Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Bed Rail question?

Posts

Bed Rail question?

#1

Bed Rail question?

Barry Irby

I am about to go back to work on the beds I was making for my grand daughters. They are cherry and fairly plain, sort of shaker moon beds.

I am agonizing over the rails. I don't have any thicker stock. what I have will dress to something between 3/4" and 7/8". Would a 3/4" by 7" piece be acceptable structurally for a bed rail on a queen sized bed? I was thinking of gluing a 2" strip on the backside to make a ledge for the bed slats. That might add some strength.

I have plenty of oak that I could use for thicker rails. Would you find it acceptable to have oak rails on a cherry bed? Would that be better?

Re: Bed Rail question?

#2

Re: Bed Rail question?

Mike Circo

First the easy part. Oak and Cherry..... No, too much clash of grains.

I did a cherry queen bed, I used 1¼" rails. They seem just about right. 3/4, in my opinion would have too much flex and not look right either.

If you go through all the effort of making the bed, (Not an easy project), I'd go the extra yard to get the right sized rails. They take a lot of lateral stresses, hold up the mattress and occupants, and tie the whole bed together. A pretty critical component.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#3

Re: Bed Rail question?

Hank Knight

Barry, we have an antique cherry cannonball double bed. The rails look to be 1" thick. They have a 2" strip glued and screwed to the bottom to provide a ledger for the slats, and both ends are laminated double thickness for about 10" to provide a thick shoulder against the bed posts. They have held up well for many years.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#4

Re: Bed Rail question?

paul in AZ

My queen size bed is walnut with nominal 1" [3/4ish] x 7" rails. I built that 15 or more years ago and it has held up fine with no bowing.

Cherry with oak rail mix sounds hokey to me unless you want to glue an oak strip onto the inside of cherry rails where nobody sees it as a support for the mattress frame or slats.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#5

Re: Bed Rail question?

Dick Coers

Incredibly difficult to deflect 7" of hardwood fixed vertically. But let it bend in the length first and you have an issue. The cleat for the bed boards will prevent the side flex, you'll be fine.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#6

Re: Bed Rail question?

John McGaw

I would not mix cherry and visible oak however screwing a strip of oak maybe 1-1/2" wide inside the cherry (I wouldn't use glue for this because of the different materials) to form a ledge for the slats or platform would be good with me. My cherry queen bed has rails that are 6" X 1-1/2" so they are plenty strong. They have a strip of poplar near the bottom to form a lip for the foundation. I found that the combination of tall foundation and tall mattress was untenable so I dumped the foundation, added a strip of poplar 7/8" below the top edge to support a 7/8" plywood platform made up of of three pieces with crosswise cleats to prevent sagging.

My only real concern I'd have with thinnish rails would be the attachment method -- little material leaves little room for error or slightly weak wood. Do you have enough cherry stock to glue on doublers at each end of both rails? Six inches would give you plenty of room to work with for the attachments.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#7

Re: Bed Rail question?

Barry Irby

That's my plan. The cherry I am working with was cut off the family farm and it's not the best. Its tree run and not sorted or graded. And I am using the crappy part. Hopefully the better stuff is buried under the bottom of the pile. I just planed some of it and got enough to make the bed rails. I will glue a strip along the bottom edge and a block at the end.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#8

Keep the grain the same on the end block

Dick Coers

Don't glue a long grain board to the end, keep it oriented just like the rail. I'm sure you planned that, but just saying it's good practice.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#9

Re: Bed Rail question?

Jim Dillon

Barry, I also have started to build a queen size Greene and Greene style bed and broke down most of the stock to rough size just today. My side rails are 1-1/4 inch thick by 6-3/4. Nothing sacred about those sizes, but 3/4 inch stock alone without reinforcement (i.e. cleats, doubling the ends) would be pushing it I would think. Plus, if you are using hardware to allow easy removal of the rails, it wouldn't give you much leeway. All the beds in Jeff Millers book use 1 inch thick stock for the rails plus a 1 x 1-1/2 inch cleat to support the mattress.

Based on the thickness of my rough wood, I may have to cheat a bit on the other parts of the bed, but I wanted to get as close to 1-1/4 thickness on the rails as they are very important structurally. I'll probably end up with some mill marks remaining, but think I can hide those to the inside. Gotta work with what I have.

Personally, I would not mix cherry and oak. but that is just my taste.

As an aside, I purchased one of those online mattresses that is vacuum packed. Pretty amazing to watch it unfold and expand to 10 inches thick. Jim

Re: Bed Rail question?

#10

What size do you make the "interior"....

Barry Irby

of the frame? I'm thinking 82" by 61". With these thick mattresses, does it have to be right on top or can it be down in the frame?

I have nixed the oak. Too much of a contrast.

Rummaged through the cherry and found some that I can get 7/8". Like you, it may be skip planed on the inside, but it will work. Still going to beef up the ends and as Dick suggests, yes I am going to keep the grain lined up. Never occurred to me to make a cross grain situation.

It is amazing to un box a mattress these days. Have done a queen and a king. The queen is 14" thick. Wonder if they ever have any of those "explode" in shipment?

Re: Bed Rail question?

#11

Barrel bolts

Barry Irby

I used some giant bed bolts on the last one I made. Made them myself out of 3/4" rod. I'm not a machinist, but I got it done. Those were captive and could not get lost. Even the bolts were captive in the rails. The idea was there was nothing to lose except the wrench and that was an ordinary open end wrench and there was a little fitted pocket for that with magnets to hold it in place. I am hoping these beds will be around a long time and I want to make it possible for any future generation to assemble them.

That was very complex to make and install in the bed. Trying for "simpler" this time.

Re: Bed Rail question?

#12

Re: What size do you make the "interior"....

Jim Dillon

Good morning Barry,

"...of the frame? I'm thinking 82" by 61". With these thick mattresses, does it have to be right on top or can it be down in the frame?"

My "plan" calls for 81" x 61". I measured my new mattress and it is 80" x 60" x 10" thick. If your mattress is the same length and width as mine, I don't see why 82 inches wouldn't work and will give you more room to tuck in covers, blankets etc. In fact, I think I left enough wood in my side rails to do 82 inches and may end up doing that.

If things go according to plan, my 10 inch thick mattress (no box spring) will fit down into the frame about 4-1/4 inches resting on top of a 1" x 1-3/4 inch cleat plus 3/4-inch thick mattress support boards. I think putting the mattress inside the frame makes for a neater appearance. I measured the floor to top of my old mattress and it was about 20 inches. That seemed good as my feet were resting flat on the floor, but I have long legs. I guess I will make adjustments as I go along as I don't want to have my legs resting right on the frame when I sit on the edge of the bed. Placement of the side rail on the leg will also allow me some leeway in overall height of the mattress. Hope this helps. Jim

Yeah, I wondered the same thing regarding "exploding mattresses". I remember getting four sheets of 4 x 8 laminate wrapped in a circle so tight that I did indeed step back as I cut the packing straps.