Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Off the wall walnut staining question.....

Posts

Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#1

Off the wall walnut staining question.....

Barry Irby

We often discuss how vivid air dried walnut is. How it has purple and other colors in it that are not present in kiln died walnut and fade away in the air dried stuff. Has anyone tried dying or staining walnut with purple stain to retain or enhance the color and keep it? I thinking subtle here not garish.

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#2

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

William Duffield

They don't call it "brown furniture" for nothing. :D

What makes the air dried walnut color so pleasing is the color variation between browns, black and purples. Staining or dying can't enhance that variation. Over time, the more interesting colors fade. Dye also fades slowly. You can changed the overall color tone, with pigment stains or dyes, but you cannot prevent the loss of color contrast. It will all eventually end up the same color brown all over. Choice of pigments can modify what that final color is, but can't retain the variations.

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#3

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

Dick Coers

Binh Pho was one of the first to air brush red dye over the natural red staining in box elder so the color life is extended. I see no reason not to try that on walnut.

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#4

ebd

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

ebd

I disagree. That has not been my experience. Walnut that has been steamed - yes. The contrast is already dead. Naturally dried has not, for me, evened out. Especially not the crazy grain with chatoyance. The only time walnut has evened out for me was when it was exposed to strong sunlight over a long period of time. Won't make that mistake again.

I have a board that I'm just now working with that I have had for about 45 years. I has been sitting in my workshop (barn heated only when I'm working there) for about 36 years. Previously it was in heated apartments. It looks exactly the same as when I bought it.

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#5

doesn't match my experience

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have handled thousands of bd ft of walnut over the years- fresh sawed, steamed and KD, just KD and air dried. It all changes color when exposed to even subdued light and air and eventually it all reaches the same color.

When selling out of a stack of dead packed lumber the when the lumber is pulled for sale exposed ends of boards are invariably a different shade than the interior surfaces dead packed and in the dark .

The change in color is only skin deep. Planing the lumber reveals original color, which then changes when it is exposed to light, even indoor fluorescent lighting like we had in the lumber storage area. In our TN summer sun lumber will change color just sitting a short time in the sun waiting to be loaded for delivery. The green in poplar turns brown, the purple in walnut goes brown, the white in maple and ash go beige, the red in red oak goes brown, etc.

It always amused me when a customer complained that they "didn't want any of that green poplar". Not to fear, it won't be for long.

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#6

Re: gruesome pic - warning

TomD

The colours do change, the question is what can one do about it. There are ways of accelerating oxidation, are there ways of retarding it indefinitely, and the light bit.

I can think of two non-solutions that are used in other arts. One is the guy who infuses bodies so they can be sliced like bacon and has all those shows in museums around the world. It is more technique than art, I think, but people take the displays seriously. One could infuse wood with something but whether it could freeze colour is another mater.


The other is what is done when mounting fish, today you keep a picture of the fish, and send it to your guy, he pulls out a fiberglass mold, and then paints the mold to look exactly like the living fish. Essentially if you mount the actual fish it is painted anyway since fish when they die, like humans, fade in a reverse blush. If I was interested in art furniture, I would make a base that displayed a separate top piece, like a trestle table, and make the top plank out of fiberglass to look exactly like a piece of wood while it was still fresh. The piece would ask the question which is the real wood. Which is a question I have occasionally asked myself when sitting at a table with photoreal veneer on it.


Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#7

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

Tony - Memphis

i haven't worked with much walnut. One big project - a low boy. I ended up using Van Dyke crystals to even things out. Still looks good - no direct sunlight. It came out a little too dark for my taste though. Might lighten up about the time they plant me!

Anyway, I used a small piece of figured walnut that i bought as a "box-o-shoirts" to make a little plaque to cover a hole in my console (long story). I just installed it last weekend. Yesterday, I was in a parking lot when the sun was just right and it lit that tiny piece of walnut up! It looked like it was a foot deep and had layers of figure. I was amazed! Never looked like that in the shop! I'll be interested to see what happens to the wood over time. I have no idea how it was dried, no stain, just Minwax wipe on and wax. Not sure a pic wopuld capture what I describe, but I might try next time the sun lights it up.

Tony

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#8

ebd

Re: doesn't match my experience

ebd

Yeah the purple changes to brown over time. It also disappears as soon as you apply oil. It is the contrtast in the grain, the ripples and depth that I find remain. I do not find that I end up with an evenly brown board - ever. Here's a (poor) picture of the top of a shop stool I made from scrap over 40 years ago. It still has every bit of the detail in the grain that it had when first made.


Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

#9

Re: Off the wall walnut staining question.....

Michael Dresdner

Funny you should mention that. One of the things I teach in finishing classes is how to make steamed or bland walnut sparkle. We were talking about it the other day and my editor asked me to do an article on just that. It is planned for the Jan Feb issue of Woodworker's Journal.