Re: OT Furnace and A/C
Jim Dillon
Mike, I can only reinforce the excellent advice you've gotten. Twelve years ago we had a complete install done on our cabin. After much research, the "wisdom" seemed to be: 1) pick a good installer (do reference checks); 2) all of the major brands are good; 3) have a heating/cooling load calculation done (to correctly size the heat pump) by the installer; and 4) pick a heat pump from the middle of the pack as it is often the best value. Twelve years later I still think these are good guidelines.
Unlike my scenario, you are considering a "simple" switch-out. Yet you have described a LOT of great insulation improvements you have made since your original heat pump was sized and installed. I would guess that you could get by with a smaller capacity unit in a mid-range SEER. And as Berry implied, bigger is not necessarily better regarding heat pumps as far as efficiency goes. While it seems counter intuitive, IIRC a nearly constantly running heat pump at extreme temperatures may actually be operating more efficiently versus a pump running only once in a while.
If you are comfortable with the installer that is offering a good deal/financing on a name brand unit, I would go with that.
One more thing. My installer recommended a basic programmable thermostat. While very, very fancy (and much more expensive) models are available, once the excitement wears off, one only needs just a few basic settings. Oh yes, I went with a Trane SEER 14 heat pump, but it is huge in size. Have had no major problems (knock-on-wood) except for some mice chewing through a big capacitor. Hope this helps. Jim