Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Sawstop product

Posts

Sawstop product

#1

Sawstop product

Robert Fuller

When this product was first marketed, I thought it was a great invention, and if I had the cashflow (and an ounce of brains) I would have purchased a new tablesaw.

However, I was confident that with the amount of time I spend woodworking and the number of years I have been at it, the cost far outweighed the benefit.

Then the company started lobbying congress (or so I heard) to have congress mandate that ALL saws sold in the US be equipped with their product. While I applaud the marketing team for thinking of this ploy, it rubbed me the wrong way. There are enough laws in this country telling us we cannot do this, that or the other thing, and this I felt was infringing on my right to risk. So I decided that I would NEVER buy a saw with Sawstop technology on it, at least until another company developed a similar product independently.

Then, on October 1, all that changed. In a brief 30 millisecond lapse of concentration, I got the pad of my left thumb where it should not be and cut it all the way down to the bone.

16 stitches, IV antibiotics, tetanus shot, and pain pills later and I am now mending again. However, this all had to happen when I was uninsured, having been laid off from my regular employment in February, the Cobra insurance only lasting 6 months, and the Open Enrollment period for health insurance does not start till Nov.1. I looked at many health plans, but failed to grasp the "special enrollment period" of 60 days following lapse of insurance.

So, for those of you who think you are charmed into not hurting yourself, I urge you to reconsider and "do as I say; not as I do" LOL. Go get a Sawstop ASAP.

Re: Sawstop product

#2

Re: Sawstop product

Ray Newman

Hope you heal quickly and without any "loss of use."

Early this year, I purchased a Saw Stop ICS. At age 70, my hands and reaction time are not what they once where. Additionally I am a bilateral above the knee amputee and do not need to loose and more appendages. After several years of procrastination, I sold the circa 1987 Uni-saw and purchased the ICS.

Not a fan of Dr. Gass’ marketing approach and some of the tactics employed by some sales people, but it is a very well-made product and for my use and situation, the safety feature is well worth it. Will be interesting to see how the Bosch/Saw Stop patent infringement law suit finally works out. Competition is good and leads to better products.

Again, hope you heal well.

Re: Sawstop product

#3

Re: Sawstop product

JAMES FOLLETTE

Robert, I also sliced my thumb with a portable table saw while helping in Mississippi after Katrina. One of the guys had some electricians tape so that and some paper towel held it together! The fingers and especially the thumb typically have good circulation so it never got infected and healed well except feeling in it was incomplete for a few years.

Regarding the SawStop...I got one about a year ago and continue to love it. One of my considerations was that although I hope to keep using it for some more years after that I hope one of my 2 sons or my daughter will take it over and I want him or her to be as safe as possible while sawing!

Re: Sawstop product

#4

Re: I'm not sold on it.

CharlieL

I also don't care for the politics of it, or where they are made. Also I believe that in a wood shop you have to respect the tools and machinery, and what they can do. Be fully aware of what your doing. It's no place to be in a hurry, or letting your mind drift. There are a lot more other things in a wood shop that can take a bite out of you.

Re: Sawstop product

#5

Re: Sawstop product

Dick Coers

All the preaching about staying attentive and respecting machinery is great until an accident happens. It's an accident, nobody can predict every reaction of a machine for a lifetime. They are great technology, I love the Sawstop. Sorry for your accident, I can relate. It's been over 30 years since I cut through a knuckle on my left ring finger. Luckily for me, it was back in the day when the corporation I worked for paid 100% of everything. Just a wink and a nod as you walked out of the hospital and all the bills were paid. Sure miss those days! My adult children look at me like I'm making up stories when I tell them how insurance used to be.

Re: Sawstop product

#6

Ellis Walentine

Sorry to hear, Robert

Ellis Walentine

In the twenty-odd years I've been hosting online forums, I've heard many versions of your story, some much worse than others. I'm glad to hear you didn't actually amputate the thumb. That would have been even more tragic. As for flesh-sensing technology, there's no doubt that it can save you a world of trouble when that lapse happens. Your story is a lesson to all of us who figure that since it hasn't happened to us yet, it never will. I hope you mend well and regain full use of that thumb.

Ellis

Re: Sawstop product

#7

Re: I'm sorry too

TomD

I'm sorry you were hurt, but the solution is not saw stop. Just never put your hand within the blood zone. I no longer pass any boards through the saw without flipping them. Ashley Iles ran a great column on working in the cutlery trade in Sheffield. He made wood turning and general woodworking tools. He said he never met a pattern maker with an injury to his hands, because they never did stupid stuff. Its a table saw. The US approach has been to keep and outdated design in production while equipping it with all kinds of expensive accessories, that largely don't work. The Euros redesigned their saws years ago. The US approach was to find a way to jig absolutely everything on the table saw, no mater how stupid the attempt. This is now obsolete because proper tools are so easily available that we don't need to push one behemoth into all the roles. Learn to use hand tools so you always have 90 options for doing something that doesn't involve feeding some tiny piece of shrapnel into a big saw.

