting.

ben d.

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#3

Ellis Walentine

Brilliant

Ellis Walentine

A man after my own heart. Own what you need to, make what you want to. From your long post, I'd say you've uncovered the essence of design: Decide what you want to accomplish then get there by your best means of problem-solving, which includes cost, resources, aesthetics, and any other relevant criterion.

Keep us posted on your journey. And, IMO, think twice about selling the tablesaw. It can be useful...

Cheers,

Ellis Walentine

Host

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#4

that's what I thought

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"IMO, think twice about selling the tablesaw"

The narrative was going along well till I hit this part and wondered....why. The decision seemed to be at odds with the rest.

I would suggest to anyone to decide if their woodworking motivation is to build stuff. If so, get started and it will soon become apparent what tools and skills are needed. Acquire (or keep) the tools and skills needed while working your way up the learning curve.

Alternatively, the motivation may be to work in a life style-18th century cabinet maker, 19th century Japanese carpenter, no electric tools, etc. , and build what your life style and skills enable. It is easier to know beforehand what one needs to support this latter decision. However, the beginning of the learning curve may be steep. Learning to saw a straight line is obviously easier on a table saw than a push, or pull, hand saw, for example, and one won't be making much till sawing a straight line is mastered.

The hardest decision will be for the person with a foot in each camp. Might take years to reach equilibrium and to know what is needed.

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#5

Re: that's what I thought

Barry Irby

I have been thinking about what you said in the original post. I have been accumulating tools for fifty years. I was thinking I was going to make furniture, and I have made some, but not as much as I thought.

It seems you are between two differing thoughts. What to make and how to make it. And example would be, "I want to make dovetails". Now decide if you want to buy the necessary equipment to cut them with a router and a jig, or do you want to cut them by hand. This has been discussed many times here and at length. There is no one answer, only a preference.

Deciding what to build will lead you to deciding how. Another problem is the idea of thinking outside the box. Having a table saw does not prohibit you from ripping lumber with a handsaw. But Having a table saw might mean it never occurs to you to learn to do it by hand. An example might be "My planer is only 12" wide, so I am restricted to designs that use stuff less than 12" wide." If you did not have a planer at all, you might learn to hand plane panels or find a friend or shop that would let you use or pay to use their wider planer or wide belt sander.

Then there is the craftsmanship aspect. Even if you own the router and dovetail jig, you may feel you have not really made dovetails until you cut them by hand.

I agree with Ellis and Bill, I would keep the tablesaw. Welcome back and keep us posted.

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#6

Re: that's what I thought

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

both my sons in law have table saws and neither makes furniture. But they find ample use for one doing "housework".

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#7

Re: that's what I thought

Joseph Mulherin

I bought my Shopsmith back in 1978, upgrade3d it to the '510' series, and still use it regularly.

Have another saw i bought to use outside the shop when necessary, but my main saw is the Shopsmith.

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#8

Re: that's what I thought

Joseph Piotrowski

i need to look at those someday. A combination machine may make sense for me. that is still to be determined. i starting on shop cabinets tonight. need to get it all tidy before making some "stuff"

Re: re-introduction to everyone. long winded

#9

Re: that's what I thought

Joseph Mulherin

Joe, Look at EBAY or Craiglist before buying a new setup from Shopsmith....they are very expensive nowadays. I would upgrade to the 510 series and you can go up to the 520 setup and the new motor is very nice and expensive too.