I applied two coats of Watco Danish Oil to a cherry dulcimer today. The dulcimer was sanded to 320, first coat of oil applied, rubbed off after 30 minutes, lightly scuff sanded with 320 again, second oil coat applied, rubbed off after 20 minutes, then lightly rubbed with a gray mesh pad to really smooth the surface.
Ideally, I would like to get a bit of luster (not gloss) on the dulcimer. It is not terrible right now, but, never having used Watco Danish Oil as the only finish, I am not sure if aging and buffing, with or without, additional coats, will accomplish this. Will thin coats applied over a period of time produce the luster I am looking for, or should I bail out and use a very light rubbed-in coat of poly after the oil has cured? (I am in no hurry...the final finish is the goal, not speed.)
I sometimes use "danish" oil on woodturnings. Typically, I soak in as much as the wood will take at first. Wipe off any excess then let that dry, maybe a few days to a week. Then apply another coat and wipe off after a few minutes. Let dry, and repeat. It will slowly build up a tough layer on the surface over several weeks or a month.
If we want a gloss, buffing with polishing compound works well. For a non-gloss luster, rubbing with 0000 steel wool and/or fine abrasive scotchbright pads can look good.
You might also ask this on the woodturning forum since some people use Watco a lot on turnings and may have a better ideas about how to get the luster look.
You didn't put WATCO on the fret board did you? If so, I'd strip it off with lacquer thinner of something like that. Oil on the fret board will make a gooey mess because of hand oils under heavy use. It will slow the play if the player uses a finger to do the fretting. If they use a stick, not so much of an issue. I'm not a poly user on dulcimers, looks to much like plastic. I use a few thin coats of pre catalyzed lacquer. My wife does a lot of outdoor gigs at historical events, and the oil would never work out in the dampness encountered under a canopy during a rain. I've built 3 for my wife.
I agree on the buffing advice, but the key thing is to give it some time to dry thoroughly. You aren't buffing as with something soft like wax, you are buffing the hardened oil. How long it takes to harden is quite variable. Watco finishing is basically the same as Trueoil, for which there are a million threads.
Apply more finish to get a build and then sand and or buff it to whatever gloss you want. I find 4/0 steel wool followed by a good floor wax gives a nice sheen that is inbetween satin and gloss.
I think you are getting more woodworking advice than musical instrument advice. Waxing a dulcimer will make playing it a chasing game on your lap. ABSOLUTELY DO NOT WAX THE BACK! My wife wears a strap from the fret board head, around her waist, and to the tail end of the dulcimer to keep it in position. She tried using what was basically a router anti slip pad for a while, but likes the strap much better. All that for an unwaxed instrument. Waxing the back would make it a horrible instrument to play! Waxing the fret board would exacerbate the finger oil darkening and drag over time. For better advice, I suggest you find a luthier forum.
Did you use Sitka Spruce or Western Red Cedar for the sound board? I'd think WATCO would change the tonal quality of those woods. I'd also think the oil would just about soak all the way through those quarter sawn woods and possibly even make the inside of the dulcimer stink for a long time. I've always used Sitka Spruce.
Did you ever build one from sassafras? I notice a thin sassafras board has a nice "ring" to it when tapped making me imagine it might have good properties for an instrument. I've turned some music boxes from sassafras.
Hey, you have any dulcimer plans to share or suggestions where I could get some? A dulcimer maker in Berea Ky (Warren May) once said he would help me with a design and traditional measurements but I don't get up that way much.
BTW, I bought the Psimple Psaltry book and hope to build one of those by Christmas. This year.
The walnut one was from a kit, the other two from scratch. I bought the two fret boards so I didn't have to fuss with fret spacing. All have Sitka Spruce tops. The birds eye has the sharpest sound, wife's least favorite. The two I made from scratch have Warren May's design, but likely not an exact copy since I laid out the lines myself. Half tear drop, half hour glass. We've visited with him several times as we passed through to Florida when visiting family. I used the kit dulcimer as the pattern for these two, so no real patterns.
All parts of the dulcimer are cherry. It was from a Folkcraft kit...not the prettiest cherry grain ever, but, being cherry, it is still pretty nice. I plan to put it in a sunny window and wait for the "real" cherry to come to life.
No one really knows the proportions of varnish, boiled linseed oil (BLO), and thinner in Watco Danish Oil. I think the manufacturer's instructions are to thoroughly saturate the wood once, then let dry.
Oil-varnish blends, which many woodworkers mix, often is equal parts of varnish, BLO, and mineral spirits. BLO warms up the wood, varnish provides more durability, mineral oil makes it thin, easy to apply. Seems like once I saw a suggestion the mix could be as extreme as 1/9 BLO, 4/9 varnish and 4/9 mineral spirits to make a harder finish.
When I used equal thirds oil-varnish blend on bowls, 5-6 coats never got beyond satin in my mind.
Second the suggestion to see what full time dulcimer makers use for a finish.