Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Pencil sharpeners

Posts

Pencil sharpeners

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

Pencil sharpeners

Jack Guzman from Maine

Here's a subject I haven't seen here. Most woodworkers use pencils every day. I have a drawer full of #2 pencils and jars around the shop full of all kinds of different pencils. I try to keep a handful sharp but it's hard not having a decent sharpener. I have used carpenter's square pencils,mechanical pencils fat round pencils,etc. I prefer a sharp standard #2 pencil for most things because they are everywhere and I get a nice sharp thin line.To keep getting a thin line you have to sharpen often. I have several old Boston wall crank models but these are old and worn out. Some sharpen off center too much to be useful. Some grind the wood and break off the point. I have tried little battery operated ones and they usually break or the battery cover gets lost. Besides this kind doesn't sharpen to the same taper that I like. I have tried several modern versions of the crank style but all so far I have found have been junk.

What do you all use to sharpen your shop pencils? Is there a quality crank style wall mounted sharpener available? Is there an electric or battery sharpener that sharpens to the same long taper as the old hand crank models?---Jack

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#2

You need an upgrade

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Upgrade to Pentel 205 0.5mm drawing pencils. I have not used a wood pencil in decades for all the reasons you describe. Supplement the pencil with a Pilot fine tip ink pen and the marking needs are met.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#3

Re: You need an upgrade

David Bair

You must have a light touch; I use a .7mm pencil because the .5mm breaks too easily. I know it doesn't seem like much, but that extra .2mm makes a big difference to me.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#4

Yup

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Have two; one in the office, one in the ship. Panasonic "auto-stop". Plug-in not battery.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#5

Re: Pencil sharpeners *LINK*

Stuart Johnson

I like Rockler set with the little sharpener. I usually use it rather dull but if I want a fine line it just takes a second to sharpen. The lead is larger so it isn't breaking as often as the smaller leads.


Rockler Pencil

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#6

Re: You need an upgrade

William Duffield

Pentel make two different leads (at least) for these pencils. They usually pack the cheaper lead with the pencils. I will only use the super hi-polymer lead. It's much tougher.

OTOH, My old Boston KS sharpener works just fine with Ticonderoga pencils. It came with the shop, so it's probably been screwed to the same post for 40 or 50 years. Cheaper pencils don't perform nearly as well.

For heavier lead drafting pencils, I use one of these.

After all that misinformation, what I usually use to mark wood or paper is (thanks to Bill Tindall's recommendation several years ago) black Pilot P500 ball point gel pens. however, they don't work on dark oily stuff like ebony, wenge, and cocobolo. For those, I used soapstone welding pencils, which I sharpen to a wedge point with sand paper.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#7

Not the sharpener

Gary Smyth

If you have any Incra rules, you will have to use the .5mm leads to fit into the laser cut slots. .5mm leads are readily available from any graphics/art supply house. That said, I too often break the mechanical pencil graphite.

I use a Boston (now part of X-ACTO) sharpener almost always. With their spiral cutters, wall mount or suction mount it doesn't matter. They give excellent points on a proper#2.

Where the problem is with a "general use" pencil is that the surrounding wood is not cedar or poor quality and 'the graphite is brittle or placed off center in the making of the pencil. I have approved payment of more than several dozens of replacement pencils from places like Staples, Sam's Club, Office Depot, Office Max and corporate promotion supply stores. My thinking early on was that a #2 is a#2. Many times I was wrong. They bought cheap. I now pay attention to who makes the pencil. Faber-Castell, Dixon/Ticonderoga, Wallace, Sanford Eagle, Staedtler are the ones I've had no reported problem. You don't often buy shop pencils, and they aren't too expensive. Treat them as an expendable but also a tool. Buy the name brand online to get the best deals. The problem is not the Boston sharpener. By the way, they used to have new replacement parts for sale. If you are attached to a particular model contact them.


Re: Pencil sharpeners

#8

Re: Pencil sharpeners

Tony - Memphis

I like the old hand crank models. I bought one on Amazon. I believe Xacto bought the original maker..I'll check....ah yes, they still have it...Xacto KS manual pencil sharpener... less than $10 today. Works great. Gets real good reviews too.

My wife prefers an electric. Bought it on Amazon too, but I don't recall the brand/model. It does a nice job, I just like the old crank.

Tony

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#9

where did you find

Gary Smyth

the sanding discs for the inside? I haven't seen one of those since Bechtel decades ago?

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#10

Re: Pencil sharpeners

John McGaw

I have the old standby Boston sharpener that has been (or at least was) a fixture in every US classroom since before I was born. Mine is probably 30 years old and when presented with good pencils it will produce perfect needle points all day long. When sharpening cheaply-made pencils there is probably no guaranteed way to get good results.

This type of 'shop machine' very handy when it comes to sharpening little dowels to use for plugging unneeded screw holes.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#11

Re: You need an upgrade on lead too

Robin Corell in Atascadero

Same here. Buy some 2B lead and pitch the what comes standard if you have old eyes like me.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#13

pencils

John K Jordan

I use the .7, .5, and .3mm pencils, depending on the use. The .3mm are especially good for marking out fine patterns for chip carving. I mostly use the .5mm and carpenter's pencils at the lathe.

