Re: Weatherproofing a wooden cross
TomD
It would be possible to make something that looked like that relatively durable if epoxy was used, but it would never work with such heavy sections. One would need to go to some crazy extreme like building a form out of plywood, coating that all over in epoxy, even glassing parts of it, then veneering the surface say 1/2" thinck, sealing everything, maybe with glass, and then using a catalyzed varnish. Obviously not applicable in this case.
On Mahogany, Deck Olje might work, or Watco marine oil. Where they can be superior to varnish is they are not merely on the surface. I have some experience with Watco marine, but not as severe a situation as what you have going on there. Decks has been the rear cover of Wooden boat, or was, for decades.
http://www.jamestowndistributors.com/userportal/show_product.do?pid=168
http://forum.woodenboat.com/archive/index.php/t-124387.html
If I went with Decks, I would make a hat out of copper or vinyl something for the top, make it inconspicuous, but something to protect the end grain (even white latex paint). And I would soak marine epoxy into the endgrain of the arms. I would not put epoxy anywhere else (well maybe knots if there are any).