Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

OT Furnace and A/C

Posts

OT Furnace and A/C

#1

OT Furnace and A/C

Dustmaker Mike

Howdy All

I have been running around the US for the past few months and have not really done any WW. I do have a question about getting a new gas furnace and A/C unit. Mine is a 1994 model and will need to be replaced this year or next. Depending on cost. I would like to hear the good or bad about Lennox Rudd and Carrier or any other ones I should look at. I would like to have it replaced before the old one bites the dust.

I am leaning for the Lennox because of a financing deal they going on right now.

Thanks

Mike

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#2

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Nat Robison

I have a Carrier AC unit that was installed in 1998. It's maybe needed $200 in repairs to date. Also have a Carrier Furnace installed in 2003 and haven't done a thing to it except change the filters. Both installed by the same company.

In my opinion, if the company is skilled and the unit(s) are sized appropriately for the space, that's half the battle.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#3

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Joseph Mulherin

Second what Nat said. If the financial is good and the product has a good background for reliability

just go with them.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#4

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

When we replaced our pair (2-zone heat & AC) I went with Trane to replace the original Rudd units. 10 years on with $0 repairs other than a flame sensor that was covered under warranty.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#5

Carrier for us

Dick Coers

We had a Carrier Performance Series furnace and AC put in June 2014. The furnace is rated at 97% efficiency and a 16 SEER AC. Very happy with it. We got a $600 rebate from the utility company on the AC, cost us just under $5600 installed. The AC unit has to be physically half again bigger than the one they took out. Huge heat exchanger and a big slow speed fan to get the high rating. Furnace is close to being 1/2 the size. Outside air comes in PVC pipe, exhaust goes out another PVC pipe. Damned furnace sounds like a blast furnace when you take off the sealed front panel.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#6

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Brian Holcombe

I did this a month ago, I also went with Trane and had it installed by a trusted installer. They had the units changed in about 6 hours.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#7

What the service guys told me

Henry Higginbotham

I had to have a coolant charge around the first of the summer. After the bad news of $55/lb Freon (and they expected near $100 by early next summer), they told me that none of the new units today are reliable and that two years was all I might get from one. But then, I've been using these guys for years and I know they like to bitch about stuff. As in, they could probably have their own YouTube channel, bitching about stuff. So who knows--anyone else heard these dire predictions?

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#8

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Joseph Mulherin

Save the blower and make a room filter to catch the small items in the upper air of your shop.

They have several listed on YouTube.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#9

We got ours 28 months ago

Dick Coers

Our furnace and ac comes with a 10 year parts and labor warranty, and 10 years on the compressor. Hard to image they design it to fail in two years, then put a 10 year warranty on it. This is the third furnace in our house in 39 years, none of the furnaces failed, but two of the AC units failed.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#10

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Barry Irby

As a Home Inspector I see anything that is out there. I can't make a clear distinction between any of the units. It maybe that I am not paying attention to what I don't see as in really old brand X. Many of the units now come with multiple name badges in the box and you can put which ever one you like on your unit. American Standard owns Trane. Carrier owns Bryant, Day Night, and Payne. At least, I think thats correct.

I am skeptical of extremely high performance units. The guys I have seen in the field seem very poorly qualified to install and service them. And the new AC units are huge compared to the older ones to get the surface area they need to get the performance. This may create a problem when they install the outdoor unit. You may have to remove shrubs and move other things.

Newer equipment is "by law" more efficient that the older stuff. Personally, what I would do is buy good solid middle of the road reliable equipment as opposed to the high end stuff and take the savings and apply it to energy conservation. Have an energy audit done and use the money to knock out the top two or three items. Cut air leakage, improve the ceiling insulation, and maybe the windows. You are a handy guy or you would not be here on Wood Central, if you are patient, you can do a lot of the work yourself. I can give you a list of things that take effort and cost very little in materials. Caulking is an example. We have seen cases where the size of the equipment can be reduced by a third and that saves you money on the "buy" as well as the operation.

Its unfortunate that the HVAC companies sell the equipment "by the ton". they have no incentive to send you to the people that could cut your energy use.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#11

Thanks

Dustmaker Mike

I was looking to replace my furnace before it dies. I have repaired it twice now in the last few years and I think the fire box is on it's last legs.

