Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

Dust Collector Noise

Posts

Dust Collector Noise

#1

Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

I have a small shop in my basement where I have a dust collector that I want to reduce the noise level. I cannot move it outside. I have no room to build a closet.

Does anyone have any experience or knowledge on wrapping parts of the machine with foam? Do you think it would help?

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#2

Re: Dust Collector Noise

David Bair

Check to see if your dust collector maker offers a muffler.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#3

Re: Dust Collector Noise

CharlieL

How small is your shop ? Which dust collector do you have ? And what kind of noise ?

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#4

Re: Dust Collector Noise

John K Jordan

Is this a cyclone? Some on the ClearVue forum have reported some noise reduction by insulating certain parts of the machine. I don't remember the specifics.

Without room to build a closet I think I would try building some insulated panels that could be fastened around the unit and removed for access. Sort of a non-closet closet.

I use a 5hp Clearvue and it is deafening without some sound insulation. I was fortunate to have the space to design a 4x8' closet into my new shop to house it plus a big air compressor. It's amazing how quiet both of these are now.

JKJ

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#5

Any kind of photo would be a big help!!!!!

Dick Coers

There are a lot of different systems out there, just some kind of general information of what you have would make our help a lot easier!

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#6

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

Thanks for the feedback.

The dust collector is a Craftex C400 2-HP unit, sold by Busy Bee Tools in Canada. The unit is made in Taiwan. It is a bag type machine with a upper canister 1 micron filter.

I have not checked for a muffler, but being a canister filter, I doubt if there is one.

For a picture and description I have included a link to the machine on the Busy Bee website. It would not work in the "Optional Image URL" box. Sorry.

http://www.busybeetools.com/products/dust-collector-2hp-w-canister-csa-cx400.html

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#7

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Hank Knight

Allan,

I have no idea how small your shop is, or how it's laid out, but I would encourage you to be creative and rethink whether you have room for a sound insulating closet. My shop is tiny, 17' X 23', and it is pretty full. I bought a 5hp Clear Vue and, like John's, mine is a screamer - so loud I couldn't work with the noise. I tamed it with a small insulated enclosure that is barely larger than the machine's footprint. It's tucked in a corner behind my table saw; and, while it limits the cutting width of my saw a little, that price is more than worth the relative quiet the enclosure provides. My shop is in my basement, immediately below the family room. My wife has never complained about the noise. Here are a couple of photos.

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Clear%20Vue%20Cyclone%20Installation/DSC_1008Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

[URL=http://s50.photobucket.com/user/hankknight/media/Workshop/Picture009Medium.jpg.html][/URL]

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#8

Re: Dust Collector Noise

CharlieL

I look at it this way, where would a guy stop ? Most machinery in a shop is loud. I just use hearing protection, and if your worried about the sound spreading in the house, insulate the walls and ceiling in the whole shop, and sheetrock.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#9

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Dick Coers

Thanks for the picture. If you don't have room for a large box, and for easier service, I would split the seam on the duct to the bag and filter. Then build an insulated box for just the motor and blower. Have you looked at the Thien baffle? I put one in my Jet version like that and it has greatly increased the cleanliness in the top canister and made it a new machine!

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#10

Baffled

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Took the tip and bought the $10 wok at IKEA. Installed with a strip of 16ga. Lot less to shake down from the bag.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#11

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

Thanks, Dick. I'll take a look at building a baffled box around the motor and fan enclosure. That would not take up as much room as a closet.

Yes I have looked extensively at the Thein baffle before I bought this machine. It looks like a good add-on. A buddy of mine has built one and it works well on his small Shop Vac system.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#12

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

Thanks everyone for you help.

Has anyone ever tried wrapping parts of the metal housings with polyurethane foam?

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#13

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

Thanks, Hank. I will look at building a closet if that ends up being the only way to reduce the noise. I would like to not have to use ear plugs as CharlieL suggested.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#15

Re: What's the heat build up like, Hank?

Barry Irby

Derek raises a good point, what about the heat? I have a similar Delta unit and I was lucky enough to be able to add a small closet on the exterior of my shop for the air compressor and DC. A huge benefit. Two large noisy things outside the shop. More space in the shop and a LOT less noise. AND the micro dust is outside, not recirculated.

I would be hesitant to wrap up the motor. I think the blower and the rest of it would not suffer, but the motor will overheat. I tend to turn mine off and on frequently as I move from tool to tool, but have been known to leave it running for hours on some big projects.

Can you investigate exactly where the noise comes from? I think the motor makes a lot less noise that the blower. Where does the noise come out? You can put the lower bag into a trash can. I have mine in a 30 gallon can to make it easier to handle, but it may also reduce noise a little. If it helps you could wrap the can with foam, or line it. You could make some sort of canister to cover the upper canister. Make it bigger, big enough to allow the air to escape freely, but if its padded it may absorb some noise. Or you could wrap the upper canister with a couple of inches of open foam that lets the air pass through and see if that abates the noise and fits under the handle.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#16

Re: Heat Build Up

Hank Knight

Hi, Derek and Barry,

I worried about the heat issue a lot, so I designed my enclosure to combat it. All of the air the cyclone sucks in has to escape somewhere. I don't have a he luxury of being able to vent it outside, so I built sound-baffled vents around the top of the enclosure where it meets the ceiling. My thought was to prevent the heat from the motor from pooling in the top of the closet. The continuous flow of air escaping back into my shop through the vents carries the heat with it. Apparently it works. I've had no problem with heat build-up. The motor runs cool, even for long periods in operation.

Hank

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#17

Re: Dust Collector Noise

CharlieL

I'd be a little leary of boxing in the motor. It would just trap the heat of the motor inside the box and shorten the life of the motor.

Re: Dust Collector Noise

#18

Re: Dust Collector Noise

Allan Cusworth

Thanks a lot for all the experienced information and opinions. I have a lot to review.

Thanks again.