Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Appearance in edge gluing panels

Posts

Appearance in edge gluing panels

#1

Appearance in edge gluing panels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Light reflecting off end grain differs from light reflecting from flat grain (think light trap if you are into optics). Suppose we have a board where the grain is not parallel to the board surface, as illustrated by this representation

/////////////////,

where the forward slashes are grain orientation along the board edge. When viewed from the right we see light reflected from end grain and flat grain. When viewed from the left we see only flat grain. The appearance, mainly the brightness of the reflected light, will appear different depending on what end the board is viewed from.

We see grain more or less standing on end around knots, in crotches and in curly wood. It is this difference in reflection off the different grain orientations that makes these features stand out and they stand out different depending on the viewing angle.

Suppose we have grain on the edge of two sequentially sawed or sliced boards or veneer oriented /////////. In book matching we flip adjacent pieces with the result that the grain in one piece is ///// and the adjacent piece is \\\\\\. When the assembled pieces are viewed from the end one side will show end grain and the other will not, and visa versa for viewing from the other end. The result will be a discontinuity of brightness at the edge joint when viewed from some angles, for better or worse, depending on your taste. Personally it is a factor that doesn't concern me, which may be a minority view of things.

An alternative to book matching is to edge joint the adjacent pieces so that //// aligns with //// of the mating piece. In practice it becomes a compromise as to which choice looks better in the application at hand for there is an even more apparent appearance consideration .

While these appearance differences with observation angle are significant with what we call figured woods the effect disappears with boards sawed largely parallel to the grain. If the grain of a board lies parallel to the surface the appearance of the surface will be identical when viewed from any orientation. A board whose grain is ====== can be edge joined to another board with grain

====== and there will be no brightness difference observed at the joint.

In edge joining there is an effect more apparent than brightness differences at an edge and that is growth ring mating. In rift cut where the dark lines of the growth rings are largely parallel to the length of the board it is easy to get a nearly invisible joint when rift cut is joined to rift cut. The result is lllllllllllllll. But in flat sawed lumber we can get grain that looks like ((((((( or )))))) when viewed from the face of the board or combinations as we move down the length.

If the grain at an edge is joined to the adjacent board to make a pattern (((.))) where the period is the joint, the effect can be attractive. Grain ///.\\\\ can also be attractive, as well as llll.llll. Most consider other combinations to clash, for example llll.)))) and we try to avoid this combination.

In summary, when edge gluing we need to consider the potential brightness difference that could result at the joint, as well as the attractiveness of the grain match and reach a compromise that suits the builder and customer. Book matching, not book matching and "knife hinge folding" are routes to compromise.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#2

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

Keith Newton

Bill, while I'm not taking issue with any of what you are trying to share, I find it pretty hard to follow, and think you should have tried to use pics instead of all the ////\\\\\\(((()))). Plus there are other pros and cons to any of the choices in other ways, such as raised or recessed glue line if there are any changes in MC later on mostly due to the 2-1 ratio difference in changes relative to tangental or radial ring orientation.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#3

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

Brian Holcombe

Excellent write-up Bill. That is largely the consideration I am to make.

I will add one more qualifier and that is for the maker, it is far less time consuming to plane a board will of the adjacent boards heading in the same direction. If they join up going opposite directions then you will have a spot where the plane effects the two opposing surfaces differently.

It's not a matter of difficultly but instead it will show your planing marks very obviously.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#4

I have never encountered this phenomena

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" such as raised or recessed glue line if there are any changes in MC "

Well let me qualify. If gluing wood not properly dried it can become a problem when the wood dries to ambient conditions. But I have never seen the problem in any commercially prepared panel presumed to be prepared from wood or proper moisture content upon gluing.

The bottom line of panel gluing is to glue for best appearance and forget the fretting over hypothetical factors.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#5

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

Hank Knight

I don't pay a lot of attention to the end grain when I glue up a panel. I worry a lot more about the grain dirction on the "show" surface as Brian discussed. I have found it almost impossible to orient the grain to best advantage on all surfaces of a panel glue-up, and the difficulty increases with the number of boards in the panel. Consequently, the "show" surface gets priority in my shop and everything else falls in behind, for better or worse.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#6

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....you are referring to hand planing panels, which with skill and patience the potential reversed grain of a book matched panel can be handled.

In my experience reversed grain in adjacent boards is usually not a problem with machine planing. However, when it is the result can be tear-out that can be difficult to impossible to correct.

Still yet, I glue for best appearance and hope for the best when planing.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#7

Nor I...