I sharpen carpenter's pencils with a knife.

BTW, I use magnets above the lathe, bandsaw, and other tools to hold pencils. I wrap a few turns of soft iron "bailing wire" around the pencils, sharpies, and other things that don't normally stick to magnets as at the top of this photo:


I've found more things to hold with magnets since I took this picture.

JKJ

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#14

Re: Pencil sharpeners : I have three of them.

CharlieL

All hand cranks, and I believe that they are all old Boston's, one is for a desk top. I also have mechanical pencils, some of the newer ones can leave a very fine line, where the lead is so small that it never needs sharpening.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#15

Jack Guzman from Maine

Good responses

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks for all the input. I am going to try a panasonic electric for now and pay closer attention to brand of pencil. Even the quality ones are cheap enough I don't need to skimp. I didn't know that xacto took over Boston. I think I saw an exacto sharpener at Staples that looked right.---Jack

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#16

Re: You need an upgrade on lead too

ken

I could not continue using 2B pencils for marking any longer,my eyesight isn't that good compared to 2-3 years ago,I could see the pencil lines I mark only if the wood I'm using is light in color but if it's Walnut/or Cherry, forget about it.

What works nowadays is Staedtler 110 Tradition 4B Pencil Black , it is a bit on the soft side so you would need to sharpen it often but the the marking lines are almost as dark as if it was made by a fine tip black magic marker.

I highly recommend the 4B pencils under any brand name but I like Staedtler the best.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#17

Re: Pencil sharpeners *LINK*

walta

For store bought pencils, I use a 6x48 belt sander with a 50 grit belt.

Works great.

For the ruff work I like this pencil .56 mm lead.

Walta


img

Craft supplies

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#18

Here's the best I've used

John in NM


There were a couple of these in the drafting department of a company my dad had in the 1980's - at least one of them is still kicking around my mom's house. I got two more on ebay recently, around $25 (and you can get NOS blade mechanisms there as well).

The clamp on the front grabs the pencil and feeds it into the sharpener, keeping it nice and centered. Works great. Because of the clamp holding the pencil you don't have to mount this one to anything - hold it down with one hand, crank with the other.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#19

Re:  where did you find

William Duffield

Do they wear out? I'm still using the sand paper that came with the pointer I have now.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#20

Am I the only one who'd rather use a pocket knife?

Keith Newton

First let me say, I would rather have a 2.5 rather than a 2 or 3 hardness. But all of you need to try sharpening the point to a flat wedge shape. This allows for a much finer line that will stand more pressure and will hold up longer regardless of the lead hardness.

This should be obvious with the flat carpenters pencils, but it works just as well with any of them. But maybe it isn't that obvious. When the first big-box store came to our town, they offered a big hand held sharpener in bright orange that would put a nice round point on the flat pencils, for those not accustom to working with sharp tools.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#21

Re: Here's the best I've used

Mark Nowicki

Mine is probably just as good , but I don't have the heart to use it :)


Re: Pencil sharpeners

#22

Mark, I believe I have one of those also

CharlieL

It's the one that I was referring to as a desktop unit.

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#23

Come into the 20th Century!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

These days I use 2mm clutch pencils. The ones I prefer are the metal-bodied Caran d'Ache Fixpencil 22. These have become something of a cult as it was the daddy of clutch pencils.



I keep both dark- and white-leaded clutch pencils at the ready. White is especially useful for marking dark woods.

The lead is sharpened with a Gedess Lead Pointer, which I believe once won an award for design in the 1930s. The one I have dates to the 1950s. Insert the pencil and swivel it around the abrasive stone inside.

This combination creates a fine point, one that is easy to maintain.

Recently I managed to repair my father’s electric sharpener. Well electricity is OK here because it is vintage (I’m guessing about 50 years old) and it brings back memories of visiting my dad in his architectural practice when I was a youngster. He used Faber Castell clutch pencils, and the sharpener is made by Faber Castell and constructed of Bakelite … insert the pencil and a pressure point starts the motor, which proceeds to sharpen the pencil.


Note ... pencils are hand tools! :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#24

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

You guys are missing out! *LINK*

Jason Roehl in Lafayette, IN

The link below is similar to a sharpener that my parents have had for probably at least 35 years. My siblings and I will probably fight over it when my parents pass.

It keeps the pencil centered, auto-feeds and doesn't over-sharpen (you can feel the grinding action get easier and lighter as you approach full sharpness).

Jason


Pencil sharpener

Re: Pencil sharpeners

#25

I blame my wife...

John in NM

She works in my shop too when she needs something built and I'm not around (which is most of the time these days). I sharpened pencils for years with a chisel or a pocket knife and she bugged me for years to get a sharpener :D

I also recently grabbed a block plane to sharpen one, since I was up at the house and the sharpener was down at the shop. It worked really well - especially if you enjoy the symmetry of continuing the pencil facets down to the point! :D