I have been badly injured a few times. It happens, It doesn't surprise me like I never knew that was the bet I was making. A pal of mine bought a Triumph motorcycle (actually the same thing happened to a second friend) he rode it around, laid it down and hurt his hand, he recovered. But he said that was it for him and bikes. OK, that could be a rational response, but it sounded like he didn't know that was the game he was in. This stuff can do horrible things to you. As the OP said it can ruin your body or your finances. But it isn't like that is news. Google all your favorite tools if you are in any doubt, followed by the word "accident". It is horrifying. The tool in the shop that scares me (where I am alone), is the metal lathe. It can literally wrap you around the piece you are working on and the bed so you look like some kind of soft toffee blubber. Most people don't have one of those, but what even a medium drill press can do is horrifying, and grinders. Saw stop is not on all that stuff. For starters I am not doing it if I am tired, and I am not doing it if I think it is dangerous. Unless I need the excitement.

Re: Sawstop product

#8

Re: Sawstop product

Jim Dillon

Robert, first I hope your poor thumb heals and no further issues arise during the mending process. Secondly, thanks for posting and reminding us all that stuff sometimes happens despite our best efforts to work safely. The several "lapses" I have had occured when I was tired at the end of the day and wanted to get one-more-thing-done before quitting. Bad idea. The other occurred when I was trying to "show-off" my woodworking skills to a neighbor who gave me a small piece of plywood to cut. Trying to do it at record speed (to impress), the narrow piece of plywood twisted and I got to observe kick-back first-hand. My pride was really hurt. Fortunately, the neighbor didn't realize what a stupid thing I had done and thought my ensuing "fix" for the damaged plywood was just great. Little did she know. I sure learnt a lesson from that experience.

Regarding Sawstop. If I were shopping today, I would give it very serious consideration. After firing a nail right through my thumb, I found out that one visit to the emergency room would practically pay for a Sawstop.

Have fun with your new toy and, well, "work safely". Jim

Re: Sawstop product

#9

It can happen to anybody

Bill Howatt

Sorry about the mishap and I'm glad it isn't worse.

Your incident is another example of brain problems. Yes, the brain is a first line defence against accidents but brains are not known for being attentive 100% of the time. This is where the Sawstop can save the day when you do something, well, I'll say it, "dumb". Nobody sticks their hand into the blade on purpose, it happens when we do something dumb and if anybody out there thinks they will never do anything dumb they should make sure they have all of the medical insurance details down pat.

Financial issues due to lack of medical insurance are not trivial but they can be the least of the problems if the accident causes permanent serious damage.

Bill

Re: Sawstop product

#10

Just not the way you think it will

Mark Hennebury

I hope that your thumb heals well.

Many years ago i bought a new pair of safety shoes for wearing in my shop, the type with both a steel toe and an instep guard; i thought that it was the sensible thing to do seeing as i was always dragging heavy slabs of wood around the shop and would no doubt drop one on my foot sooner or later.

I had some 2" thick rough Maple that was wide, long and heavy stacked on the floor separated by 3/4" stickers which were longer than the wood width, so they stuck out a bit.

So the first week with my new shoes i grabbed a large and heavy maple board from the top of a stickered pile on the floor, wrestled it onto the floor, stood on its side and hoisted one end and started to drag it over to the the big jointer, it slipped out of my hands and fell toward the ground striking the overhanging end of a sticker which pivoted off of the board and launch straight into my forehead knocking me back and cutting my forehead, while i was bleeding my buddy was busting his ass laughing at me.

And therein lies one problem with sawstop, its not the only machine in the shop.

I am pretty sure that if i bought a sawstop i would stick my hand into the bandsaw/ radial arm saw /jointer/ shaper/ whatever, or like Tom said wrap myself around the lathe.

Re: Sawstop product

#11

Warped logic.

Mike Circo

That is like saying, don't bother with car airbags because a crane could still drop an I-beam on your roof.

You can't protect against every possible event, it is just beyond the realm of reality. But you can protect from the most common and catastrophic events and if equipment exists to improve the odds, it is not a bad thing.

(Not going to get into the politics of the Sawstop guy, just saying the technology is valuable for safety)

Re: Sawstop product

#12

Isn't most logic warped?

Mark Hennebury

Following a trail of connected steps to reach a conclusion is great, if you can be sure that you have analysed all of the variables; Miss a few and you can end up in the wrong place.

A case in point; There have been many studies of the increase in safety and traffic flow by removing traffic lights:



The original example is Drachten, a town in Holland of 50,000 people. It is home to exactly zero traffic lights. Even in areas of the town with a traffic volume of 22,000 cars per day, traffic lights have been replaced by roundabouts, extended cycle paths and improved pedestrian areas. The town saw accidents at one intersection fall from 36 over a four-year period to just two in the last two years since the lights were removed in 2006.



The counter-intuitive finding is that streets without traffic signals mean that cars drive more slowly and carefully because the rules of the road are ambiguous—there’s no red, green or yellow to tell drivers precisely what to do. A Wired article from 2004 quotes Hans Monderman, the late architect of Holland’s minimalist roads, who explains his approach of affecting driver behavior: “A wide road with a lot of signs is telling a story,” Monderman says. “It’s saying, go ahead, don’t worry, go as fast as you want, there’s no need to pay attention to your surroundings. And that’s a very dangerous message.”

That said, i wasn't making a case for not buying a Sawstop, or in anyway denigrating the technology. Sawstop type technology may indeed prevent a lot of injuries and may very well end up on all equipment, cant see anything wrong with that. I do however have a healthy skepticism around surrendering control to any safety device, mostly with concerns on how that affects my mindfulness.

i was in fact Just relaying a funny incident that happened to me and pointing out that life can get you in-spite of your best efforts.