The dealer I am thinking of using is running a special right now 4 years interest free. Along with a humidifier and dehumidifier for free. I know nothing is free.

Thanks Barry for the offer.

Over the last few years I have replaced all the doors windows and siding with Pella triple pain units. I used foam insulated siding. I had a new roof put on along with roof vents. The attic is 12 in of battered and I am not sure of how deep the blown in insulation. My heating bill dropped big time when I was done.

I plan on selling the house when I get ready to retire in about 5 to 8 years, so I am not going after top of the line the middle of the road is about all I need.

Thanks Again

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#12

Re: Thanks

Barry Irby

An after thought.....you did a good job of reducing the energy use as evidenced by your reduced bills. Now your equipment is too big. Its important the stuff be correctly sized. For reasons its sort of hard to explain, having equipment significantly over sized makes it cost more to operate. I can explain it if you want the lecture, but I am suggesting you have an audit done or make sure the contractor carefully recalculates the demand on the equipment and size it accordingly. If you have some of your old bills and some of the new ones it might be helpful.

I am an old Fuddy Duddy, but the new fangled stuff bothers me. On my system I let them talk me into a unit with a variable speed fan. Bumped the SEER rating up by 1 from 13 to 14. Seemed reasonable. The fan crapped out in less than a year. Took them six weeks to get a replacement. In the mean time they put a standard one in and wired it directly to my panel and let it run full time for the whole time. They also left the variable speed one sitting in the floor hooked up with jumpers to trick the computer into thinking it was still running.

In your case I would buy good solid stuff and sell it with the house. Lennox, Carrier, or Trane should be fine.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#13

All this Luddite attitude towards HVAC

Dick Coers

All this technology fear on HVAC makes me wonder if you guys drive 60s cars and trucks? And what are you doing on a computer, discussing your dislike of computer controlled HVAC?

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#14

Re: All this Luddite attitude towards HVAC

Barry Irby

What are you going to do when your car wants to drive itself, maybe without you even in it, or with you in it and it thinks its a submarine?

I put an extremely efficient ductless system in one of my rentals. It failed. Apparently they don't take kindly to being stuffed full of weed.

I just don't want to be the first kid on my block to do the Beta Testing on these new systems. Work out the bugs on somebody else.

OTOH, I built a house thirty seven years ago that was so energy efficient I had to sign saying the HVAC equipment was big enough and if it was not I would pay to replace it. All very low tech.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#15

Re: All this Luddite attitude towards HVAC

Dustmaker Mike

I am not afraid of technology I am in the middle of it as an instructor for a major medical company. I do have a 1968 Mustang I drive and it really is easy to fix. I also have a 2014 Jeep Wrangler that was tossing check engine codes and the dealer took almost two years to figure it out. I have a code reader and every time it tossed the code I would read it. Every time it was the same code. They replaced just about every computer box in the Jeep before they figured it out. Just saying sometime the simpler things are easier to fix. I really do hate Windows but that is what pays my bills, so I work with it.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#16

Re: A matter of time

Stuart Johnson


Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#17

Quality of installation

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Most modern day heat pumps are charge critical to within a half ounce of refrigerant. In an attempt to make it right the manufacturers use pre-charged line sets. Equipped with oversized flare nuts and pierceable membranes, the line sets are drug under your house by a non-caring kid. The connections get dirty and insure a leak in about a year or two. How do you win? KNOW YOUR INSTALLER!

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#18

You're suggesting Chrysler/Jeep known for quality?

Dick Coers

Wife drives a 2009 Civic, never thrown a code. I drive a 2012 Fit, never thrown a code. I'd suggest that buying a Chrysler/Jeep product has more to do with that computer issue than the technology itself. I'd also suggest that getting 40 mpg in our two cars is the perfect reason not to drive a 1968 with a stuck choke. At 4,000 miles, the oil in our cars is still amber colored. Today is the golden age of the automobile. 750hp cars that get 25-30mpg on the highway, and corner like a go- cart, is another fine testament to hi tech success. Just my opinions of course! I love the technology, and have no interest in being able to fix a simple gas hog furnace or car these days.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#19

