It's Christmas gift planning time, and I need opinions on material(s) to use.
Project #1 is a set of knock-down yard reindeer for my daughter-in-law. These will, obviously, be exposed to rain/snow here in southern Indiana. I will use a good quality exterior white house paint on these. Plywood or MDO?
Project #2 is a knock-down puppet theater for my grandsons. I' am leaning toward painting it one or more colors, but a natural finish is also a possibility. Plywood, MDO or MDF?
Each of these will be made of 1/2" material, but I am not sure whether to use an exterior grade plywood, a cabinet grade plywood, MDO or MDF. I have experience with the plywoods, but not with MDO, which, as I understand, is often used for exterior sign work. I have limited experience with MDF. Whichever way, I want the projects to last for a while.
No screws will be harmed in the construction of either of these projects...tab A into slot B construction only.
MDO and exterior plywood should be the exact same plywood, but the MDO has a layer of paper on each surface so it paints better. Can't say I would have a preference of one over the other. Can't say I would put a white plywood deer in the front yard either! LOL I'm a bit of a Hum-Bug, based on 40+ years of holiday deadlines on woodworking.
Keep it simple. Use exterior plywood for the deer and put plenty of paint on their feet, where they will be in contact with the ground and snow cover. Make the puppet theater out of inexpensive, big-box cabinet ply (whatever face veneer they happen to be selling). In my opinion, MDO is overkill for either of these projects -- expensive and unnecessary. MDF is too perishable, too heavy, and will warp all over the place.
I think that is good advice, and would only add to see if there is a "real" plywood seller in your area who handles tropical plywood (unless you have some green concerns). The mershawa, etc... stuff is cheaper and 10x better than what the big boxes sell. Exterior grade "mahogany", probably 7 veneer layers, phenolic glue, good both sides no dutchmen, 1/2" 37 dollars. This is not marine grade but it is just as good for how boats are actually made, my pal made his 46' catamaran out of this stuff. Raw the wood in this stuff is not that rot resistant, but Doug Fir is, though it tends not to be easy to get a nice finish one, which is where teh MDO comes in. But with paint or epoxy (feet only if you like) the Asian stuff is a lot better made.
I use MDO for a lot for outside applications (and jigs inside). A few years ago, I made an silhouette goalie out of MDO for my son to use for practice shooting hockey goals. It takes paint beautifully, and the inside veneers seem void free compared to CDX, etc.
Most importantly, the MDO goalie has stood up to years of direct hockey puck slap shots, and lives outside all year. It still looks new and has not delaminated at all.
I have used MDO to make "wreaths" that my daughter was selling. I found a local distributor that sells primarily to sign shops. Often they would have damaged sheets that they'd sell at a big discount. I was able to place my pattern to avoid the damaged area and make it part of the waste associated with irregular cut outs.
I've only used 3/4" MDO for a single indoor project that was meant for gloss black paint but my experience with that tells me that it takes paint fantastically well. In other cases I've used 'real' wood or veneer plywood for such tasks and there is always the problem of visible grain. Sometimes you want that and sometimes you don't. With MDO there is never any grain. The fact that there are never any voids in the sheet makes layout and construction easier but to me that was just an added bonus.