Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

Posts

Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#1

Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

GWilcox

I recently picked up a sizable chunk of wood (16" X 19" X 3") and am planning on throwing legs on it and using it as a butcher block. I stained it for an entire week with Walnut oil. It looks beautiful but it dries very quickly and doesn't seem to be becoming water repellent. I understand the pores may not be full yet so am going to continue treating but was thinking about switching to Mineral oil for the remainder. Does anyone know if this is a bad idea or have any advice?

Thanks!

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#3

keep the faith

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Walnut oil has the ability to eventually polymerize into at least a hard gel which will stay in the wood. Mineral oil stays mineral oil.....oily forever, and in my experience washes out readily in use. Keep slathering on the walnut oil and eventually you will achieve a satisfactory result. Of if you are cheap switch to corn oil, Canola, Soybean, etc. But this suggestion usually sets off a torrent of objection, largely unfounded by chemistry.

Made Chilli today. Lots of chopping of ingredients involved. The cutting board looked a bit dry after washing off the meat remains so I dried it and slathered on some of whatever oil the wife uses now days, maybe Canola. This is my usual approach. Also made bread that has a lot of butter in it. Be assured that some of that oil got into the bread making board during kneading and benching the loaves. Can't fret about adding vegie oil if you don't fret about bread making.

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#4

Don't do it

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Mineral oil is not remotely similar to walnut oil. The mineral oil will keep the walnut oil from curing into a more or less hard gel in the wood. A sticky goo will be the result of mixing.

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#5

Re: keep the faith

TomD

You say it is drying quickly which is good. But in any case check if it has Vitamin E added or otherwise is modified for health. This can be an antioxidant that will stop it hardening off. It should harden a lot more than a gel.

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#6

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

Barry Irby

I made a bunch of end grain cutting boards out of walnut scraps. Coated them repeatedly with either sunflower or safflower oil (can't remember which, but it was like Bill said, whatever was in the kitchen and tasteless). The oil literally ran all the way through the boards. May have been better to use walnut oil and let it harden in the pores. Keep using the walnut oil and eventually let it cure thoroughly. Then switch to veggie oil.

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#7

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

don stephan

Are you using (raw) walnut oil sold in the grocery store or (processed) walnut oil sold in woodworking/woodturning stores, catalogs, and web sites?

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#8

Vegie oil drying

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Most of the vegie oils have sufficient reactive sites on the molecule to cure to a more or less hard film, eventually. The "drying oils" like linseed and walnut cure to a hard rubbery film. Others like corn and Canola cure, eventually, to a gel. But for a cutting board a gel is as good as a rubbery film. All that is desired is that the oil not bleed or wash out over time and in this regard a gel is effective at keeping the oil in the wood.

Re: Walnut Oil switch to Mineral Oil

#9

Some advice.......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....that may not be good advice. I made an end grain board of cherry. It was so porous that I could not keep the surface oiled. It drank oil to such an extent that I thought I would eventually weaken the glue joints. In exasperation I put a coat of thin varnish on it to seal it. Then I sanded it and oiled it and it seemed to be sealed. I gave it away so I don't know if the fix worked long term or not.

Or, this has work in the past. If it is end grain, belt sand it down to about 120 grit finishing up with a belt that isn't particularly sharp. The burnish will seal the end grain.