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

David Bair

Carrier moved all manufacturing to Mexico this spring. Their corporate offices remain in the USA. I don't know if Lennox manufactures in the US.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#20

Re: You're suggesting Chrysler/Jeep known for qual

Dustmaker Mike

Yup I agree I own a 2013 Shelby that gets 22MPG and is 662 HP. I can tune it with a computer program to give it more HP. I can do 60 in first gear 100 in second and 140 in third fourth scares me so I have not found the top of that. Here I am doing 100MPH at MI NASCAR speedway. The FCA I agree with that commit my wife wanted it so she got it. As for 40MPG I like my trucks. If I get 20 or so MPG I am good with it.


img

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#21

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Jim Dillon

Mike, I can only reinforce the excellent advice you've gotten. Twelve years ago we had a complete install done on our cabin. After much research, the "wisdom" seemed to be: 1) pick a good installer (do reference checks); 2) all of the major brands are good; 3) have a heating/cooling load calculation done (to correctly size the heat pump) by the installer; and 4) pick a heat pump from the middle of the pack as it is often the best value. Twelve years later I still think these are good guidelines.

Unlike my scenario, you are considering a "simple" switch-out. Yet you have described a LOT of great insulation improvements you have made since your original heat pump was sized and installed. I would guess that you could get by with a smaller capacity unit in a mid-range SEER. And as Berry implied, bigger is not necessarily better regarding heat pumps as far as efficiency goes. While it seems counter intuitive, IIRC a nearly constantly running heat pump at extreme temperatures may actually be operating more efficiently versus a pump running only once in a while.

If you are comfortable with the installer that is offering a good deal/financing on a name brand unit, I would go with that.

One more thing. My installer recommended a basic programmable thermostat. While very, very fancy (and much more expensive) models are available, once the excitement wears off, one only needs just a few basic settings. Oh yes, I went with a Trane SEER 14 heat pump, but it is huge in size. Have had no major problems (knock-on-wood) except for some mice chewing through a big capacitor. Hope this helps. Jim

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#22

Manufacturing these days

Dick Coers

Manufacturing these days usually means where the steel case is made, and where all the components from all over the world meet the case and get installed.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#23

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Barry Irby

Apparently the manufacturers are pushing the limits, I have a number of rental units and have had three start capacitors fail in the last year. I also had a relay that got roaches in it and caused it to fail. Caused poor contact and burned up the relay. Having ten systems to tend to may make me ten times more sensitive.

I agree about the thermostats. On Home Inspections I have seen hundreds of thermostats and many of them were programmable. The vast majority were programed to "hold 72" or whatever. I have discussed with many of the people and they tell me they programmed it several times, but tired of redoing it after every power flicker and just quit.

Another thing I see is people setting the thermostat to 70 or 72 summer and winter. IMO it should be something like 68 or less in winter and 75 or 78 in summer. Very costly to try to maintain 70 in summer.

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#24

Re: Quality of installation

Paul Cates - Henderson, KY

I had a new heat pump installed last year only to have it leak 16 mos. later. After the leak repair, I discovered that the heat pump was nearly 5 y.o. when installed. It was new, but I found some evidence that appears to point to the unit being registered in TX in 2012. I'm also getting conflicting opinions as to whether that age of a new unit is normal. BTW, leaks are not covered under the mfrs. 10 yr. warranty so a bad solder joint cost me $715. My original installer has still not provided me with proof of warranty registration. I have contacted the mfr. but I'm still waiting. So I'm with Bill, know your installer!

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

#25

Re: OT Furnace and A/C

Dustmaker Mike

I have a programmable T-stat. It is one of the best add on's I did to my security system. I can program mine from my computer or cell phone from anywhere in the world. I have it set to send me an alert if the temp in the house goes below 40 or above 100. When no one is home during the day it automatically drops the temp in the winter or ups the temp in the summer. If we happen to be home that day we just go to our phone and select it to run the Saturday program. It keeps track of fan hours run times etc as well as inside and out side temps.

Nexia is what I use to monitor things. It is Z-wave band so it does not interfere with your normal computer wireless. They have all kids of neat devices you can add on to it. I can even open or close my garage door from any place in the world.