John in NM

I've never even heard of that happening before.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#8

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

Brian Holcombe

Put skill and patience aside for a moment. If you plane a piece of wood one direction, then reverse and plane the opposite direction the wood will look differently from one direction to the other, that is not skill or patience related.

That is a problem with a book matched panel, not a problem of tearout but a problem created by the difficulty of planing one direction all the way up to the glue line, then matching that coming in the opposite direction, and in no case stepping over the glue line which will cause an effect on the look.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#9

Re: Thus the Popularity of the ROS   


Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#10

Re: Thus the Popularity of the ROS

Brian Holcombe

:b

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#11

question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Disclaimer....I am clueless about finish planing surfaces for show where there will be no sanding between planing and finish. So don't underestimate the naivety of the following questions.

1. In almost any sawed board there will be grain reversals along the length of the board and hence along the length of a case top or side panel. Will the effect you speak of not be expressed in planing a single board with its expected grain reversals? As one looks from one end, every grain reversal should show up in the effect you describe. No?

2. Continuing this line of possibly flawed thinking, when one board with grain reversals is edge jointed to another with its grain reversals it seems improbable that all the grain in one board going//// will mate with the neighbor such that its grain going /// will exactly mate or even mate at all, and visa versa. Hence, it would seen that the effect you describe will be present in every edge glued panel, more or less.

3, Book matching does not necessarily or always result in grain sloping in opposite directions at the joint. For the most part flat sawed lumber has the grain running largely parallel to the length of the board. Gluing ==== next to ==== should not express the effect you describe.

4. And finally and related to #3, if /// is joined against \\\\ how much grain angle from exactly parallel to the length of the board does it take for this effect to be noticeable?

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#13

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

don stephan

Minor addition to a very nice writeup. When working with rift and quartersawn lumber, often the line of the growth ring edges is slightly canted relative to the edges of the board. I'll rip a new edge parallel to the growth ring edges, joint smooth, then rip the opposite edge parallel. Can't remember who taught me this trick, but it can go a long way to hide glue joints where both board edges show parallel straight lines.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#14

Re: question

Brian Holcombe

Bill, you must have access to lumber that I do not as I dig through serious amounts of stock to find lumber with the grain running vertically on the sides.

I typically take the best stuff I can find, but that's after digging through stuff that rises or falls over the length of the board, and even then if it's a really good board otherwise I won't eliminate it solely for that.

If the grain reversal happens, you will see it in the finish planing, but it's not abrupt like one would see at a joint.

I plan my joints so that they plane in the same direction generally, and now plan my stock so that I have very very few grain reversals, but otherwise they would show.

You're correct in saying that two board perfectly VG that are book matched will plane the same direction.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#15

Re: question

TomD

I take what Brian says into consideration, and it is partly a furniture thing, but there are other products like curved laminations where it makes sense. On the other hand I lay wood out on large panels to look well, and then do what I have to to get the finish I want.

The reason, Bill, that joints are more of a problem that some other situations, is that grain can be unsupported there. You can have a rising piece that is not continuous over much length including across the joint, so it will tear out where some other similar feature has more continuity.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#16

lumber access

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Normally I do not have available lumber sequentially sawed from a log. It is wasteful to saw a log this way so it is never done unless one is custom sawing a log. Hence, most of us never have the opportunity to deal with a true book match in a panel. To get attractive, largely symmetrical panels I used the "knife hinge" fold it back approach and I get patterns on the panel that look close to book match as seen in the picture.


Walnut has been overharvested for many years. In addition, advances in veneer slicing have enabled mills to utilize logs as small as 14" for veneer. The result is that few large logs ever get turned into lumber that shows up at our local sources of hardwood lumber. Smaller logs are going to yield boards sawed near the center of the tree and that is where knots live. These boards will contain the grain reversals that occur when the tree makes wood around the shed limb. The result will be lumber that may have attractive figure and grain patterns, but it will not be straight grained.

I don't face the matching problem you face because I sand before applying stain and finish. Also, having hung around lumber mills for decades I also have access to lumber most don't.

Re: Appearance in edge gluing panels

#17

Re: lumber access

Brian Holcombe

That is a nice look.

I've gone through enough now that for case goods I go on the hunt for sequenced matched. As I continue I will likely attempt to get full width material if possible.

I'm attempting to move away from walnut as it has become very difficult to find really quality lumber for case goods. There is plenty out there that will make nice tables, but once you need to cut clean joinery into something those same pieces look a little unappealing.